Tardis

New to Doctor Who or returning after a break? Check out our guides designed to help you find your way!

READ MORE

Tardis
Tardis
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{Discontinuity}}
 
{{Discontinuity}}
*Not only does the Doctor regenerate, but his clothes do as well.
+
*Not only does the Doctor regenerate, but his clothes do as well.
 
::A side effect of a first regeneration?
 
::A side effect of a first regeneration?
   
 
*A Dalek crashes into a camera in one of the few surviving scenes.
 
*A Dalek crashes into a camera in one of the few surviving scenes.
   
*How do the colonists not recognise the Daleks after the events of ''[[Doomsday]]'' and ''[[Journey's End]]''?
+
*How do the colonists not recognise the Daleks after the events of ''[[Doomsday]]'' and ''[[Journey's End]]''?
:It is revealed in [[The Time Traveller's Almanac]] that the events of [[Bad Wolf (TV story)|Bad Wolf]] / [[The Parting of the Ways]], and therefore all Dalek stories since, didn't "happen" until after [[Dalek]] had "happened". Also, it is speculated that there are two Dalek histories in different timelines. The first ends with the events of [[The Evil of the Daleks]]. The second begins with the [[Fourth Doctor]] interfering in Dalek evolution in [[Genesis of the Daleks]] and includes the events of [[Journey's End]]. The Power of the Daleks may belong to the first timeline, in which case [[Doomsday]] and Journey's End never happened.''
+
:It is revealed in [[The Time Traveller's Almanac]] that the events of [[Bad Wolf (TV story)|Bad Wolf]] / [[The Parting of the Ways]], and therefore all Dalek stories since, didn't "happen" until after [[Dalek]] had "happened". Also, it is speculated that there are two Dalek histories in different timelines. The first ends with the events of [[The Evil of the Daleks]]. The second begins with the [[Fourth Doctor]] interfering in Dalek evolution in [[Genesis of the Daleks]] and includes the events of [[Journey's End]]. The Power of the Daleks may belong to the first timeline, in which case [[Doomsday]] and Journey's End never happened.
 
::Also, now as of [[DW]]: ''[[Victory of the Daleks]]'' it appears Amy Pond does not remember the Daleks, implying the timeline has been messed with at some point, so what this means in relation to these events is yet to be seen.
 
::Also, now as of [[DW]]: ''[[Victory of the Daleks]]'' it appears Amy Pond does not remember the Daleks, implying the timeline has been messed with at some point, so what this means in relation to these events is yet to be seen.
 
::It's pretty well established that even many people from the early/mid 21st century--from Zoe Heriot to Henry van Statten--didn't know about the Daleks. If this does get explained away, it seems likely that people from farther in the future wouldn't know about those events either.
 
::It's pretty well established that even many people from the early/mid 21st century--from Zoe Heriot to Henry van Statten--didn't know about the Daleks. If this does get explained away, it seems likely that people from farther in the future wouldn't know about those events either.
  +
::
  +
* IIRC, Ben says the Doctor was always going on about Daleks before regenerating. But didn't we see mostly every moment of their time together before this, with no mention of Daleks? The War Machines went directly into the Smugglers went directly into the Tenth Planet, right. Apologies if I've gotten show/novelization mixed up.

Revision as of 20:38, 30 August 2010

You are exploring the Discontinuity Index, a place where any details or rumours about unreleased stories are forbidden.
Please discuss only those whole stories which have already been released, and obey our spoiler policy.

This page is for discussing the ways in which The Power of the Daleks doesn't fit well with other DWU narratives. You can also talk about the plot holes that render its own, internal narrative confusing.

Remember, this is a forum, so civil discussion is encouraged. However, please do not sign your posts. Also, keep all posts about the same continuity error under the same bullet point. You can add a new point by typing:

* This is point one.
::This is a counter-argument to point one.
:::This is a counter-argument to the counter-argument above
* This is point two.
::Explanation of point two.
::Further discussion and query of point two.

... and so on. 
  • Not only does the Doctor regenerate, but his clothes do as well.
A side effect of a first regeneration?
  • A Dalek crashes into a camera in one of the few surviving scenes.
  • How do the colonists not recognise the Daleks after the events of Doomsday and Journey's End?
It is revealed in The Time Traveller's Almanac that the events of Bad Wolf / The Parting of the Ways, and therefore all Dalek stories since, didn't "happen" until after Dalek had "happened". Also, it is speculated that there are two Dalek histories in different timelines. The first ends with the events of The Evil of the Daleks. The second begins with the Fourth Doctor interfering in Dalek evolution in Genesis of the Daleks and includes the events of Journey's End. The Power of the Daleks may belong to the first timeline, in which case Doomsday and Journey's End never happened.
Also, now as of DW: Victory of the Daleks it appears Amy Pond does not remember the Daleks, implying the timeline has been messed with at some point, so what this means in relation to these events is yet to be seen.
It's pretty well established that even many people from the early/mid 21st century--from Zoe Heriot to Henry van Statten--didn't know about the Daleks. If this does get explained away, it seems likely that people from farther in the future wouldn't know about those events either.
  • IIRC, Ben says the Doctor was always going on about Daleks before regenerating. But didn't we see mostly every moment of their time together before this, with no mention of Daleks? The War Machines went directly into the Smugglers went directly into the Tenth Planet, right. Apologies if I've gotten show/novelization mixed up.