During the frost fair of 1814, Sutcliffe's men paid Spider and his friends to lure people onto the frozen River Thames to be fed to the creature Sutcliffe's ancestors knew had been trapped under the ice, though the children themselves were unaware of Sutcliffe's true goal.
Spider and his friends would also use the frost fair to con people for money or food. During one such con, his friend Kitty distracted the Twelfth Doctor and Bill Potts by claiming her dog was missing. Spider then crept up from behind and tried to snatch the Doctor's sonic screwdriver, but the alien caught his arm, only for Kitty to kick him in the leg, allowing the two to run and hide. Spider was puzzled at to what the screwdriver actually did, but Kitty assured him it was valuable. The pair soon fled towards their home, but the Doctor and Bill caught up. However, Spider was entranced by the green lights beneath the ice, which proceeded to absorb him below the ice, though not before the Doctor retrieved his sonic.