FANDOM


"Aliens of London dating controversy" is a title based upon conjecture.

Check the behind the scenes section, the revision history and discussion page for additional comments on this article's title.

RealWorld

The Aliens of London dating controversy stems from a narrative feature introduced in the 2005 Doctor Who television story Aliens of London. In that story the Ninth Doctor returns Rose Tyler to her home time one year later than planned, in 2006. Indeed, a missing persons' poster created for that episode states that Rose has been gone since 6 March 2005. Various episodes of Doctor Who and its televised spin-offs that were executive produced by Russell T Davies directly follow from Aliens of London, with multiple successive markings of Christmas Day from The Christmas Invasion (2005) to Voyage of the Damned (2007). The writers of these shows, however, often forget that the contemporary setting is actually a year in the future.

This narrative feature was sometimes forgotten or not applied by some writers, leading to several contradictions.

Towards the end of the Davies era of Doctor Who, no on-screen date is given for the 2009 Easter Special Planet of the Dead, nor The End of Time, which comprises the 2009 Christmas Special and the 2010 New Year's Day Special. [note 1] Planet of the Dead alludes to the real-world liquidation of major Icelandic banks in 2008 and The End of Time shows President Barack Obama making efforts to end "the recession." Early into Steven Moffat's run as executive producer of Doctor Who, Flesh and Stone (2010) directly describes Amy Pond's home time as 2010, synchronising Doctor Who's contemporary stories with their date of broadcast.

The third series of the spin-off series Torchwood synchronised with its year of broadcast, 2009, when in Children of Earth: Day One, a government operative mentions Clement McDonald's name was last active 44 years ago, i.e. when Clement disappeared in 1965, until Torchwood found him living under an alias. As well as this, in Children of Earth: Day Four, Rhys Williams mentions that Jack Harkness' deal with the 456 at that time worked for 44 years.

Contradictory clues Edit

Doctor Who Edit

The Sarah Jane Adventures Edit

Torchwood Edit

Notes Edit

  1. There is a scene near the end of The End of Time set on 1 January 2005; this, however, is clearly from before Rose's travels with the Ninth Doctor, and by extension, any of the John Simm Master's appearances on Earth in the 21st century.
  2. Though the parallel Earth the Preachers are from runs ahead of the normal Earth in later stories, in Rise of the Cybermen (2006), the episode before The Age of Steel, Mickey reads a newspaper dated to 1 February of "this year".
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.