User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-31010985-20190928203157/@comment-28743561-20191013202042

Kaldor City story PROSE: Skulduggery is a valid story on this wiki since the page was made in 2013.

This short story was first published in the 2008 charity anthology Shelf Life It was reprinted in Cosmic Masque issue 3 (December 2016) and later published on the official Kaldor City website. 

While T:VS doesn't allow charity publications, it specifies "Any fiction, by any author, where the copyright holder hasn't given permission isn't allowed." Was this one allowed for having the proper copyright? Because I notice that admins user:Doug86 and user:Shambala108 both edited the page with no scrutiny over it.

Even if we ignore the charity publication, the later publications back it up. Skulduggery gives us a precedent that supports the includion of the three 10,000 Dawns stories.