User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-26285319-20150407171302

Can we get a general consensus whether or not we should include the TV version of Shada as a valid source on this wiki.

I have read other inclusion debates on the subject of Shada, and it is apparent that many people believe the TV version is "canon".

Personally I see no reason why we cannot include all 3 versions as valid sources, as although the original version of Shada was never completed, the intent for it to be broadcast exists. As well as this, all TV stories are definitively "canon" in the DWU, and excluding this on the basis that it was not broadcast is slightly strange.

Even if the entire VHS version cannot be included as a valid source, is it not wise to include the completed extracts from the story, and let the novelisation fill in the gaps?