Forum:Why do prefixes link as they do?

What's the rationale for prefixes not linking to the actual pages for the series which they abbreviate? On MemoryAlpha or the BionicWiki, for instance, when you link to the prefix TNG or SMDM, it takes you to the main page for those two series. It doesn't take you to an intermediate, stubby page that explains what the acronym means. Is there a particular utility to the way we do things here? I'm not sure I see it — especially since we have so many different series to which we link.  Czech Out  ☎ | ✍


 * In some cases the prefix actually stands for a group of similar things such as the DWM and DWMS prefixes stand for both the comics and short stories etc. So linking to the Doctor Who Magazine page wouldn't be an adequate description of what it actually is about. In the case of Memory Alpha the TNG link takes you to the TV series article (but I struggled to find any of the TNG novels, and in the end just searched fir 'novels'). The various prefixes should have links out to the pages like the comics and short stories (I say should because many of the prefix pages are created quickly by various users). --Tangerineduel 14:44, 20 July 2008 (UTC)
 * Cool, thanks for clearing that up. As for your problems with finding novels on MemAlpha, that makes sense, because MemAlpha doesn't cover the nevels with in-universe articles.  They cover the articles only to the extent that they catalogue their existence.  MemAlpha (I think quite wisely) is only for what Paramount considers canon, and therefore considers novels as merchandise, not narrative sources.  They leave it to MemBeta to handle the narrative "history" of those novels, although they do allow some intra-wiki links.   Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  03:17, 21 July 2008 (UTC)
 * Whoa. I think I read ya wrong.  I thought you were saying that the prefixes should link to the main pages, but they haven't because they were a quick and dirty way for the site to be built.  But that's not actually what you said upon a re-read. Are you saying you don't think it's a good idea to make all of them link to the main page, except for those which may be ambiguous?  I can quite understand, for example, of the short stories vs. comics in DWM.   But is there a harm in making TW link to Torchwood or DW link to Doctor Who?   Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  05:26, 21 July 2008 (UTC)


 * Well, there is, as it sort of sends a double message that some links go to the pages and others don't. I think to keep it consistent and logical we should maintain the system we have at the moment, at least right through the prefix system it ad hears to a logic. --Tangerineduel 13:09, 21 July 2008 (UTC)

Eleventh Doctor Adventures
A new concern with this system is what's going to happen once we start getting Eleventh Doctor novels going. Then, EDA will be quite confusing. We might want to start thinking now of how we're going to fix this, as EDA has somewhere between 500 and 1000 entries in its "What links here?" list already. Might I suggest we create new prefixes for these novel ranges using actual numerals? 9DA, 10DA, 11DA, perhaps? And, a simple move isn't going to do the trick, because that'll just leave behind <1000 instances of linked EDAs all over the place, without in any way preventing the further use of that confusing prefix. We're gonna need a bot to clean it all up quickly. If I knew how to write such a bot, I'd take care of it right away, but my skills don't extend that far, I'm afraid.  Czech Out  ☎ | ✍  01:51, 18 April 2009 (UTC)


 * Urgh. Why did this have to become a problem? Well...a 1000 isn't that many things to change. (It's certainly possible, I've done it, all those Unsorted images didn't sort and add templates themselves, it's just mildly mind-numbing to do so).
 * I'd rather not change EDA to 8DA (and the others etc).
 * I don't suppose we could just have 11DA for the Eleventh Doctor Adventures and leave the rest as they are? (I say that with a hopeful tone in my voice).
 * At the moment I can't think of any other alternatives than going for numerals, unless we have a mix of numerals and alphabetical based prefixes. Which would be okay, but not all too logical for EDA/11DA.
 * I also don't have the programming skills to even attempt to create a bot for the task. (But as mentioned it's not a gigantic task, just mildly mind-numbing.) --Tangerineduel 14:40, 18 April 2009 (UTC)