User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-86.174.105.135-20161211174119/@comment-1432718-20161215153120

DENCH-and-PALMER wrote: Amorkuz wrote: Why not use the approach from #1 for #2 also?

No need pal, all invalid doctors are indisputably different, usually why they are invalid.

And alternate are different as well, that's why they're alternate. That's what we're trying to determine here. Stating they all need different pages is just your opinion.

There are a wide range of reasons why a story is invalid, not just because the Doctors are "indisputably different".

And there are tons of alternate universe Doctors that only last for a short time within a story. I don't think we need a separate page for each of them.

That's the whole point of this discussion — that we have too many Doctor pages. We're trying to clean up this mess with some kind of agreed-upon policy.