User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-4028641-20151011010956/@comment-1789834-20151014185028

Despite disputes or debates here, I think we all reach the same conclusion. Some think we're a replacement for Clara. Some think we're a part of his one way conversation. But our joint conclusions seem to be that we have insufficient evidence to simply say, as RogerAckroydLives suggests, that it's an "error". An error that Withouse apparently wrote in knowingly and that Steven Moffat and script editor Nick Lambon went on to allow in the final production... okay then.