User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-1272640-20161223201024/@comment-1272640-20170116230449

OttselSpy25 wrote: Not to mention the fact that there are like three contradicting post-Ainley incarnations.

I still stand by the fact that as the story in-universe only vaguely touches upon his incarnation he's no different from any other one-off Doctor of secondary-stories past. Agreed.

If we really have to treat it as a ninth incarnation, there's always the existence of Grandfather Halfling (who's implied to be the version of the Eighth Doctor who became the Relic, resurrected in the City of the Saved)...