User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-1317169-20130130010742/@comment-188432-20130208234145

I've just checked out the latest change to the Heroes Alliance, and it's still stuck on blogs. Plus, it's giving information that this wiki would consider a spoiler. I think it would be confusing for people to go from this wiki where there are no blogs and where articles about characters from upcoming stories are completely forbidden. It implies that we're cool with revealing that kind of information.

I'll look again next week, but so far this thing has a lot of strikes for me:
 * features blogs, which we don't have
 * immediately exposes our readers to a totally different definition of spoiler
 * links to content that is sometimes graphically violent, far beyond the limits of even what's in Torchwood
 * seems to define each of the three alliances so broadly that there is no definition
 * so far, it stresses the work of Wikia Staff members, rather than the actual local community.
 * gives unrealistic expectations about the way the wiki actually looks