User talk:Gousha

Hellfire Club
Really good work with the Hellfire Club article i must say however please don't relegate Faction Paradox audios to the notes section as this wikia treats them the same way as they do any other Doctor Who related media.

Thanks,-Revanvolatrelundar 10:42, January 1, 2011 (UTC)


 * I was unclear on that. Thanks!  I'll revise accordingly. Gousha 21:49, January 1, 2011 (UTC)

Good work
Hey there, I've enjoyed reading your edits on the Big Finish monthly range. It is a section that is in need of improvement and you have all but completed some of the Eighth Doctor audios. Keep up the good work. --Revan\Talk 09:01, February 5, 2011 (UTC) 16:32: Tue 20 Dec 2011

Songs
I saw absolutely no point in the category for a number of reasons:

1) What category would it fit into? There was none, so you would have had to create more and more categories so the 'stories with songs' would have fitted into a proper category.

2) What did it cover - stories with songs was very, very vague - if someone never knew what it actually meant - they would have added it to every story in which there was a song played - most of these would have been background songs. What would be the point in known this?

3) What else is similar? By creating 'stories with songs', other users would have been inclined to create categories such as 'stories with dancing', 'stories with drinking' and eventually 'stories with talking'.

4) Creating what seemed to be a random category - it could also look like you were trying to score point on the Game of Rassilon - creating random categories just to get point can get yo blocked by the way.

So by creating a category that could not fit into another existing category could therefore result in a lot of similar categories being made, some of which would be ridiculous, vague or pointless.

However, I do like your think - and everything above was not criticism, it was reasoning. I think you are a very good editor and enjoying seeing your work - I just hope that this has not put you off editing or has discourage you in anyway (some users do feel this way). Keep up the good work and do not hesitate to contact me or another admin if you need to ask/anything. Thanks. MM/ Want to talk? 19:27, December 28, 2011 (UTC)

your comments on the blog
Thanks for the kind words.Boblipton talk to me 02:20, December 30, 2011 (UTC)