User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-1272640-20161223201024/@comment-1272640-20161228055213

But back to the main subject - Scream of the Shalka.

1. It's clearly a story. 2. It's certainly licensed. 3. It's a complete serial. 4. It's certainly clear that it was meant to be set in the DWU as it was in 2003. The intention was to make a story about the ninth incarnation of the Doctor. It's the same Doctor as the one from the classic series and the TV movie. A few months later, RTD decides he doesn't like the serial, and decides to ignore it, casting Eccleston as a different Ninth Doctor. Chalk it up to contradictions. Different accounts. But the intent here was to make a story set in the DWU.

This story passes our four little rules with flying colors. The original "decision" wasn't one, just someone throwing something out there, and taking it as valid, with no one debating that story. It was part of the debate on The Infinity Doctors. One person saying something isn't a decision. We, as a community, did not decide as a group to deem this invalid.