Howling:So Rory is dead then

So I take it then now that the Rory we see is a Auton then Rory is dead. I mean when this crack thing is fixed then he will still be dead, so the big bang will probably be other than the odd flashback or other possible doppelganger Rory's last appearance. I mean the only way he can come back is if series five is kinda erased but I dont think Moff will undo the last series. Winehousefan, 20:50, June 18, 2010, [UTC

Well, the Doctor said something about people coming back from the crack if they could be remembered, and now that Amy remembers him because of meeting him and the ring, he might still be in the crack, but be remembered by Amy because of the helpful Auton lookalike. Or something magical and non-sensical could happen and that could mean that he comes back to the universe, back through the crack, and back to life for Series 6. --Halftimelord 21:01, June 19, 2010 (UTC)

Rory remembers when he died. This memory could not have been taken from the house as implied in the episode. Deliberate plot element (a genuine miracle and Rory's reall conciousness has transferred a la Dust (Greg Egan)) or poor scripting? I wouldn't trust Amy's 'memories' at all; they could be false; planted by the Doctor when she was seven. The level of reality of the events we have seen may be variable. Jack Chilli 08:47, June 20, 2010 (UTC)

I couldn't help but notice a similarity between Auton-Rory and Bracewell from Victory of the Daleks. Perhaps Rory will similarly "become human" during The Big Bang? 115.69.5.221 13:47, June 20, 2010 (UTC)

Rory Is dead, otherwise Amy would leave next season to marry him, and I believe Amy has already been confirmed to be returning next season. I believe he will just stay a memory - R 15:05, June 20, 2010 (UTC)

But how did the memory of his death get there? This happened after he left the big house so should not be a construction of the Nestine. His real memories are there and so the plastic Rory is the real Rory after all. He may not survive the Big Bang however. Jack Chilli 14:12, June 20, 2010 (UTC)

I reckon that, in order to save Amy, Auton Rory will hurl himself into a crack, so that he never existed, and therefore could not have shot her, therefore saving her life 17:02, June 20, 2010


 * Remember what The Doctor said in Blink [which Moffat wrote] - "People assume that time is a strict progression of cause to effect, but actually - from a non-linear, non-subjective viewpoint - it's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly... timey wimey... stuff." Ie, removing the cause won't necessarily change the effect. 115.69.5.221 16:37, June 20, 2010 (UTC)

Yes of course that could be how this whole mess gets sorted out as without Amy dead maybe someone can save the doc. Winehousefan, June 20, 2010, [UTC]


 * Or, the Nestene might have the original copy as they did with Mickey. Scary Daleks hovering next to a crack, reaching in to pull something out just moments after the Doctor found his shrapnel? Agonaga 16:10, June 20, 2010 (UTC)
 * Another possibility worth considering, at least in this week between the two episodes, is that Rory was an Auton from the start. It's still possible, at least until The Big Bang airs and tells us the truth, that Rory in The Eleventh Hour was an Auton, that he had grown up in Leadworth with his body subtly manipulated by the Consciousness.  Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  16:19, June 20, 2010 (UTC)
 * Oh, nice. Hadn't thought of that, but wow. That photo of Amy and Rubber Roman Rory got there somehow... and Amy's prepared to destroy any universe that doesn't have him in it. And (filed under 'it fits') the Doctor's "oh so what" attitude about Rory dying, and Rory being alive (and the visual of him pushing Rubber Rory like a weeble-wobble doll) would fit.  Agonaga 16:54, June 20, 2010 (UTC)


 * My impression of that photo was this it's from Amy's normal pre-Doctor time, and is just some sort of fancy-dress party they went to. This also explains why Amy is in her police officer kissogram outfit. 115.69.5.221 16:44, June 20, 2010 (UTC)


 * Yeah, I'm striking out today, because you're right. She liked to make him play dress-up. Agonaga 16:54, June 20, 2010 (UTC)


 * Exceeeeeept... if he'd sent Rory up there to kiss the girl, then Rory and Amy's lips would be two parts of time and space that should never touch, being pressed together. Not even kidding here, I don't think #11 was so distracted that he'd forget the biggest mystery in the universe standing right in front of him with puppy dog eyes. Human or Auton, that kiss would be a paradox. Agonaga 16:38, June 20, 2010 (UTC)


 * I don't think physical contact is important so don't see a significance in the kiss. Memory, the lack of it, love, the loss, regain and re-loss.  These are thematic so are probably more important.  Amy remembers and the world falls to bits. Jack Chilli 18:06, June 20, 2010 (UTC)
 * Ahh, the paradox in her mind being enough, then? Makes enough sense, although the contact of Rose touching Rose (or her clothes) was a big deal in Father's Day.  Just trying to fit-in 'two parts of space and time that should never have touched,' but clearly Big Bang is a better place to expect that. Agonaga 18:21, June 20, 2010 (UTC)
 * Speaking of The Big Bang, in The Lodger, I think it's Craig that mentions 'a big bang' coming from upstairs. Perhaps it's just a co-incidence, but the fact he used those words really stuck out to me. And I can't believe that Moffat would have included this episode without it playing a larger part in the overall series arc, especially with leaving so many questions unanswered regarding the 'upstairs TARDIS'. 115.69.5.221 06:02, June 21, 2010 (UTC)

I've been wracking my brain trying to discover how The Rory Story for episode 12. There are problems no matter what. The reveal that Roman Rory is an Auton means that the Nestene would have to not only have Rory but, according to the Doctor in Rose, have him alive. Three possible explainations for this.
 * 1. Rory wasn't erased from time by the crack but was in fact saved by the Silurians and delivered to the Nestene. This would mean he wasn't killed either because the Nestene Conciousness would need him alive to make an Auton from him.  The biggest problem here is that Amy forgot him which would mean that either this isn't a valid explaination or that Amy is an Evil Alliance of Evil construct and playing along.  I say construct instead of Auton because if she was an Auton previously she would have melted during time travel due to severing communication from the Nestene controlling her.  She would have to be some sort of android like Bracewell.


 * 2. Rory was always a construct of The Evil Alliance of Evil. Again, Rory could not have been an Auton the whole time unless there was a Nestene on board the Tardis in which case The Alliance would have known about River.  The biggest problem here is that if Rory was a construct from the beginning, then why not use another construct instead of an Auton?  They would have to have a valid construct to maintain the Auton anyway.


 * 3. The Doctor was wrong about the Nestene needing a live body. In other words, we've all taken some retcon.  The biggest problem here is that it would be a big cop-out.Psykechan 07:43, June 21, 2010 (UTC)


 * I think it's quite clear that the Nestene doesn't require a living body. It created all the Romans from a picture book. In Rose, the Doctor said that Mickey still being alive 'was always a possibility'. My impression is that it kept Mickey alive so that if the Doctor incapacitated Auton-Mickey, it could make another one. 115.69.5.221 07:55, June 21, 2010 (UTC)

Taking 'the trap' at face value it does not seem as if Rory was part of that plan. A Rory lookey-likey was there because the Nestine used pictures and Rory was from a photograph and it dod not understand the difference between this real person and the Roman book. Luck break. The tranfer of Rorys's memories seems to be a _genuine_ miracle alowed by the fact there was somewhre for his memories to go (Thanks Nestine). Why whould he be in the plan at all? His presence would only lead to trouble and suspicion from the Doctor so I assume he was a mistake. He's not needed at all for the plan to work; any fake Roman would do. Of course now that he is there (was there as the Universe is gone) there may be a glimmer of hope. Jack Chilli.

On the subject of rory always being an auton, this would make alot of sense because, apart from his nurse uniform we mostly see him wearing the same things in every episode, even when he was prepared for rio, this could explain the id controversy aswel the nestene coudl have just made a mistake

Remember it's not just the Nestine. The Daleks can manufacture the artificial personalities memories from people that are not real (Bracewell) and that acounts for the personalities. The nestine just needs to animate the bodies it's made from pictures in the books and that can't be that hard for it I'm not convinced about he need for Rory though. His memories were the real ones and I can't see where they got them from. Genuine miracle? Jack Chilli

Hello people, has it ever occurred to anyone that the psychic link mentioned may come directly from future Amy and not just her room? The Doctor did promised to bring Amy back to 25/6/2010 after all the adventures and the alliance raided Amy's house sometime between 25/6/2010-26/6/2010...Amy could have returned after all the adventures (and got kidnapped by the aliens or even killed as well?) and have the Alliance establish the psychic link at that point...thus Auton Rory remembering the part about Rory's death...as for the complicated time paradox stuff...Let's break it down: 1. The Alliance as a whole has time traveling technology 2. The Alliance planned pretty much everything before The Eleventh Hour in their timeline 3. Cracks can change history 4. Time travellers are unaffected by changes in history if these changes do not tie significantly into their personal timelines Doesn't it all make sense now? The Alliance could create an Auton Rory because Rory wasn't erased in the original timeline on 26/6/2010 and that's the timeline the Alliance traveled to when they raided Amy's house and established the psychic link. (If the Alliance traveled to the timeline that's post-crack-devastated-the-entire-universe, there wouldn't be an Amy's house as everything were erased.) In this timeline, Amy likely returned on 25/6/2010, and the Alliance used her memory to create a trap for the Doctor. As the cracks change the timeline, Amy's memory is changed and thus the psychic link retconned with her memory in the new timeline, thus Rory, which is created from Amy's memory, has his memory retconned to the point of his own death. Auton Rory, who is now living in another time, is existing, thus the photo that the Nestene used as a reference exist because it's tied to Auton Rory's existence despite Rory never existed in the first place. For a cleaner theory, let's just say that the Nestene took the photo and time traveled and decided to put it back out of politeness....203.168.176.42 08:53, June 23, 2010 (UTC)

Except that all reality has been destroyed (and of course always _was_ destroyed so there can be no past or future 'timelines'; no alternate universes to take things from to do things with. Nothing real remains.  Doctor Who is fantasy; not science fiction.  Don't try to explain things rationally; accept that there will be a miracle and all things will work out in the end. Jack.

Hello, time travelers...immune to changes in timeline...the idea's been here since Flesh and Stone....It's simple...it doesn't need miracles...Auton Rory exists due to the exact same reason that Amy remembers those bishops/whatever they are and Doctor remembering Amy and the wedding ring being in the Tardis...The Tardis has/had not been devoured by cracks so it exist despite the original timeline is modified...the Alliance created Rory despite the new timeline is Roryless because they don't belong to the new timeline...You can use miracle to explain everything...but that sort of ruin the point of watching anything on TV...and pretty much everything else...and certainly make going on the forum kind of pointless222.166.181.15 10:34, June 23, 2010 (UTC)

Well time travel is a miracle to start with. It can't be explained (see all the previous attempts here) by rational means and therefore is a miracle. You accept it in every episode I assume. You're using miracles to explain why a miracle is not needed. Rory exists becase they remember him? Didn't the Doctor explain why Amy forgot Rory but not the clerics? If the places that time travelers have been to still exist then why would The aliance be worried? Their places still exists; Skaro is still there so the Daleks should be loving the destruction of all of the non-time travel species. This isn't the removal of all existance that the cracks were supposed to threaten. I'm assuming that when Moffat says that everything is destroyed that's _exacly_ what he means. It's all 'currently' gone. What we will see now are places of imagination and of memory. Meta-fictional worlds. Places where ideas can take on their own life just as was described in The Time of Angels. Discussing miracles of this form is exactly as valid as discussing ones involving time travel. AA Adding psudo-science explanations can be fun (see all of my earlier explanations of paradox and why the Byzantium is still cracshed) but so can discussions about the nature of _story_ and fiction and imagination. Moffat loves the minds and beliefs of children. I hope that the anweer will lie there. Jack Chilli

Time travel is a miracle?!? You just rejected the existence of the entire Sci-fi genre. Theory and miracle are two different things...theory is rational. The thing is, I don't quite understand what it is that you are trying to reject...if it's what I said earlier...then I don't recognize it from what you wrote. The places do not exist, they are wiped from existence...and that has nothing to do with what I said...I think you may be a bit confused. In explaining why Auton Rory has the memory of Rory's death, I am simply putting forward the chronology of when things happen, and you seem to not be able to grasp any of it at all. Let me phrase it this way, in the perspective of the Alliance:

1. The cracks are beginning to appear, stuffs are getting erased

2. Certain time traveling (time-aware) aliens notice this, and starts planning to prevent it after finding out that the Doctor is involved

3. Amy returns from the adventures with the doctor (or not, doesn't really matter)

4. the Alliance uses Amy memory after her return (sometime around 26/6/2010) to create a trap to lure the doctor, Auton Rory is created at this point

5. Auton Rory is placed in 102 AD

6. More and more cracks show up at different points in time, and real Rory gets erased

7. Amy's memory is changed, retconing the psychic link

Thus Auton Rory exists because Auton Rory is not on the timeline that is wiped, and because the psychic link is linked to Amy, who is now synched with the current timeline, his memory retconned to that of Amy's.

What you're thinking is a bit weird...you are thinking that everything is absolute, I guess I'll have to label that hyper-rational...There's really no point in watching the show if you think like that...because you should be watching a blank screen seeing you think that everything is destroyed without any relation to the relative chronological placements of the events. If there is no significance to the chronology of the event then there would be no Alliance, no Doctor, no anything, because you propose that everything is absolute without regard to chronology, so everything before the first episode of Doctor Who even air has already been wiped from existence...222.166.181.90 11:52, June 23, 2010 (UTC)

Wow "Not able to grasp any of it at all?". Seriously? I really think you should take a look at some earlier discussions before you decide on my capability to understand.

Firstly. If all 'sci-fi' is about time travel then I must have been reading a lot mislabelled books over the years.

Secondy. Time travel is not possible. It is a fantasy. We discuss it as though it is possible in the 'whoniverse' and try to rationalise the evenrty that we see despite the clear fact that a lot of stuff is just made up as you go along. It has no long term logic and is often many contradictions. This is why is is a fantasy world not a 'sci fi' one. The science used is not really anywhere near the science of the real world as 'science fiction'. So the time travel works miraculously to us; it is not logical or consistant and, despite some good efforts to rationilase it, it is not always rational. Simplest example of the top of my head: where does the message on Amy's note in the window come from? It's an infamous San Dimas loop(cf. technicolour time machine). Irrational because information comes from 'nowhere'. If you can accept this impossible event then what's you problem with another one?

Thirdy. I addressed transfer of conciousness and memory (by necceccity) earlier: see Greg Egan short story Dust or the novel Permutation City as examples of how this can 'rationally' be explained by scientific ideas that are just a likely as time-travel. Here you will also find mechanisms for constructing real worlds from virtual or potential ones. You should have a read to see if I have managed to grasp it all correctly.

Fourthly: When there is no time there is no chronolgy. How do these real places exist when there is no time and ,of course, never was? You may have your chronology back when the Universe is returned if you like.

Fithly: You've got a 'psychic link' that passes through time and space to a memory of a person that's somehow embedded in Amy's mind. Shes's got a copy of Rory's thoughs in her head? Not miraculous? It's irrational nonsense: fantasy.

Lastly. If you read my earlier posts I explain quite thoroughly that the reality we have seen will be restored along with the chronology and events depicted. I even rationise how and event could have happened such as the CyberKing and now apparntly hasn't. The whole of WHo history is in flux but of course it will 'come back'. Don't confuse the world we live in with the fantasy world of Doctor Who; the programme isn't going to vanish from my memory and every episode retains is 'validity'.

Oh, as and aside, please explain why Rory has any of his real (or fake) memories of the future at all. What's the point of giving him memories that conflict with his current state of existance? How does that fit in with the plan? Jack Chilli 15:04, June 23, 2010 (UTC)


 * As a writer myself, all I can say is that Moff has done a fantastic job, but he may have written himself into a corner with respect to a few details, like Rubber Roman Rory remembering things he ought not. I have a slight worry that 9/10 of the times we've all said "ooh that's gotta be something, because of X" ... we're going to be left in the lurch over those things because Moff only has 45 minutes to resolve this story.  But then again, he's done a great job so far, he might knock all these paradoxes and questions out of the park, and he's pretty certainly going to entertain us. Agonaga 15:14, June 23, 2010 (UTC)
 * You're most likely right but filling in the potential gaps in the plot is fun. Jack Chilli 15:19, June 23, 2010 (UTC)