Howling:On the other hand?

New idea to consider... if Stolen Earth / Journeys End never happened, where is the Doctors cut-off hand from The Christmas Invasion? There wouldn't be a meta-crisis doctor left with Rose in Pete's World and, of course, the Daleks and Davros not genicidedly wiped out. The Doctor knows 'time can be rewritten' so Donna wouldn't have become Doctor Donna and had her memory wiped, etc, etc, etc. Has the hand somehow become River Song, or become someone else and that is the 'Doctor' she killed (presuming we are not being intentionally misdirected by Moffat on this being who she killed of course). Any thoughts ? 86.26.137.154 07:58, May 5, 2010 (UTC)

Don't think about it too hard, the best explanation is timey-wimey. Time can be rewritten, but time travelers are not affected by time being unwritten. It's like when a story is erased, the Doctor's timeline is never affected. This series is full of timey-wimey. Before you mention Amy Pond being a time traveler, she didn't travel until after the crack started miessing with the timeline. If it something is changed after you begin to time travel, you won't be affected and therefore remember the way things were, such as the Doctor. Delton Menace 17:27, May 5, 2010 (UTC)