Board Thread:Inclusion debates/@comment-27280472-20161218221939

Technically the discussion about The Casebook of the Manleigh Halt Irregulars was about the anthology only, not "Manleigh Halt Irregulars" series. I didn't think it mattered, because as far as I knew it was a series-of-one. Apparently I was wrong:

Storyteller is a charity anthology from Obverse books. The contents follow (I've only skimmed the book):


 * Strangers from the Sea — George Mann (Part of his Newbury & Hobbes series, which is involved with Paradox Lost. But that's a conversation for another day, if ever.)
 * Moon Eyes — Stuart Douglas (Featuring the Manleigh Halt Irregulars, and the reason for this post. Seems to obviously pass the four rules.)
 * Grandad with Snails — Nick Campbell
 * Seal Morning — Cody Quijano-Schell
 * Doctor Syn — Ian Potter
 * A Daughter of the Samurai — Andy Smillie
 * The Hanging Tree (no relation) — Cavan Scott
 * Honey in the Horn — Mark Manley
 * The Unicorn Leacock — Orna Petit and Jacqueline Rayner
 * Put Out More Flags — Sarah Hadley
 * Black Mischief — Elizabeth Evershed
 * Harlic – A Story of a Grey Seal — Simon Bucher-Jones
 * The Devil’s Children — Richard Wright

I think Moon Eyes is the only one set in the DWU (ignoring Newbury & Hobbes for simplicity's sake). It's published by Obverse Books, like the Irregulars' previous appearances. I suggest that only Moon Eyes is considered valid, like with The Judgement of Solomon in Decalog 5: Wonders.  