User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-1296654-20200616211544/@comment-1432718-20200616224308

User:Scrooge MacDuck said: "The fact that we keep having new users weirded out by the John and Gillian exception and restarting the old discussion..."

Not just new users, I've been griping about this one for nine years. No matter what has been said in the previous decisions, it is against policy to combine more than one character into a page. Sometimes we do that for obscure characters, or one-off characters, but these guys are companions. User:CzechOut's objections in the previous decisions fail to take into account that someone out there might want to actually fill out each character's biography even more.

Ruling: we will split this page into two separate pages.

Now all that's left is to decide what to name them (see the previous decisions cited above by User:Borisashton for background) and then decide what we need to do for the split and ensuing cleanup.