Talk:Eighth Doctor - Timeline

Dr who refguide
This timeline now has much more content on it than the Drwhorefguide due to the guide failing to update in recent years, shouldn't this be noted on the page e.g. "this timeline has used the basic structure of drwhoreguide in its editing" rather than based upon the refguide? Revanvolatrelundar 17:33, September 14, 2010 (UTC)
 * I don't understand what you're talking about here. Refguide was last updated on 4 Dec 2010, not "years" ago.
 * Yeah, at the time the new short story collections and TV episodes were not updated for a good few months after broadcast/release. I now understand that the guide is still being edited just not so much in the areas I was looking at. I still believe that we should build our timelines upon that of the ref guide because there are certainly flaws in the eighth Doctor's timeline. However talking to you on the matter a few months ago CzechOut I understand that there are many flaws to timelines in general and I'm beginning to support your view of scrapping them. --Revan\Talk 16:20, February 3, 2011 (UTC)