Board Thread:The Panopticon/@comment-26285319-20170104192003/@comment-4028641-20170610140215

I hope it isn't going too far to discuss my thoughts on the problems with how we cover Shalka, amoung other stories. I've been wanting to push this discussion off, but as long as we can agree to only talk about these special "edge-case" stories in this discussion, I'm fine with bringing my points up.

I didn't wa

When this site started up, we started these inclusion debates because, as we saw it, there were only two options to how we could cover each and every story:


 * This story is canon with the BBC television series.


 * This story isn't canon with the BBC television series.

Over the years, this started to change. We eventually started to realise that some stories couldn't be written about even if they were canon. The stageplay version of The Ultimate Adventure is canon, surely? The VHS Tom Baker into version of Shada is surely canon. Yet both of these stories eventually came to break our rules. And so we stopped