User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-1506468-20190827123101/@comment-28743561-20190911223150

Let's keep this simple.

Which rule of T:VS is not being met by these three stories? Is it rule 3?: "A story must be officially released to be valid"?

I see nothing in that requirement that says valid stories cannot be published by James Wylder of Arcbeatle Press of "CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform".

ISBNs are irrelevant for the digitally released stories in question, so discussion on the ISBNs of 10,000 Dawns books not in question is not relevant information.