User talk:PaulMcGannIsAwesome11777

Just to clarify, it was The Master (First Frontier) who appeared in Happy Endings, he is described in the novel as being the same incarnation who appeared in First Frontier and NOT the corpse Master from Dust Breeding, which was written around 7 years after Happy Endings. Revanvolatrelundar 12:14, December 11, 2010 (UTC)

Canon
Please note that Canon does not exist on this wikia as all stories are treated as canonical in some shape or form. Also please do not add opinions or speculation on articles as you have done with the Eighth Doctor page, as this is and saying things are not canon treated as vandalism on this wikia. Revanvolatrelundar 16:16, December 12, 2010 (UTC)

Eighth Doctor's Regeneration
There is NO definitive source for how the Eighth Doctor regenerated, Clives website is mainly based on the view of other who did not understand the concept of what regeneration is. I cant even remember it actually having anything about the Eighth Doctor regenerating just the 9th Dr in 8th's clothes.

"Everyone knows The Eighth Doctor's death was caused by an explosion, the fiery cataclysm of The Time War, the Time Lords, the Daleks, they all burned," this is just speculation that MAY be correct, there has been no story that explicitly stated that the Eighth Doctor was present at final end of the Time War and the best source we have on it is The Forgotten which gives no definitive ruling on what truly happened to the Doctor in the War, just that he was going to use the De-Mat Gun at one point.

This wikia is based upon SOLID FACTS and theory just doesnt belong here, on the forums fine but not on articles. The best info we have on the Eigthh Doctor's regeneration is there on the page now as it IS unknown exactly how he regenerated, we only have knowledge on what happened some time BEFORE and some time AFTER it happened. Revanvolatrelundar 10:03, December 20, 2010 (UTC)

RE: Regeneration and canony stuff
I never said the Time War didn't cause his regeneration in fact The Forgotten explicitly states that the Time War was the cause of his regeneration but it did not state that he was exterminated or the actual specific cause; the Time War is a general statement. I have read that quote from Clive's website before and it does suggest that he regenerated after or at the end of the War, but there is also the possiblity that this happened during the Time War as well, leaving a wide range of possibilities to exactly when it happened and why.

Also about the Stop the Pigeon thing, we dont know if that story was set in an alternate universe, it could be that it is set in the mainstream universe and that First Frontier and Dust Breeding are the ones that are set in an alternate universe, therefore we cannot say on the article that it is set in an alternate universe as we do not know for certain that it is. Revanvolatrelundar 11:31, December 20, 2010 (UTC)