Talk:A Christmas Carol

I'm surprised this site doesn't have the 2010 Christmas special page up, which I'm told is going to be entited "A Christmas Carol."

Should all the Blackadder connections really be on here. This page is about the version written by Charles Dickens. The Blackadder special wasn't even really the same story, since Blackadder saw his ancestors and descendants instead of himself, and learned to be mean instead of nice. For most of them, we are saying that an actor who appeared in a spoof of Doctor Who also appeared in a spoof of A Christmas Carol, when we should just be listing actors who have actually been in Doctor Who and A Christmas Carol. If we consider every story that is loosely based on A Christmas Carol to count, then every actor in the next Christmas special would have to be listed on here.Icecreamdif 18:57, December 4, 2010 (UTC)

Shocking and shameful
I come here for all information Doctor Who. However, you do not even have a page dedicated to the Christmas Special to air in 17 days. I do not foresee the BBC 1.)Changing the title of the story between now and airtime 2.)Changing the plot with a whole new plot. 3.)Changing anything they have CONFIRMED thus far. These were previous arguments presented for not having pages on previous episodes. Whatever, moderator or tyrant you have running this is someone who should NOT have his or her position. To say you are a index file or source of what is Doctor Who is false if you do not cover anything CONFIRMED. I am not saying to have rumors spoilers speculations and the like but have the FACTS please.


 * Yeah...get over it. It's how they work, and if you don't like it, then go away. I would also like a 'Christmas Carol' page, considering how it is really hypocritical for them to have a page full of speculation for a series half a year away, but not even allow the idea of a page for confirmed info, but I can't really do anything about it. -- Bold  Clone  03:51, December 9, 2010 (UTC)

How very childish of you
To be rude and nasty and then say you want the same thing. To tell me to go away and gt over it when you clearly state you feel the same way. I do not have to go away. It is not your site. I certainly will get over it when I feel like it. You do what you want sir and I shall continue to do what I please as well.
 * You're being obnoxious and pugnacious. Please stop being so rude and others will likely begin to treat you better. If you want to be treated nicely, treat others nicely first. Common sense. I wanted the page, but was not going to trash-talk others to get attention. This isn't your site either, and so it would be wise of you to not whine about whatever doesn't fit your desires. Thank you.
 * However, since the page has been made, I would rather just drop whatever the issue is and see if you could just speak with whomever's in charge about the 'future content' policy. -- Bold  Clone  17:12, December 16, 2010 (UTC)

In reply to your once again rude retort
"Yeah...get over it. It's how they work, and if you don't like it, then go away" No where in my OP was I anywhere rude as your first line to me.

"If you want to be treated nicely, treat others nicely first. Common sense" you obviously do not practice what you preach sir.

"You're being obnoxious and pugnacious." So anyone who doesnt word everything exactly how you view it is being what you stated? Again very childish and rude of you.

" This isn't your site either, and so it would be wise of you to not whine about whatever doesn't fit your desires." In my OP i stated facts and reasoning. Just because it wasnt how you said it doesnt automatically make it whining. Too many of the youth these days like to automatically tag any argument or complaint as "whining". Also do not tell me what to do is wise of me to do or not do. It sounds like you have a god complex or overego.

"Thank you." Your very welcome.

"However, since the page has been made, I would rather just drop whatever the issue is and see if you could just speak with whomever's in charge about the 'future content' policy" Now if you had said this it owuld have been perfectly fine from the get go. Instead you resorted to rude and boorish behaviour.

Please rethink how you address people even though its just internet folks rude is still rude. I am always the gentleman but I have a right to state what I feel strongly about and I had done it in a none rude not in a bad attitude way.


 * Whatever, moderator or tyrant you have running this is someone who should NOT have his or her position. To say you are a index file or source of what is Doctor Who is false if you do not cover anything CONFIRMED. That is being rude.
 * you obviously do not practice what you preach sir. You were not being nice to anyone, so there was no reason for me to be nice to you; confronting your rudeness with harshness.
 * You were being childishly pugnacious and obnoxious to anyone reading your comment, and particularly the site staff. And for the record, I agreed with you. I was just willing to be polite about it, unlike you.
 * In my OP i stated facts and reasoning. Liar. You were hostile and insulting. You were basically whining because there wasn't a page that you wanted.
 * Also do not tell me what to do is wise of me to do or not do. It sounds like you have a god complex or overego. Right...it is not wise to insult others. Just telling you that. I am perfectly fine, and think that you should take a break before coming back to insult me. Again, just get over it. You were slapping others in the face, and now you're whine that I slapped you in the face. If you can't take it, then don't dish it out. Thank you. -- Bold  Clone  02:40, December 20, 2010 (UTC)