User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-24894325-20161008100044/@comment-6032121-20181006193305

I'd support either. I think it does seem like individual incarnation pages are as accurate for the Eleven as for the Doctor, but another way to look at it would be that the way we do the Doctor isn't a logical consequence of his characteristics but just for out-of-universe convenience, as a special exception to the normal rules.

Amorkuz wrote: Procedural note: as rightfully pointed out by OncomingStorm12th at Talk:The Eleven, the scarcity of information is not a concern at all. Pages can be created with the bare minimum, as long as there is a valid story behind.

Can they? Because I believe the suggestion of an individual page for Professor Yana (which would seem to logically follow from the precedent of "John Smith (Tenth Doctor") was rejected twice on the basis that there wasn't enough info about him to justify a page.