Howling:Amy's childhood (with the cracks)

Okay, there's one thing I've been thinking about and would like to know what others say. The Doctor said Amy's life didn't make sense. Fair enough. But did Aunt Sharon actually live with her in the timeline with the cracks? Or, was the reason she was all alone at home at night because it was her house, but not Aunt Sharon's? I mean, her parents were taken out of time, but she still existed (the erasing from cracks is delightfully screwy in that way). So was her house still her house, and Aunt Sharon never lived with her? Sure, it's totally wrong for a child to be living alone, but would the cracks lead to a lack of ability to perceive that?

Against the arguement of separate living is Sharon speaking to the mental health professionals. For it is that Amy is in the same house both ways. And that she still lived there as an adult with no indications of Aunt Sharon being there. And she is still in the same bedroom (the child bedroom?) even as an adult.

Just an idea.

207.171.251.170 18:35, July 5, 2010 (UTC)


 * 1) Aunt Sharon lives with Amelia; it was shown in the finale.

When Amy's parents were erased, it was her and Aunt Sharron living in the house alone. Sharron at least had been there for most of Amy's life, but it seems that during Amy's adulthood, either Aunt Sharron moved to another house, or was, too, erased, without afrfecting the consequences, such as her making Amy see psychaticsts, ect.. In the finale, the Doctor commented on her empty the house was and how everyone who lived there was gone, aside from Amy. He said the crack ate away at Amy's life, meaning that, one-by-one, her family dissapeared until it was only her lfet in the house.
 * 1) the cracks only erase and don't retcon...whatever's deleted from the timeline never existed but the timeline itself doesn't work around it and make any attempt to mend the gaps...they also only affect what's afterward but not before, that's why Post-Cracks Amy can exist without having parents....Similarly, that's why they were still involved in the Silurian incident despite that Rory never existed203.168.176.42 00:31, July 6, 2010 (UTC)

Delton Menace 18:19, July 6, 2010 (UTC)

But the events of The Eleventh Hour don't support that. When the doctor says 'You were a child five minutes ago'. Amy replies 'You sound like my aunt.' The implication is that she still has an aunt. And we see her aunt in her childhood taking her to the museum and with the psychiatrist - events which come after the night when the doctor either did or didn't crash the Tardis in her garden. So where was Aunt Sharon on that night? This was not explained satisfactorily and I, for one, was disappointed that the finale offered no explanation for that. I was expecting Aunt Sharon to have a more significant role at the end and consider this to be a plothole.86.190.57.165 21:26, July 6, 2010 (UTC)