The Girl Who Died (TV story)

 was the fifth episode of the ninth series of Doctor Who produced by BBC Wales. It was the first part of the 100th story of Doctor Who since its revival in 2005.

The story was notable for revealing the origins of the Twelfth Doctor's face: he had unknowingly taken on the likeness of Lobus Caecilius, a man whose life the Tenth Doctor had saved. This marked the first time Doctor Who had given an explanation for the Doctor being played by an actor who had previously played a different role in the series. Colin Baker, who first portrayed the Time Lord Maxil, later went on to portray the Sixth Doctor; however, in this instance it was never explained in-universe why the Sixth Doctor had taken on Maxil's appearance, or if the likeness was deliberate.

Synopsis
Captured by Vikings, the Doctor and Clara must help protect their village from a deadly warrior race: the Mire. Outnumbered and outgunned, their fate seems inevitable. So why is the Doctor so preoccupied with a single Viking girl?

Plot
Clara is floating in space, calling the TARDIS for a pickup. However, the Doctor is busy trying to resolve a conflict, and is having trouble locking on to her location. Clara then notices that something is in her spacesuit; the Doctor suggests it's a Love Sprite, a parasite that eats brains from out of the mouth, hence the name. To help the Doctor locate her, Clara lists the four most interesting stars she can see: two whisky-coloured stars below a blue one and a green wing-shaped nebula.

Within moments of the Love Sprite getting too close to Clara's head, the Doctor materializes the TARDIS around her and takes off her helmet. The Doctor chases the creature, squashing it under-foot. Clara wonders how they did, to which the Doctor says he just saved an entire planet by transporting their attackers half-way across the galaxy and draining their weapons systems; not to mention saving a school teacher from suffocating/having her brain eaten.

The Doctor decides to land the TARDIS to clean his boot in the grass; he steps outside into a forest, bracing himself against a tree as he wipes the Love Sprite off his boot. Clara wonders what's to stop the aliens from attacking again, to which the Doctor says "nothing. At least this time, they'll be ready for them." He explains that as time travelers, it's okay to make ripples, not tidal waves; Clara laughs, calling him a tidal wave. Realizing that was a jinx, he retorts not to say that.

At that moment, they find swords pointed at them. The Doctor moans about not being in the mood for vikings, who surround them. The leader tells the Doctor that he and Clara are coming with them. Filled with his usual confidence/arrogance, the Doctor puts on his sonic sunglasses, gloating that what he wears on his face is technology the human race will never create in billions of years. Unimpressed, the leader simply takes the sonic and breaks them in half. Seeing that he should have had a backup plan, the Doctor flatly tells Clara that they're going with the vikings.

Two days later, the Doctor and Clara are dragged by the vikings back to their village, enchained. For the last two days, which was spent on a rowboat, the Doctor has been lying to Clara about having a plan, to keep her calm. However, Clara has traveled with him long enough to know when he's lying. The leader gifts a girl named Ashildr with the right half of the Doctor's sonic sunglasses; she seems to think it's a weird eye patch. Clara wonders if the Doctor has a plan now, to which he says is the usual - "find the boss man, replace him"; he recites Clarke's Law to Clara, who wonders "is it going to be the yo-yo again?" To her surprise, she finds the Doctor has already freed himself of his cuffs using what he calls "magic".

The lead viking addresses his father, whom the Doctor takes to be the village leader. Tossing his yo-yo at the viking, the Doctor is met with blades pointed at him. The Doctor loudly declares that he's cross with the vikings and that he's very, very disappointed in them; he tells them that he's taken human form to walk among them. When a villager asks for his identity, the Doctor tosses his yo-yo upwards, yelling "Surely, you would recognize the sign of Odin." The vikings declare that the Doctor is not Odin and the yo-yo is not Odin's sign, to which he asks if they have actually met Odin and know what he looks like. As if responding to the Doctor's words, what seems to be Odin's face appears in the sky. Odin declares that the day of reward has come for the villagers; the Doctor yells "Do not believe this impostor" as he fails at a yo-yo trick, embarrassing himself.

Odin declares the best warriors will dine with him in Valhalla. Clara wonders if its really Odin, to which the Doctor says "he doesn't even have a yo-yo" - no, it's not Odin, just a more convincing fake. Armored aliens teleport down, and begin scanning the villagers. They teleport away the strongest warriors. The Doctor explains that they're not invading, but harvesting; children and the weak will be left behind. Though an outraged Clara wants to stop them, a rational Doctor informs her that they need to avoid being chosen as well. Ignoring him, Clara rushes over to Ashildr, whom she instructs on how to use the sonic sunglasses to unlock her cuffs. Unfortunately, once their advanced tech is noticed, they are both teleported to a ship hidden behind Odin's projection.

On board the ship, Clara notices that her cuffs are gone and that the warriors are impatient to meet Odin. The leader tries opening a door in front of them, succeeding only to be zapped into dust in the next room. A wall begins pushing everyone into the chamber, despite their best efforts to jam it with their blades. Clara and Ashildr manage to open the door on the other end of the chamber, barely escaping the next zap that reduces the other warriors to dust as well. They come face-to-face with "Odin", whom Clara knows is an alien; he spared them because they had technology not belonging to this planet's time zone, and the fact Clara is in a spacesuit. "Odin" downs a green vial of liquid made from the warriors' adrenaline and testosterone;

On Earth, Ashildr's father, Einarr, notices that all the chosen went willingly to Valhalla, while another says he wouldn't due to fearing heights. Annoyed at their stupidity and superstitions, the Doctor tells them that homo sapiens are an intelligent species, so they should stop lying to themselves; they just got raided. Einarr tells the "false Odin" to choose his words carefully, to which the Doctor admits that he lied, but "the big fella in the sky" lied too "because what's the one thing Gods never do? Gods never show up!" When the Doctor says he lost someone important, Einarr retorts that he did as well.

Clara is puzzled as to why aliens traveled to Earth to "mash up" some vikings for "warrior juice". She asks "Odin" why he played God to vikings, to which he says there's always some kind of "farmer" that "cattle" will respond to; however, Clara calls him a thief caught in the act. Ashildr is bewildered by what little she can understand of the conversation. Clara asks "Odin" to go seek warriors on other planets to use for his sustenance as "the universe is full of testosterone; believe me, it's unbearable." However, at the mention of not wanting to start a war, Ashildr buts in, declaring war on the aliens. "Odin" is happy to hear combat will take place as talk is for cowards; he says ten of his warriors will attack at this time tomorrow. Clara wonders why "Odin" is doing this as he was about to leave peacefully; he responds that it is for "the joy of war"; his species live for the battle. He then removes his hologram face, to show how happy he is. Ashildr is left shocked that she has declared war on a monster.

Back in the village, the Doctor reads his 2000 Year Diary, learning the aliens are the Mire, who leave others alone if they get what they want; they are a deadly warrior race, like the Sontarans. Clara returns at that moment, explaining Ashildr's blunder. The Doctor tries explaining that the best option for the villagers is to run, since the Mire will give up on trying to kill them if they hide out for about a week. However, he fails due to their pride; upon hearing a baby's cries, which the Doctor can understand as words, he decides to stay and teach the villagers basic combat. He nicknames them as he hates to waste time learning names. Unfortunately, they are too blundering or questioning to be properly trained, resulting in accidents. Clara tells the Doctor to stop playing soldier and start looking for what he's missing - how he's going to win - because he always finds it at the last minute.

The Doctor comes across Ashildr, who is fighting a puppet of Odin. Ashilder explains she makes puppets and comes up with stories whenever the raiding parties head out, believing the right story will ensure their safety. She further elaborates about never really fitting in with boys or girls, due to not being girly and being a girl in this era limits her options. Her father "Chuckles" consoles her, to which the Doctor allows them privacy. However, he then notices "Lofty" is stealing the baby. Ashildr explains it's Lofty's child; he takes her to the boathouse to see the fish when she won't settle.; the Doctor immediately realizes why, calling for Clara as he rushes to the boathouse. The Doctor examines the buckets as Clara enters; she wonders if he got his hand stuck in something again because he's yelling. The Doctor explains he's found what he's missing and that no-one told them they had "fire in the water" - electric eels; telling Chuckles to inform everyone that bedtime is canceled, the Doctor goes on to announce "There's going to be a war tomorrow. This just in: we're going to win the Hell out of it!"

They spend the entire night prepping for battle; the Doctor tells the group that they should look happier than their enemies as its assures winning and to always walk briskly as it makes them moving targets. Among the various items mentioned for the plan are anvils and the silver wiring from Clara's spacesuit. After the prep-work is done, the Doctor explains the plan - if they can get him a helmet from a Mire soldier, this entire thing is over; they can mop up the rest with Ashildr's monstrosity. The moment it's unveiled, Clara points out its ridiculous, to which the Doctor smirks "I know".

The next day "Odin" arrives with some of his men, they enter a barn, where the Doctor, Clara and the villagers are all dancing and having fun. When Odin points out that it's time to fight, the Doctor says they decided to have a party and there's not a single weapon in the barn. "Odin", desiring a fight, threatens to kill everyone. During this time, Lofty has been tossing rings on the Mire suits, failing are six; the Mire are briefly startled. On the Doctor's cue, Chuckles startles a bucket of eels; their electric charge is channeled into the barn by the wiring taken from Clara's spacesuit, rendering six of the Mire suits immobile. The villagers run out as the Doctor cues Chuckles to startle the next bucket, which turns an anvil hanging above the Mire into a magnet that takes their helmets and blasters.

Yelling for the magnet to be turned off, the Doctor takes a helmet, while Clara takes a blaster to hold the Mire at bay. The Doctor quickly gives the helmet to Ashildr, who uses the visual link to trick them into thinking a puppet of a sea monster is a real one attacking them. All but "Odin" teleport back to the ship. Ending the ruse, the Doctor shows "Odin" the recording of this embarrassment on Clara's phone, which has been made funnier by adding the Benny Hill Theme; he threatens to upload it to the Galactic Hub (and thus ruin the Mire's reputation) if they don't leave peacefully. "Odin" threatens the Doctor's actions will not go unpunished, but is teleported back to his ship by the Doctor, who hacked the system. Without any further conflict, the Mire leave the Earth. The villagers rejoice in their victory.

However, the Doctor discovers that using the Mire helmet has drained Ashildr's heart, leaving her dead. The Doctor is left brooding about the loss, with Clara trying to comfort him, saying he couldn't save her. He snaps back, saying he can do anything, but the Laws of Time prevent him from doing so. Looking at his reflection, the Doctor suddenly remembers back to when he first saw it, wondering once more "who frowned me this face?" It's at that moment that the memory comes back to him; Donna Noble had encouraged him to always try to at least save someone even in a fixed point, and he saved Lobus Caecilius' family from Pompeii's destruction. He tells Clara that he chose this face to remember to always save someone, no matter how impossible or wrong it seemed. The Doctor then yells to the sky:

"I'm the Doctor, and I save people. And if anyone happens to be listening, anyone with some kind of a problem with that, to hell with you!".

He takes a chip from the helmet and rushes over to Ashildr's corpse. He places on her head and activates it, bringing her back to life; it's the medical kit for the Mire soldiers. The Doctor gives her father a second chip, telling him it's for whoever she wants; he explains to Clara that the kit would likely keep repairing her, preventing Ashildr from dying. The second chip is to prevent her from being alone for eternity.

Returning to the TARDIS, the Doctor is left wondering if he did the right thing; when he's emotional, he makes mistakes. And he sure as hell was emotional just now. Clara assures him everything will be fine, because what he did was born of good intentions. Brooding again, the Doctor says: "time will tell, it always does." However, he then realizes that his actions have turned Ashildr into a hybrid.

Ashildr is then seen in a montage of time passing her by, but with age never affecting her. As the screen pulls into her face, she is shown to have stopped smiling, her smile being replaced with a grim stare...

Cast

 * The Doctor - Peter Capaldi
 * Clara - Jenna Coleman
 * Ashildr - Maisie Williams
 * Odin - David Schofield
 * Nollarr - Simon Lipkin
 * Chuckles - Ian Conningham
 * Lofty - Tom Stourton
 * Limpy - Alastair Parker
 * Hasten - Murray McArthur
 * Heidi - Barnaby Kay

Uncredited

 * Mire - Jon Davey

The Doctor

 * The Doctors reads his Two Thousand Year Diary to remind himself of the Mire.
 * The Doctor implies that he is immortal.

Clara

 * Clara finds herself floating space after working in a mine and picking up a love sprite.
 * Clara has wielded a sword in battle. The Doctor's reaction to her indication of this hints that he may not have been aware.

Individuals

 * Heidi has Haemophobia, which he later "upgrades" to a fear of even the mention of blood.

Species

 * A Love Sprite within Clara's space suit nearly kills her.
 * The Vikings use electric eels to defeat the Mire.
 * The Doctor aids Velosians in a war.
 * The Mire feed on adrenaline and testosterone.

Technology

 * A Viking snaps the sonic sunglasses in half. They still seem to function, at least to a degree.
 * The Mire possess spaceships which have extracting rooms.
 * Clara teaches one of the townspeople how to use her iPhone to record "Odin" whilst retreating from the image of a sea serpent.
 * The Doctor uses a Mire repair kit to "repair" Ashildr.
 * The Doctor threatens to upload Clara's video of "Odin" to the Galactic Hub.

Popular culture

 * The Doctor gives a bearded Viking the nickname of "ZZ Top", another "Noggin the Nog", and he names a third after the children's book character "Heidi".
 * Clara adds a piece of music she calls "The Benny Hill Theme" to the video of the Mire's defeat.

Story notes

 * This story features the use of footage from The Fires of Pompeii and Deep Breath when the Twelfth Doctor finally realises where he got his face.
 * This is the 100th story of the BBC Wales era of Doctor Who.
 * This is the third episode in a row in which the Cloister Bell rings, the first time this has happened on the show.
 * The FX shot of Clara floating in space was seen in the "Next Time" trailer at the end of Before the Flood where it was shown in an incomplete state. The shot as seen in the episode itself is complete.
 * Brian Blessed was originally cast as "Odin", but had to drop out due to illness.
 * The Radio Times programme listing was accompanied by a small colour head-and-shoulders shot of Ashildr dressed in armour during the Battle of Agincourt, as seen in flashback during the following episode, The Woman Who Lived, with the accompanying caption "Doctor Who / 8.20 p.m. / Viking girl Ashildr (Maisie Williams) becomes the focus of the Doctor's attention".

Ratings

 * BBC One overnight: 4.85 million
 * BBC America overnight: to be added
 * UK final ratings: 6.56 million

Filming locations
to be added

Production errors
to be added

Continuity

 * The Doctor attempts to use his sonic sunglasses (TV: The Magician's Apprentice et al), only to have them abruptly destroyed, much like the sonic screwdrivers (TV: The Visitation).
 * The Doctor and his companions previously tried to resolve conflicts peacefully, only to have their efforts made pointless. (TV: The Poison Sky, Cold War, etc)
 * The Doctor attempts to "reverse the polarity of the neutron flow," a statement he used often during his third incarnation, and would occasionally be used by later incarnations. (TV: The Sea Devils et.al.)
 * The Doctor is able to speak Baby. (TV: A Good Man Goes to War, Closing Time)
 * The Sixth Doctor had previously wanted to save someone because he grew to like her, though on that occasion Evelyn Smythe stopped him from changing history to do it. (AUDIO: Arrangements for War)
 * The Doctor tries to pass himself off as the head god of a religion. In his first incarnation, he was mistaken for Zeus by companion Katarina and others. (TV: The Myth Makers)
 * The Doctor uses his yo-yo. (TV: Robot et.al.)
 * The Doctor reads his Two Thousand Year Diary. He previously read his Five Hundred Year Diary (TV: The Tomb of the Cybermen et.al.) and his Nine Hundred Year Diary. (TV: Doctor Who)
 * The Seventh Doctor also referred to Clarke's Law. (TV: Battlefield)
 * The Cloister Bell rings. (TV: Logopolis et.al.)
 * Clara once again wears one of the Doctor's orange spacesuits (TV: Kill the Moon) This suit is later destroyed for its components.
 * The Doctor states that he's not a hugger (TV: Deep Breath et.al.) before initiating a hug anyway (TV: The Magician's Apprentice).
 * The Doctor had previously wondered where he had gotten his face, and had theorised he was trying to tell himself something. (TV: Deep Breath) He finally realises his face matches that of Lobus Caecilius and that the message he was telling himself was to save a person, even if it meant breaking the rules of time. (TV: The Fires of Pompeii)
 * Upon thinking about how Ashildr's situation will play out now that she is functionally immortal, the Doctor says, "Time will tell. It always does." His seventh incarnation said this to Ace when she hesitantly asked if they "did good" after the Shoreditch Incident, aware that their victory over the Daleks came at the expense of many lives. (TV: Remembrance of the Daleks)
 * The Doctor states that Ashildr is immortal "barring accidents," echoing a statement he previously made in reference to the Time Lords. (TV: The War Games)
 * The Third Doctor had previously met the real Odin. (PROSE: The Spear of Destiny)
 * The Eighth Doctor had previously given someone immortality while saving their life. (COMIC: The Road to Hell)
 * Captain Jack Harkness also became immortal after he was brought back to life, in that case by Rose Tyler. (TV: The Parting of the Ways)
 * The Doctor previously met Vikings in his first incarnation. (TV: The Time Meddler)
 * The Doctor demonstrates his skill at swordplay. The First, Third, Fourth and Tenth Doctors also demonstrated this. (TV: The Crusade, The Sea Devils, The Masque of Mandragora, The Androids of Tara, The Christmas Invasion) The Twelfth Doctor previously engaged in a sword fight with Robin Hood, on that occasion using a spoon rather than an actual sword. (TV: Robot of Sherwood)
 * The Doctor recently had to forcefully stop Mason Bennett from trying to save Alice O'Donnell from being slain by the Fisher King to avoid altering history. (TV: Before the Flood)
 * The Doctor worries that saving Ashildr's life will have a negative effect on time, and that he did it because he had gotten emotional. In his tenth incarnation, he interfered with a fixed point in time (TV: The Waters of Mars), as River Song also did, and ended up causing more harm than good in altering the flow of history. (TV: The Wedding of River Song) Both of theses instances were influenced by putting their own personal feelings above the consequences of their actions.
 * Odin compares himself and the Vikings he killed to a farmer and his cattle, just like Miss Kizlet did with the Great Intelligence and the human minds it captured. (TV: The Bells of Saint John)
 * The Doctor notes how small changes in the course of time can go from ripples to tidal waves. In his seventh incarnation, he once made a similar comparison to the consequences of choices individuals make, saying, "Every great decision creates ripples, like a huge boulder dropped in a lake. The ripples merge, rebound off the banks in unforeseeable ways. The heavier the decision, the larger the waves, the more uncertain the consequences." (TV: Remembrance of the Daleks) The Doctor had also recently compared changing time to ripples in a pond in TV: Before the Flood.
 * Hybrids are mentioned, in this case Ashildr. (TV: The Magician's Apprentice/The Witch's Familiar)
 * Clara and the Doctor argue over his notion that he has a "duty of care" to look out for her. (TV: Under the Lake)
 * Clara affectionately strokes the Doctor's face. The Eleventh Doctor was known to do this on occasion (TV: Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS) and the Twelfth Doctor also previously did this with Clara in COMIC: Four Doctors.

DVD releases
The Girl Who Died was released on DVD as part of "Doctor Who: Series 9, Part 1" on November 2 in region 2 and November 3 in region 1.

Blu-ray releases
to be added