Board Thread:The Panopticon/@comment-188432-20130129081336/@comment-4028641-20130129173957

No, common sense should not prevail.

We know they are somehow "the same". Despite what some people seem to have presumed, there is no indication that she has the same memories, or that she isn't just one of those "coincidences" mentioned in The Pandorica Opens. She could like Scaroth, and be the same person. But we don't know. She could just be part of the whole "Gwen Cooper" time-family thingy. We don't know. She could just be part of the Blackadder dynasty. But We Don't Know. So the only logical solution to do until we find out if she is or isn't literally "the same person" is to keep the pages seperate.