User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-4028641-20151008023030/@comment-27343779-20191104221723

I'm genuinely interested in the subject as a whole and not against making a new thread about it or try and discuss it with each other on our own talk pages if you wish.

Maybe we have one on this very subject in september 2015 (by going through the page history) given that it was apparently decided that we don't explicitely put Delgado as being the 13th despite Legacy of the Daleks anymore at the time.

Back to the OP topic: should we keep Delgado separated from the crispy husk one(s) in the Master Stories template which is a real world section and not an in-universe one?

I see three sensible options so that we don't lose information:

1) We keep the distinction as it is as of now (other unrelated changes not withstanding):
 * Early
 * Dreyfus
 * Delgado
 * Pratt
 * Ainley
 * "John Smith"
 * VNA
 * Roberts
 * Mastermind
 * Macqueen
 * Titan
 * Jacobi
 * Simm
 * Gomez
 * unclear (tipple, ...)
 * AU
 * Kisgart
 * Inferno
 * NOTVALID

2) We put them like I proposed already above, with Beevers distinct from Delgado and all his attempts at prolonging life as being subsections (following what appears to be the way BF see it but which you don't seem to agree with due to the apparent conflict with John Peel's book)


 * Early
 * Dreyfus
 * Delgado
 * Beevers
 * Pratt
 * Ainley
 * VNA
 * Roberts
 * Macqueen
 * Titan
 * Jacobi
 * Simm
 * Gomez
 * unclear (Tipple ...)
 * AU
 * Kisgart
 * Inferno
 * NOTVALID

3) We put ALL the Beevers and Pratt stories in the Incarnation unclear section because of the conflict between some accounts. Would that be ok with you?


 * Early
 * Dreyfus
 * Delgado
 * Macqueen
 * Titan
 * Jacobi
 * Simm
 * Gomez
 * unclear
 * Pratt
 * Ainley
 * "John Smith"
 * VNA
 * Roberts
 * Mastermind
 * Others (Tipple, ...)
 * AU
 * Kisgart
 * Inferno
 * NOTVALID