User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-121.45.54.78-20130925110520/@comment-1827503-20140513204400

Re: Billie Piper in TDOTD

Piper is credited as "Rose" in TDOTD, whereas she was credited as "Rose Tyler" in her other appearances. However, it is not unusual for a character to be credited under another name in a return appearance. If the interpretation stated by CzechOut two and a half months ago were to be applied to the entire wiki, The End of Time would not be listed as an appearance for Martha Jones, because Freema Agyeman was credited as "Martha Smith-Jones".

It is true Rose Tyler did not appear in TDOTD, but it is also true that Piper was credited as "Rose". I propose completely eliminating the credits as a means for determining appearances in televised stories, and instead judging on whether new footage was filmed or previously-unseen footage used.