Howling:Eleventh is Leaving

Matt Smith is leaving. Opinions? - User:StevieGLiverpool
 * Please sign your name with four of these things: ~ instead of just typing it out. It shows not just your name but also the date, which is helpful for other users. Thanks!


 * Also, for everyone who posts in this thread, do NOT post this info in any way on the main wiki namespace. It will result in a permanent ban.


 * OK, the boring stuff out of the way, I think it's about time. One of the things I like best about the show is the constant change in Doctor/companions. As much as I like the Fourth Doctor and Third Doctors, by the end of their runs I was ready for someone new.


 * My only concern is who will Moffat choose for the next Doctor. I'd prefer it be someone in their thirties or forties, and preferably not a major star like Daniel Radcliffe, for example, whose name has apparently come up before. Shambala108 ☎  23:24, June 1, 2013 (UTC)

I second that. We've had some younger Doctors, now time to switch it up a bit with somebody older. Not too old (I don't think somebody around 1 or 3's age would work as well in the show as it is now), but enough to give some contrast. Also, I like it when they don't choose somebody overly well-known. If they get Daniel Radcliffe in, sorry, but I won't be able to see him as anyone other than Harry Potter. But it's deffinitely time to change. I just hope they don't announce when beforehand, so we can have some surprise! Imamadmad (Contact me) 01:32, June 2, 2013 (UTC)

I thought I had read that he signed through 2014. I never knew if that meant inclusively or not. Apparently, now we know! Yes, I too, would really struggle seeing Radcliffe as The Doctor.Boss MD ☎  01:53, June 2, 2013 (UTC)

The last time they decided to look for someone older, they ended up choosing Matt Smith! Other things being equal, older -- but not too much older -- would be a good idea. I also agree that it ought to be someone not closely identified with another role. That wouldn't necessarily mean avoiding "big names", only avoiding anyone who's known primarily for a single character.

This time, it looks as if we'll get a regeneration with a companion who already knows about it, since Clara has seen the Doctor's various incarnations & she's not likely to leave after only half a series. Unless there's another new companion (possible, if additional to Clara), Moffat will have managed to avoid the "Are you really the Doctor?" routine entirely. If there were a new (second) companion, it could be left to Clara to do most of the explaining -- especially if regeneration trauma puts the Doctor out of action for a while. That might be quite fun. --89.241.74.205talk to me 02:19, June 2, 2013 (UTC)

Although I'm REALLY sad about Matt Smith leaving (11 is my Doctor), I am interested to see who they cast next. Of course Benedict Cumberbatch crossed my mind first, but given how menacing he managed to be in the new Star Trek, I think he might make a better Master. If they were to go older, I think David Thewlis would make an interesting choice. Memnarc ☎  02:30, June 2, 2013 (UTC)

You never know, Moffat might get really adventurous & cast a woman. Any good ideas for that eventuality? --89.241.74.205talk to me 02:45, June 2, 2013 (UTC)

Well, Moffat did write the Curse of Fatal Death, and later used references from that in his later episodes. And whilst I trust his judgement, at least casting-wise, I don't think others would be ready for it, and it might seem like a bit of a gimmick for publicity, as would casting "known" actors. If I could decide right now, I'd have Damien Maloney from Being Human, but I saw a clip of the rumoured Ben Daniels, and all I could remember thinking was "Oh, he's GOOD!" Either way, both are older than Matt Smith, which is really the only way go. If we keep getting younger, it'll start getting weird. Gallifrey102 ☎  13:31, June 2, 2013 (UTC)

Gallifrey102: What do you mean "start getting weird"?

More seriously, if Moffat (or his successors) were to wait until "others would be ready for it", casting a woman will never happen. Yes, that or casting "known" actors might seem like a bit of a gimmick but, if the actor (of either sex) is good, that'd be forgotten very quickly. --89.240.253.132talk to me 14:03, June 2, 2013 (UTC)
 * Well, last night, I felt like someone had punched me in the gut. Just two weeks ago, the media reported (in detail) how Smith had signed on for Series 8 and he even discussed the production schedule and when filming would likely begin. So, either:


 * a) The whole article was fabricated by the reporter,
 * b) Smith intentionally was misleading people, or
 * c) Smith changed his mind at the last minute, before his contract was signed.


 * None of these options are great. But I don't know how that article from mid-May can just be explained away. I know I certainly used it to defend my position against people who were predicting a regeneration in the near future. I just feel like the rug was pulled out from under viewers and it's remarkable to me how cheerful Steven Moffat and Jenna are, like it wasn't a surprise to them at all. That might be understandable if it just wasn't for that damn article! How could Smith go on the record and say all of that?


 * As for future Doctors, I'd love for Felicia Day to be cast. She's got geek cred, she can act, she's a redhead, in the right age range...the only negative is that I don't know if Moffat would hire an American to play The Doctor. 63.143.221.134talk to me 18:46, June 2, 2013 (UTC)