Silence in the Library (TV story)

"4022 saved, no survivors"

- Strackman Lux

Synopsis
One hundred years ago, the universe's greatest library was sealed off, leaving only an enigmatic warning: "Count the shadows". But now, the shadows are moving again. The Doctor and Donna must uncover the terrible truth behind the Nodes and the Data Ghosts, to find The Library's secret, and on the way they try to avoid the Vashta Nerada, piranhas of the air, shadows that melt the flesh.

Plot
A little girl seems to be going through a therapeutic session with psychologist named Doctor Moon. She reveals that she has a Library, a whole world, which she sees whenever she closes her eyes. The Library is a world, home to every book ever written, powered by the most powerful computer ever. It is a peaceful place; entirely empty of human life... but suddenly the girl's imaginary world is interrupted by the arrival of two mysterious strangers.

The Doctor and Donna arrive, in the 51st century, on a planet-sized book repository simply called "The Library". Though the Doctor has received a message for help on his psychic paper, and though the Library's computers claim over "a million million lifeforms" are present, they find the Library deserted. A Node, a statue with a strangely realistic human face, warns them to beware the shadows... just as the lights begin to go out around them. The travellers race through the Library stacks, eventually finding a central room that is well lit. As they try to figure out more about the Node's enigmatic warning, they encounter a team of explorers led by archeologist River Song. Professor Song explains that she and her team are there with Mr. Strackman Lux (whose family had built the Library) to learn why the Library has been sealed for the last one hundred years.

The Doctor quickly organises the team to make sure the area is well lit as he explains that the shadows are occupied by the Vashta Nerada, microscopic carnivorous creatures that use shadows to hunt and latch onto their prey. The team works to find a way out of the library. However, Mr. Lux's assistant, Ms. Evangelista, wanders off and falls prey to the Vashta Nerada, her body eaten away in seconds. The Doctor and Donna learn that the exploration team each wears a communication device which has a glitch called "Data Ghosting" where a copy of a person's consciousness is temporarily held within it for a short time after death, allowing them to communicate briefly with the living.

Professor Song's behaviour throughout is markedly curious. First, she appears to know the Doctor quite well, though from some point in his own personal future. She carries a diary that seems to be about the Doctor's life with a cover that looks like his TARDIS, and she possesses a more rugged version of the Doctor's sonic screwdriver, which she claims was a gift from the Doctor himself. Also, when the Doctor mentions Donna's name, she knows her surname and seems shocked that its her, when Donna asks her if she travelled with the Doctor then why doesn't he know her, River goes silent.

The young girl who dreams of the Library, meanwhile, sees the team through the eyes of a security camera when they first break into central room; later, they appear on her television as the Doctor attempts to hack the Library computers... and when she fiddles with the television's remote, she causes events to occur in the Library. The girl is under observation from Dr. Moon, a child psychologist, at the request of her dad, but Dr. Moon appears to have significant knowledge of the situation of the Doctor, Donna, and the exploration team. He reveals that her reality is an illusion, that her nightmares are reality, and that only she can save all the people trapped in the Library. The final mystery appears to be the word "CAL" that appears at times on the Library screens, the Doctor wondering who or what that means.

The team's investigation is interrupted when the pilot Dave acquires an extra shadow. The Vashta Nerada have attached themselves to him, and though the Doctor attempts to save him, he is quickly eaten away, the organisms taking control of his suit. Dave's Data Ghost echoes his last thoughts as the suit approaches the rest of the team. The Doctor attempts to teleport Donna back to the TARDIS while he leads the rest of the team to safety, but something goes wrong in the teleport and Donna fails to materialize properly. As the team races away from the possessed suit, the Doctor is horrified to find a Node with Donna's face on it... which claims that Donna has left the Library and has been "saved".

Cast

 * The Doctor - David Tennant
 * Donna Noble - Catherine Tate
 * River Song - Alex Kingston
 * The Girl - Eve Newton
 * Doctor Moon - Colin Salmon
 * Strackman Lux - Steve Pemberton
 * Proper Dave - Harry Peacock
 * Other Dave - O-T Fagbenle
 * Anita - Jessika Williams
 * Miss Evangelista - Talulah Riley
 * Jelivia Lux - Mark Dexter
 * 710/aqua - Sarah Niles
 * Node - Joshua Dallas

Production crew
to be added

Story notes

 * Transmission of this episode was delayed by one week due to the Eurovision Song Contest, as was the case with the Series 3 gap between The Lazarus Experiment and 42.
 * According to Russell T Davies this episode is more frightening than Steven Moffat's series 3 episode Blink, which rated a 5.5 out of 5 on the official Doctor Who website 'Fear Factor' feature.
 * While the Doctor is hacking into Girl's TV she is watching the CBBC show Pedro and Frankesheep which makes it the second time in this series someone has been watching a real-life kids show after The Doctor watching Tommy Zoom in The Poison Sky and the third since the series revival.
 * Professor River Song mentions having "been to the End of the Universe" with the Doctor.
 * Excluding the Children in Need specials, this is the 50th episode of Doctor Who since the series returned in 2005.
 * Steve Pemberton is the second of the League of Gentlemen to appear in Doctor Who, the other being Mark Gatiss who appeared in The Lazarus Experiment as Richard Lazarus.
 * When The Girl collapses due to the Doctor's tampering with the security camera, the pattern of the rug she collapses on is the same as the red pattern on the computer screens reading "Access Denied". It also can be briefly seen on the lens cap of the security camera, and repeated in the metalwork in the background of the circular room much of the library scenes take place in.
 * Additionally, when Doctor Moon and her father rush to her side when she collapses, a plastic tag reading "CAL" can be briefly seen on Doctor Moon's briefcase.
 * The security camera appears to have angel wings carved on its sides.
 * Steven Moffat continues his theme of highlighting childhood fears. In Blink it was statues coming to life, in The Girl in the Fireplace it was monsters under the bed, and in The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances, the fear of war and bombardment.
 * Talulah Riley is the second major cast member of the 2005 film Pride & Prejudice to be featured in a Steven Moffat story, the first being Carey Mulligan in Blink.
 * The spoilers theme may be an in-joke about DW spoilers (especially online).
 * Professor Song says to the Doctor, with astonishment, "you're so young!", which implies that the Doctor will live long enough to make his present age of 900+ years seem young in comparison.
 * She also says, "going by your face, I'd say it's early days for you, yeah?" which may imply that their relationship begins when he still has the same face, i.e. is still in his tenth incarnation. If this is true, then his tenth incarnation may be exceptionally long-lived.
 * There is, perhaps, unintentional irony to the Doctor's line, "No, I never land on Sundays. Sundays are boring." David Tennant was himself born on a Sunday. Given that Saturdays are "good", according to The Stolen Earth, it could also be a reference to the fact that, to kids, the day after a new episode of Doctor Who is broadcast is comparatively boring. It is important to note that companion Ace mentioned that she found Sundays boring in Survival.
 * The Library's front desk looks like a redecorated version of a control consle from The Sontaran Stratagem/The Poison Sky.

Ratings

 * Official BARB - 6.27 million viewers

Myths and rumours

 * The mystery of River Song led to much online fan speculation over her identity. Possibilities cited ranged from River being an iteration of Bernice Summerfield (as the two share similar personalities and are both space archeologists) to a disguised Time Lord like Romana.
 * Evangelista's last words have occasionally been misinterpreted as "I scream." On the official BBC subtitling, her final words are, "I... Ice cream. Ice cream." Which is in keeping with her (initially) childlike demeanour.

Filming Locations

 * The main library scenes for the episode were filmed at Swansea Library and Brangwyn Hall, Swansea.

Discontinuity, Plot Holes, Errors

 * When standing on the balcony upon entrance, the Doctor remarks on how, being near the equator, they must be in or near the Biography section, though when the screen pans down, a Traffic sign can be seen with a marking to the left with the Words Xenobiology. It also had "Art" underneath it, both with arrows pointing to the left. It could be biographies of xenobioligists and artists, there are probably tonnes of them by the far flung future.
 * At the beginning when we see the Doctor and Donna enter the room from the little girl's point of view we see the door is kicked multiplied times before they enter however when we see it from the Doctor and Donna's point of view we see Donna kicks it once before entering. The Doctor tries to open it without the Sonic Screwdriver before Donna Kicks it open.[Although the screwdriver would probably not make the door look like it is being kicked.]
 * The keyboards on the computer terminals in the library are, in fact, the latest incarnation of Apple Computer's Bluetooth keyboard. Are they? That's nice. Don't see any problem in that, due to the fact that Apple seem to be doing very well for themselves. Maybe it's popular for old keyboards in future libraries.
 * Despite the Doctor stressing to the entire team about not staying in the shadows, all but one are standing blatantly in the shade when talking to the already-dead Miss Evangelista. This is revealed from a downwards shot on the team, with the ray of light almost completely neglected as protection. The Vashta Nerada probably were probably feeling a little sick after just haven eaten for the first time in decades.
 * The Doctor receives a message on the psychic paper which shows up and he shows it to Donna. Donna takes it from him and shows it to him but it is now blank. This has happened a lot of times on the series, and can be interpreted as a feature of the psychic paper
 * Also in this shot when Donna holds the psychic paper the green screen can be seen behind the books.
 * After Proper Dave has been turned into the suit creature, the green lights on his comm system are no longer on, even though Dave's Data Ghost is still talking. The vashta narada are learning to use his voice, making it unclear if it is really still his data ghost at that point.
 * After the shot where in Proper Dave is seen to have two shadows, there is a short shot from a different camera angle where in the Doctor passes Dave his helmet. In this short shot, Dave is seen to have but one shadow. When the shot returns to the previous camera, Dave has two shadows, as before.
 * When the Doctor and group are talking to the little girl on her TV you can see them all standing around the console but when the shot pulls back and they all back away from the console you can see that half of them have changed positions. Mr Lux, Proper Dave, Anita and Miss Evangelista have all changed from their positions seen on the tv to when you cut to the group.
 * Also Donna who is clearly close to the Doctor's right is not shown leaning to look into the console but jumps back like everyone else as if she had been looking into it.
 * How does River Song recognise the tenth Doctor? The tenth Doctor changes his appearance to the eleventh Doctor (as confirmed in the fifth series). River does mention that the Doctor's appearence is 'young' but not different. However, River does discover that the Doctor is an earlier form of himself than the Doctor she tried to contact and that is why he does not recognise her but surely she should know that already seeing that his appearance would be different to the Doctor she would have known. The tenth doctor still has not regenerated, meaning he has all the time between now and his next regeneration to meet River. Furthermore, in the original series those that knew certain Time Lords well were able to recognize them even after multiple regenerations. If River Song deeply loved the Doctor one might assume she recognized before she noticed his age or even his previous regeneration. There are a remarkable number of point when the Tenth Doctor is without a companion for an unspecified period of time; between Runaway Bride and Smith & Jones, Voyage of the Damned and Partners in Crime, Journey's End and The Next Doctor, The Next Doctor and Planet of the Dead, Planet of the Dead and The Waters of Mars, and presumably The Waters of Mars and the 2009 Christmas Specials. Travels with River Song could have happened at any of these points after Journey's End. This is similar to the situation with Elizabeth I.
 * The Doctor claims that he never lands on Sundays, Sundays are boring. Yet the entire novel TDA:Wetworld is set on a planet named Sunday. Does this mean the novel can't be canon? The Doctor stating he finds a particular day boring has absolutely no impact whatsover on whether or not he had an adventure on a planet of the same name.
 * The message on the psychic paper doesn't say the time or date that the Doctor should land in the Library so how does he manage to arrive a few minutes before River Song arrived? Additionally how does he know to land in the section that she will arrive in?

Continuity

 * A similar species which could take over the light but weren't hostile were the Cimmerians in the BFA: Embrace the Darkness.


 * As shown on the BBC Doctor Who website, there are a number of books in the library that reference previous episodes. Those seen are the operating manual for the TARDIS, Origins of the Universe (DW: Destiny of the Daleks), The French Revolution (DW: An Unearthly Child), the Journal of Impossible Things (DW: Human Nature (TV story)/The Family of Blood), The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (written by Douglas Adams, former Doctor Who writer and script editor), Everest in Easy Stages (DW: The Creature from the Pit) and Black Orchid (a book first seen in the Fifth Doctor serial DW: of the same name).
 * The Doctor makes mention of 'Emergency Program One' which would return Donna home, this was first seen and used in DW: The Parting of the Ways.
 * The last time the Doctor received a message on his psychic paper was in DW: New Earth.
 * This is the second time the Doctor has arrived 'too early' (or rather the TARDIS has brought him too early), this previously occured in DW: The Doctor's Daughter.
 * The Doctor once again expresses his affinity for little gift shops of the type found in museums and hospitals, having mentioned them in DW: Smith and Jones and DW: New Earth
 * The previous episode ended with the Doctor showing a traditional paper-bound book dating from the far future, a thematic lead-in to this visit to the library (although dialogue indicates that he and Donna were originally travelling elsewhere).
 * River Song, although she never comfirms it, appears to know about Donnas memory loss at the end of Series 4.
 * On the little Girl's wall are 2 Drawings: A blond & a Wolf.This is a sign of Rose's return as Blond(the colour of Rose's hair) & (Bad Wolf

DVD and other releases

 * Released in the Series 4 DVD boxset in November 2008 along with the rest of the Series.
 * Released as Series 4 Volume 3 in a vanilla edition alongside Forest of the Dead and Midnight.