User talk:Mini-mitch/Archive Talk 8

'''Please do not comment on this pages, as I won't read any comments that are on this page. Please leave comments on my other talk page.'''

20:07: Tue 20 Dec 2011

commas
We seem to be having a wrangle about commas. In particular, you seem intent on making sure that commas appear in places where they are not optional (as they may be when preceeding "and"; I cut those out anyway unless they are mandatory) but others in which you think they mark off a subordinate clause -- which, if they were, would be mandatory. However, your analysis is wrong.

In particular, in the article on Julie Legrand, you have

Julie Legrand played the Partisan in the Doctor Who story, The End of Time.

It's a fairly subtle point, but The End of Time is not a subordinate clause which further defines the preceding. This can be better appreciated by removing it.

Julie Legrand played the Partisan in the Doctor Who story.

This sentence is nonsense. It leaves you hanging for definition, because there is no item which can reasonably be called "the Doctor Who story." I think you have confused this with what would have happened had the indefinite article been used. Had the sentence read

Julie Legrand played the Partisan in a Doctor Who story, The End of Time.

You can remove the clause and still have a meanginful, if vague sentence. This difference renders the phrase a subordinate clause.

Anyway, I am going to leave this particular article alone until the normal course of events (hitting it on the random button or noticing that it has recently been edited a lot and so may need a cleanup) brings it to my attention again to give you a chance to think about this. Sorry to lecture a fellow decent writer -- it embarasses me to do so -- but we seem to be working at cross purposes here. Boblipton talk to me 14:10, December 22, 2011 (UTC)

Uncat images
I actually want to wait until 31 December to do the next clean, precisely because I'm expecting an influx of new, unlicensed images.

However, earlier today, I made some changes that might stem the tide of unlicensed images. Open an edit window and hit the add photo button on the right. You'll see much clearer instructions.

Oh, also, preloads work again, though I'm still tinkerin' just a bit. 18:54: Fri 23 Dec 2011

Tree
Was there something wrong with my picture of trees?

The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe
So were not allowed print screens with the BBC logo on them? Clone gunner commander jedi

Adminship
Hello, Mini-mitch, with my greatest copliments, I woul like too become an admin, for mostly, improving this Wiki. (Please note that I know how to work being an admin, I'm the only on Just William Wiki!) Metardis talk to me 14:05, December 26, 2011 (UTC)

Hi, in the reply you sent me, just now I realised that after I made the mistakes on policies I got blocked for 24 hours. I'm trying not to make this mean, regards - Metardis talk to me 08:44, December 27, 2011 (UTC)

is it all right?
me again, is it all right if I archive your reply and then ask User:Tangerineduel if I can be one? Also, do you leave nonimations on the talk page of the link you sent me, or on the page? Metardis talk to me 14:26, December 26, 2011 (UTC)

Outnumbered
Shouldn't Category:Actors who appeared in the Outnumbered franchise be Category: Actors who appeared in Outnumbered? It's not a franchise, as it consists of the original TV show and nothing else. No spin-offs, no video games, no merchandise, no other media except for DVD releases. Digifiend 00:35, December 27, 2011 (UTC)

Images
I'm sorry for the Pictures. There were none I could find without the logo's.

Songs category deleted
I created a new Category:Stories with songs, which you promptly deleted. I'd love to know why. Did I miss a policy somewhere? -- Gousha talk to me 19:15, December 28, 2011 (UTC)

Thank you for the explanation. My intent was to have a category for those stories where there's singing involved, but I also quickly realized it could be diluted with background songs. I didn't have a good solution for that. I'll endeavour to put more thought into any new categories in the future. -- Gousha talk to me 21:03, December 28, 2011 (UTC)

Brilliant Books
Thanks. I've gotten through all of the 2012 pages except The Moon, and I plan to tackle 2011 the next few days.

On a side note, I see you've deleted a few pages that were 100% based off of the book, but wouldn't it be better to keep them under the "Non-canon" category? Like we've done The Master (Scream of the Shalka) and Splinx? Just to expand the wiki to its limits, if nothing else. Thanks for the help! OS25 (talk to me.) 01:18, December 30, 2011 (UTC)

Category creation
You seem to be in a "Category: Actors who appeared in XXX" mood. While some of the elder ones seem to have little in the way of linkage to Doctor Who apart from the fact that busy supporting actors turn up everywhere, most do have some "stickiness". Could you explain your criteria for these new categories? Boblipton talk to me 00:41, December 31, 2011 (UTC)

Images
I got a message from you about a week ago regarding the images I uploaded, and that they had to be deleted due to having network logos on them, though I've seen Loads of images on different pages on this wiki which have network logos on them, though they weren't deleted! So how come only mine were Deleted??!!

Re: Reply
What About These Then: http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/File:Sky_shark.jpg http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/File:Vlcsnap-2011-10-19-11h36m53s1.png

Sock puppetry
Ask Wikia to do what's called a "CheckUser" report, providing the names/IP addys of the users in question. 14:04: Tue 03 Jan 2012

16:04: Mon 09 Jan 2012

Lee Johnson
Why has the artwork for The Wedding of River Song been removed from the 'Lee Johnson' page?

Ravalox talk to me 16:53, January 10, 2012 (UTC)Ravalox

Stop
I wasn't ignoring you. I simply hadn't looked at my talk page yet. Once I had noticed your message, I did stop, thank you very much, and plan to follow your advice. The only reason that I edited Dancing the Code again is that you reversed some of the edits which weren't related to the setting part of the infobox.

GusF talk to me 20:42, January 11, 2012 (UTC)

can you delete the category I just made?
Hi. I know this would be a bit of bother, but could you delete Category:Real world musicians whose work appears in Big Finish audios? I made it and thought there would be some pages that linked. Thanks. !Ṃě ṭáṛ  đί  'Ṣ'!    at   

--Tangerineduel / talk 14:21, January 16, 2012 (UTC)

Sock puppet
Just go to Special:Contact, navigate to any of the choices that give you a free-form input box to fill out, and ask them to run a CheckUser report on the account(s) you suspect to be the same. 02:27: Thu 19 Jan 2012

Be judicious with pic deletion
I again urge you to read T:IUP UNUSED. Our rules, which do come from community discussion, clearly establish that a picture should not be deleted simply because it's unused. I've pointed this out to you before and yet you still appear to be basing many of your deletion decisions solely on their presence on Special:UnusedFiles.

I again remind you that a number of pictures which I upload are not obviously linked. I try my best to make it clear in revision notes, protection rationales, and upload notes that these pictures will appear to be unlinked. I know you started some kind of page where you link some of these pages, but it is not my job to remember to make a link on that page. T:IUP UNUSED makes it very clear that it is the job of the deleting admin to carefully assess the situation on each picture.

It's unlikely that you carefully assessed the situation at file:zeroroom.png before you deleted it. It had several notes in several places showing that it was a file in current use. Because you deleted it, I had to take the time to restore it, and to go back into the CSS and change the URL. When you restore a pic, it's always at a different URL than before the deletion occurred. So it's not as simple as just restoring a file. I have to do additional work when I restore a file used by CSS.

Special:UnusedFiles is a useful tool, but it is not a list of files that need to be deleted. It's a list of files which do not meet the criteria of being "used". That doesn't mean they won't be in the future, or that they aren't being used in a non-traditional way. Remember, too, that Special:UnusedFiles uses cached results. Consequently, files can appear on the list which actually are currently linked. The linkage simply may have occurred after the report was generated. 02:16: Tue 24 Jan 2012

Doctor Who minis - reference site
Hi,

I've recently updated the Doctor Who miniatures section over at the Lost Minis Wiki (http://www.miniatures-workshop.com/lostminiswiki/index.php?title=Category:Doctor_Who).

I'd very much appreciate any feedback on missing figures/manufacturers. Also if you have any of these miniatures and could contribute a missing or better picture* then please go ahead (or send me the file). I'm also looking for catalogs, magazines and adverts showing these at the time of production (Jpgs or PDFs preferred).

I hope you find the section informative and useful. Thanks for looking and please pass this on to anyone else you know who may be interested.

regards

Andrew (Tiki Gamer @Lost Minis Wiki)

* ps. on pictures they must be photographs you own/have the rights to contribute.

23:49: Fri 27 Jan 2012

X Century individuals
So, it's less about common sense (i.e. this person didn't just spring out of the ground) and more about categorizing them based on our perceptions of them through the show? Memnarc talk to me 23:37, January 29, 2012 (UTC)

Allies and enemies
I've started a discussion Forum:What makes an ally and an enemy?. I didn't include companions in this discussion as any discussion of companions would quickly wash out any discussion there, we've also got several previous discussions concerning what makes a companion, so those would need summarising and looking at before we look at starting another discussion. Thanks. --Tangerineduel / talk 13:28, January 31, 2012 (UTC)

Look,
Look, I wasn't archiving things I didn't like. I felt my talk page was a bit big, so I thought it wouldn't do any harm to make an archive.

Nonsense categories
I wasn't aware that the category had been deleted before. I simply saw that Let's Kill Hitler was tagged with it and wanted to expand on it. Memnarc talk to me 12:01, February 10, 2012 (UTC)

Thanks Kind Sir (Mini-Mitch) (Information regarding the Thirteenth Doctor's unwelcoming behavior, "Scaring New Members Away from this Wiki with Threats"
Thanks for undoing my mistake by accidentlly editing the thirteenth doctor's profile. I didn't mean to publish that. Also do you think that Tardis Index File is a friendly eviroment for new wikia people, because someone told me that their first five edits on wikia were on this wiki, and that the thirteenth doctor undid them, because he/she said that it was too much content for Earth Reptiles or something, then blocked my friend on his first ever wikia edits.

Sincerly

Navigation
Please stop tripping the "advanced" navigation feature. It will require substantial work to theme it with CSS and I just don't have the time or inclination to do that right now. There's nothing wrong with the navigation we have presently. Thanks. :) 23:22: Thu 23 Feb 2012
 * If you want to play with it, don't forget that you have admin access at w:c:tardistest. 23:24: Thu 23 Feb 2012

Do you have to delete the image?
Do you have to delete File:Fifth_doctor_hurt.png as well?

So let me get things strait. Things have to more than 250px or just 250px?

Hidden categories
I hadn't even noticed that the option went away. I have sent in a bug report to Wikia staff, explaining our particular need to have the option restored. I doubt they'll actually go for that. However, I do think they'll probably allow the trickle of people from here that need to be able to see hidden categories to request it be manually enabled by a staff member. I'll let you know what happens as soon as they reply.

All I know is that it is possible to see hidden categories still, because I see them daily. This indicates that the option still exists somewhere in the true user preference file, only a portion of which we operate through Special:Preferences. 14:09: Wed 29 Feb 2012

Untitled message 1
hi, i edited a page called ' the mr copper foundation, adding further, valuable information which wasn't there previously. it said that you removed it. i was wondering what your reason for doing this was