Talk:Eleventh Doctor

The Big Bang
Does the entire plot for The Big Bang need to be included in this article? Seems a little much to me. Thoughts? 152.131.9.132 19:34, November 24, 2010 (UTC)

I agree with the above comment, far too much information on a single story, it's apparent that Smith will be on for at least one more year and this article is already longer than quite a few other Doctor's78.109.186.10 23:05, December 13, 2010 (UTC)

Was just about to suggest the same thing, then realised the two users above have already suggested it. This article should be about the 11th Doctor. The plot of every episode he is featured in is not necessary. There are already story articles which serve this purpose. Try to summerise what he did in the episode using a few sentences. KKIH4, April 4, 2011.

Ditto above, the section should be about the same size as the current christmas travels paragraph ~ 10-15 lines at most. PL.

I already did all this back in 2010 but it seems to have been reverted since without my knowing. I've cut it down again so hopefully this time it will stick. --Revan\Talk 16:06, April 14, 2011 (UTC)

Eh, kind of an overreaction. The Tenth Doctor got a single section for each of his finalies, so what's wrong with giving the 11ht Doc his own? Not much of a problem there. Sure some trimming would be good, switch some long winded explanations with shortened versions.

Deleted Scenes
Do deleted scenes count as canon, because in this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAI7ZcIbzw4&feature=related, he calls himself a "Space Gandalf" and compares himself to Yoda. And theis one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaOPe4emP9Y&feature=related contains good Info on the TARDIS' chameleon circuit and others.
 * Those two scenes are not deleted scenes, but were additional scenes written and filmed specifically for the DVD and Blu-ray release. Therefore they are both canon, alongside the two Comic Relief mini-episodes. There is still debate regarding whether bona fide deleted scenes, such as the one from Journey's End that established the whole "TARDIS coral" thing, should be considered canon. But there's little debate regarding the two you cite, except from those who hold to a strict personal (as opposed to official BBC) view that only televised material counts. 68.146.78.43 14:33, May 1, 2011 (UTC)

Our canon policy says deleted scenes don't count. OS25 (talk to me, baby.) 05:32, April 21, 2012 (UTC)


 * Can someone explain to me how the Meanwhile in the TARDIS scenes come across as deleted scenes? I assumed they were exclusively produced as DVD extras like Night and the Doctor. -- Tybort (talk page) 11:29, April 21, 2012 (UTC)

"Cleanup"
What is with the big ugly tag at the top of the page? "Paragraph, align images" - fair enough, but as far as I can see, the paragraphs and images are aligned just fine (certainly no worse than Amy Pond, and certainly not enough to warrant a "big cleanup"). When can we get rid of this obstructive tag?--The Traveller 20:46, February 23, 2011 (UTC)

Page Protection
Why is this page protected? It seems every page on this wiki is protected and I cannot edit, even though I registered... -- Rest In Peace Sarah Jane \ Talk to me! 12:35, April 21, 2011 (UTC)
 * It's the practice of this site to protect pages that are "current event" pages - as in with new episodes and information coming in - due to in the past people posting nonsense, incorrect information, rumor, or simple vandalism. As a result, numerous pages are "blocked" from anonymous editors and also newbies. I don't know what criteria is used that allows newbies to post - I assume post count. So If you want to contribute to these current pages I suggest adding valid information to other articles about non-current subjects. You don't need to actually add information; I think improving the wording, fixing spelling and grammatical mistakes, etc, would qualify as valid contributions too. Just remember this is a UK-based wiki and therefore UK-based spelling, grammar and formatting prevails. 68.146.78.43 14:29, May 1, 2011 (UTC)

Main image
I'm not criticising the current image - it's far better than the Christmas Carol one or the Impossible Astronaut one - but why do we need to change it so often?--The Traveller 07:56, June 9, 2011 (UTC)

Can we bring back the Christmas Carol one? I like this one (after all, it's of the Eleventh Doctor, I like all pictures of the Eleventh Doctor), but the Christmas Carol one is absolutely incredible. 65.35.225.248 18:28, June 16, 2011 (UTC)

Eleventh Doctor Quotes
What is your favourite Eleventh Doctor quote? Mine is:

The Doctor: Legs. I've still got legs. Good. Arms, hands. Oo, fingers, lots of fingers. Ears, yes. Eyes, two. Nose, I've had worse. Chin, blimey. Hair -- I'm a girl! No! No! I'm not a girl! And still not ginger! And there's something else, something important, I'm, I'm, I'm -- [loud explosion] ha! Crashing! Ha, ha! Whoo-hoo-hoo! Geronimo! 65.35.225.248 23:51, June 15, 2011 (UTC)

Got idea. Mine is (Cloister bell rings from regenration-damaged TARDIS)"No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no!"Forgetful 10th doctor fan talk to me 17:23, October 8, 2011 (UTC)

Grammar/Spelling
I'm reading this article, and whoever wrote it has terrible grammar. Someone please go through and fix it.

Nathan 15:49, June 21, 2011 (UTC)


 * Could you be a little more specific regarding the issues with the grammar? --Tangerineduel / talk 15:57, June 21, 2011 (UTC)
 * Section 1.8 bugs me. Interfere, friends, permanently and affiliated are misspelt. Also the sentences seem a little to complex with superfluous commas.
 * Section 1.8 bugs me. Interfere, friends, permanently and affiliated are misspelt. Also the sentences seem a little to complex with superfluous commas.

Hearing, but not seeing.
There needs to be a few more pictures of the page. Specifically in the personality, habits/quirks and outfit sections.

Reason?

There needs to be more pictures of the Doctor's habits in the Eleventh incanration while showing his various different outfits and aspects of his personality being displayed. Not to mention that's the only part of the page that pictures thin out on.

Another thing; the early travels section needs a bit more picturers from the other episodes. Its bare compared to the sixth series section. (173.167.179.77 18:48, June 22, 2011 (UTC))

Yes. Someone, please fix it! We really need more pictures. Eleven is my favourite Doctor. Sorry if that sounded random. 65.35.225.248 23:52, June 24, 2011 (UTC)

main image
We need to find one mug shot of the Eleventh Doctor that feels right for the main picture. Something calm, not really showing emotion. Like when he's contemplating something or has a realization. How about the one from the Beast Below where he says "yes" to Amy's question with a smile. That one seems good; its not over-emotional, its just the little bit we need. (173.167.179.77 18:48, June 22, 2011 (UTC))

Not really. The one Cortion added is just fine. BroadcastCorp. 10:26, July 27, 2011 (UTC)

His eyes are what!?!
This article says the Doctor's eyes are blue. His eyes are green. Trust me, I know! Can someone edit the article for me? 72.185.37.205 19:53, August 6, 2011 (UTC)

Done-- 19:56, August 6, 2011 (UTC)

Main image
I preferred the previous image, from The Lodger, rather than the current one. I would like a Series 6 image, though, but not the current one. It's not quite as focused on the Doctor's face, which is the most important aspect. 20:17: Mon 9 Sep 2011

Wished granted! It got changed by someone elseForgetful 10th doctor fan talk to me 17:21, October 8, 2011 (UTC)

Undated/unchronicled events
The doctors adventures shown in the impossible astronaut i.e. the nazi camp, laurel and hardy film. Could they not be dated as between god complex and his death. 81.154.210.113 20:47, September 22, 2011 (UTC) LL


 * Probably somewhere along those lines. -- Tybort (talk page) 20:58, September 22, 2011 (UTC)


 * According to an interview with Gareth Roberts on the BBC website, "Closing Time" will take place 200 years (for the Doctor) after "The God Complex". Roberts mentions that everything they saw him do/was referenced in "The Impossible Astronaut" takes place between the two episodes. Glimmer721 21:54, September 22, 2011 (UTC)

The Wedding of River Song
Under the "Escaping Death" section, it mistakenly reads that Amy finds out that Kovarian is herself. Just to make sure I didn't miss something, I went back to make sure she didn't.

I noticed that it says that the distress becon was created using the White Point Diamond that was used to link the Master to the Time War. I've watched the episode and the confidential and I dont recall any reference to this? Also in the same paragraph when River said a "million million voices" I dont think it was ment to be literal.89.243.236.181 01:28, October 2, 2011 (UTC)

umm...
The Doctor dislikes his past lives. When he guest-starred in Sarah Jane's show, he rudely remarked on Jo Grant's age after she remembered how he looked with his first three faces. Would this go under his habits and quirks?

Would this example would

"Upon being reminded of a past life, the Doctor would rudely remark on a fault of the person who reminded him of it" (SJA: Death of the Doctor)

Forgetful 10th doctor fan talk to me 17:20, October 8, 2011 (UTC)

If I recall, Jo didn't just remind him of his past lives. She said that he had turned into a baby. She was basically insulting this version of him. She was complaining that he had become younger, so he complained about how he got older.Icecreamdif talk to me 20:56, October 31, 2011 (UTC)

omg!
I'm so, so, very very very very very very sorry!

Something went wrong when I edited the section on "Habits and Quirks". I am so sorry.

I feel just awful for messing up part of the page, something went wrong when I hit the "Publish" Icon.

Oh, sorry, sorry, sorry. Oooh... Please, don't be VERY angry with me. I do expect some Anger.

173.167.179.77 21:00, October 26, 2011 (UTC) "Forgetful 10th Doctor fan"

Well we are hearing, but not seeing
There needs to be more pictures in bare places on the page, wouldn't you agree. The Habits and Quirks section is looking awfuly lonely. Not to mention, the Appearance part has no picture now. There are also other parts in the Eleventh Doctor's history, where there can be pictures, but hey. That's life. (Forgetful 10th doctor fan talk to me 02:00, November 9, 2011 (UTC))

Paragraphs
I can't seem to get the paragraphs around the bit spanning from The Doctor's Wife through Let's Kill Hitler to break lines properly. Does it have something to do with the densely packed images? -- Tybort (talk page) 00:34, November 25, 2011 (UTC)

Sheesh
Okay, I see when I've been beat; I try adding pictures onto the empty ares, but no dice. Well, can somebody else do it, i have trouble getting the words to stop sticking together and if I hi the space bar twice, that makes it look terirble. (Forgetful 10th doctor fan talk to me 21:33, December 15, 2011 (UTC))

Should there be another section in biography?
After Flesh and Stone, the tone of the series is the Doctor looking for answers to the cracks origins "Searching for Answers". After that he finds the answer in Cold Blood. That would end that section, anything after that, I see as "Further Travels with Amy" until "Rebooting the Universe".

Habits and quirks?
The Doctor often says variations of "good, and not so good". Also, he has often explained what he tells people are clever lies. Anybody else picking up on this or is it just me? Okay, about the knitting - it's kinda hard to see what king of magazine he is looking in while waiting for the fake Gideon. So, could somebody add a explaing that part, cause it IS very hard to notice the cover of the magazine unless you get eal close to the screen.Forgetful 10th doctor fan talk to me 23:01, December 28, 2011 (UTC)

Well, that may or not be true. However, the Doctor is often seen mumbling sometimes, often to himself, which is hard to hear. Such times would be Flesh and Stone, The Big Bang, and The Curse of the Black Spot. What he said at each of them are "Night-night", "Now listen...", and "Comfy sofa" (Forgetful 10th doctor fan talk to me 00:29, January 10, 2012 (UTC))

Too long
Some of the infromation should be sectioned off. There's just too much for "Alone no more". After the Flesh and Stone part, it should part off into another section, don't you think? It would make it easier to keep the readers' attention. (173.167.179.77talk to me 21:35, February 14, 2012 (UTC))

Main image
Currently, there seems to be some dispute over the main image on the page. The current image was the one which is to the right. However, a couple of Users have described it as 'creepy'. I would warmly welcome any other images that people want to upload and use. MM/ Want to talk? 00:05, April 20, 2012 (UTC) - 	I've probably been the most vocal in my objection to that image. Even disregarding the fact that I think the Doctor looks like Gollum from Lord of the Rings there, the picture itself is from a moment when the Doctor is giving Amy a grimacing half-smile as he leaves her behind. Hardly the best representative image. I propose Image 2, or the picture of the Eleventh Doctor that's already used for the main The Doctor article. Memnarc talk to me 00:10, April 20, 2012 (UTC)


 * Image 2 is immediately disqualified on grounds that it does not even come close to complying with T:ICC or tardis:guide to images. It's far, far too distant a pic to be the main image for an infobox.  Personally, I think pic 1 is a perfectly representative "tentative" smile from the Doctor.  He does it in a lot of instances, and it's a definite "Matt Smithism". I'm honestly scratchin' my head at your description of it as "Gollumesque".


 * However, if you want to replace, I don't really care, as long as the replacement is an equal closeup, of equal dimensions and clarity. I think, though, you'll be rather hard-pressed to find a closeup that's as well framed or in quite as good natural light. Take a look at the pics of all other Doctors.  The shot has to be a true "hero" closeup moment, where the head fills the frame.


 * Until such time as an alternative is found, however, please leave pic 1 in place. 14:54: Fri 20 Apr 2012
 * Just to clarify, administratively we have in the past sometimes removed an image until the bone of contention is settled. However this was in cases where a whole raft of users had competing ideas on which pic to use, and also when the resulting picture was a "collage" that had to be constructed.  In this case, it seems to be mostly Memnarc's view that the current pic is somehow "Gollumesque" that's driving things.  One person cannot hold a page "hostage" and end up depriving it of its infobox pic, especially on the page of the current star of the show! So we'll hold at file:ElevenHeroCloseup.jpg until Memnarc can provide something of equal quality here on the talk page.  15:05: Fri 20 Apr 2012


 * Although I would argue that Image 2 is just as close up as the Tenth Doctor's current image, I'll digress, as I think Image 3 is better representative of the Eleventh Doctor. While I can't say I recall many instances of the "tentative" smile CzechOut described, the smug grin he displays in Image 3 is very indicative of Matt Smith. Plus, if it's good enough for the main Doctor article, why wouldn't it be good enough for the Eleventh Doctor article? Memnarc talk to me 20:52, April 20, 2012 (UTC)
 * Pic1 is a closer closeup. I'm sure you can actually see that.  Look how much of the frame in Pic2 is not Matt Smith. Pic3 is disqualified precisely because it already serves as the infobox image at the Doctor.  There's no need for duplication.  And it's not as closeup nor as bright as Pic1.  Remember, the goal of an infobox pic is to be as big as possible, as bright as possible, and as clear as possible. Pic3 just isn't an improvement on Pic1 in any of these regards.  Keep looking.   21:31: Fri 20 Apr 2012
 * Huh. I actually considered the infobox on The Doctor to be updated to fit the more ICC images on First Doctor, Fourth Doctor, Eighth Doctor and Ninth Doctor, and what'll result on this page. Is it really redundant when it's a composite?


 * But I suppose that's better reserved for the discussion on The Doctor. -- Tybort (talk page) 22:46, April 20, 2012 (UTC)
 * Okay. I didn't want you to think I'm just saying "no" to your search for a new pic because I'm trying to particularly protect that picture.  I don't think the pic needs at all to be changed.  But if you do, let's get the ball really rolling here with a lot of options.  Here's a whole range of pics I'd find acceptable.


 * I would go with either 4 or 6, both are good. So we all agree the range is 4-6? OS25 (talk to me, baby.) 04:48, April 21, 2012 (UTC)
 * Not to be difficult, but I prefer #11 (no pun intended). It's the brightest and clearest, and you can even see his eye color. Shambala108 talk to me 05:16, April 21, 2012 (UTC)


 * well, that really isn't that important in deciding for the main image. The main problem with 11 is that because he is looking at the camera (and making a weird face) it could be mistaken for a publicity shot. I think six is the best. It's clear enough, with the tightest image possible. OS25 (talk to me, baby.) 05:31, April 21, 2012 (UTC)


 * Actually, it does not matter if it looks like a publicly photo or not, all that matter is if it's a publicity photo or not. To me, with six we can't see his bow-tie, a crucial part of about the Eleventh Doctor. He is making a 'stupid face' in picture four which you have stated you would like to go with. Picture eleven shows his hair, whereas six does not. MM/ Want to talk? 00:01, April 22, 2012 (UTC)


 * @Memnarc: 12 and 14 just aren't close enough to be conisdered.  13 is very interesting, though.  I can't quite place the episode.  Where'd you get it? I'd happily consider 13 still in the running. (Oh, could you do me a favor, though when uploading pics?  Please put it in the appropriate story category (like category:The God Complex TV story images) and the appropriate subject matter category (like category:Eleventh Doctor images)?  It'll really help us build a truly useable image library!)


 * @OttselSpy25: He's not looking at the camera in #11. He's looking at the massive Time Crack in the wall of the Silurian cave.  It's totally in-universe.  Do you honestly think that I would propose an image which flagrantly violated T:ICC?  Seriously, the difference between a character looking forward, and an actor looking into camera is obvious.  No one would reasonably think that a publicity shot.


 * And you're quite wrong to dismiss Shambala's observation about brightness. Brightness is one of the key issues surrounding infobox pictures.  The fact that we can see his eye color without enlarging the pic is important, and it's one of the reasons I uploaded this one. The vast majority of people looking at our pages never, ever look at infobox pictures at any other size than the one the page gives them.  So brightness is almost everything, because it must be clear.  Indeed, from a technical standpoint the objectively "best" picture — "best" being measured by metrics like resolution — is certainly #8.  But that's probably the least-appropriate infobox pic, because it's just a bit muddy at 250px.


 * As for the supposed "weird face" in #11, I can only say, This is Matt Smith, people.  His face is one of the most interesting and adaptable of all the Doctors.  He's going to look "odd", on some level, in just about every image.  The dude just has a weird face that looks a little bit different in every light, every emotion.  These aren't "unfair" pictures taken of an "off frame".  All of them are the very best of a series of between 5 to 20 taken in very quick succession.  This is just what the guy looks like in these various scenes.


 * @Mini-mitch: I agree with a lot of what you're saying, but I don't think the bow tie is actually necessary. After all, the infobox pic of Pertwee doesn't give us the smoking jacket and frills, the one of Four doesn't give us a scarf, and the one of Davison doesn't give us celery (though it does give us cricket whites, which are clearly more important!).  Of course, I ultimately think that whatever we choose will probably have the top of the bowtie — just because it's so close to the chin — but I don't think it's strictly necessary for an infobox pic of a Doctor to have the trademark costume element.   00:20: Sun 22 Apr 2012
 * A general note: remember to judge these pics solely on the way they appear on this page.  Do not click on them and compare the "blown up" versions.  All that matters to the exercise of picking an infobox image is the way they look in an article.  00:27: Sun 22 Apr 2012


 * The reason I said not to 11 is because due to the fact that it looks like a publicity photo, it may result n edit wars. Also he looks strait into the camera, which is a big no-no for main images. Past the relatively unimportant catchphrase, the Bowie is very unimportant. I would argue that, if six is disliked, then four is the best choice afterwards. OS25 (talk to me, baby.) 01:19, April 22, 2012 (UTC)


 * #11 is clearly the best image of the lot. It's brightly lit, perfectly framed, NOT out-of-universe (seriously?) and just the best one. @OttselSpy25 - I have to say that having followed your edits and specifically your picture uploads on this wiki for a while (not everything on the wiki needs to be redone--focus on things that are actually in need of pictures because there are actually *none*, rather than replacing everything with often dodgy images that aren't really well-thought-out or interesting), I have noticed that your sense of what a well-framed, non-awkward (attractive), iconic or noteworthy image is is something I practically never agree with you on. This is one such example. Your preferred image has the hair cut off (Matt looks better with more of his hair in view) and it's simply not epic enough. And he's not even looking towards the camera, he's looking slightly to the left. He's not doing a bugged-out Tom Baker publicity shot with the eyes straight ahead or the Terrifying Pertwee face/Dracula cape (now those are obvious publicity shots). And NOBODY is going to confuse this image for anything but a screencap. It's close to being a hero shot, which are actually really good images for this sort of thing. Most of these images have Matt's face scrunched up or in motion expressions (avoid them!). Screencaps sometimes do have the actor looking straight ahead (which this actually isn't). The fact that #11 also lights up his eyes is another plus. NileQT87 talk to me 13:05, April 22, 2012 (UTC)


 * Image 11 does not actually look at the camera, just by looking at the image, it is obvious to tell that it is left. The chances of an edit war, it very low. If we did, all we had to do was say is "it's not' and that be it.


 * Simply, it does, in no way look like a promotional image and in not way at all, is he looking at the camera. MM/ Want to talk? 14:52, April 22, 2012 (UTC)

Winnowing down
Okay, people, this thing shouldn't drag on forever. It appears that we've already had some clear enthusiasm expressed for some of these, so let's begin with an initial round of voting. I'll bring down those pics that have already received some support:

Which should be in the infobox? 1 4 6 11 13 Place your votes above and give your reasons below. 15:14: Sun 22 Apr 2012
 * 1 15:20: Sun 22 Apr 2012 As I've consistently maintained, the image doesn't need to be changed.  To me, it's not a "Gollum face".  It's the perfect expression of that in-between-happy-and-sad-state that Matt does so well. It's a fun smile, but if you look more closely, it's a bit wistful.  And I think the TARDIS backdrop is cool, at least for the present time. It subtly suggests he's the current occupant of the TARDIS, because none of the other Doctor pictures have the TARDIS in them.