Talk:Clara and the TARDIS (home video)

Careful with speculation
Remember, we can't include speculation in these articles. Someone added that the other Claras were all holograms, but there is absolutely nothing in the episode to suggest this, so I removed it. The reference that was removed to them being future versions should probably be restored as this is actually confirmed in dialogue ("I'm you, from tomorrow night") but I'm not in the mood for an edit war. However we can't have factual errors and saying the Claras were holograms is a blatant factual error. 68.146.70.124talk to me 03:33, October 6, 2013 (UTC)
 * Clara talks about the holo leopard at the beginning. The TARDIS has created a holo copy of Clara previously just to interact and argue with Clara. All of the Claras at the end appear in exactly the same clothing and they are interacting with one another after Clara dares the TARDIS to do her worst. Given that the TARDIS knows what happens at every point in time simultaneously, the "I'm you, from tomorrow night" line doesn't prove that the TARDIS has stolen Clara out of the future, which doesn't fit with anything she's done before, it only proves that the TARDIS knows what tomorrow night's Clara will say when she takes away her room again. To say that she has met herself in this scene like previous companions would also then be a factual error as defined above, because we do not know for a fact that she has. Mewiet ☎  05:29, October 6, 2013 (UTC)
 * Oh come on, it's complete speculation that Clara's lying in saying, "I'm you, from tomorrow night." Yes, the TARDIS is capable of making holograms as proven in the leopard line... But the implication (actually, it's pretty explicitly stated in dialogue) is that these are, as Clara says, future versions. I wouldn't be surprised if she hasn't changed because her clothes are in her room... or maybe she can't find the wardrobe either. Either way, her clothing is not proof that the future versions aren't real. As clearly shown in Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS as well as many others, the TARDIS can manipulate time within itself, cause time loops, echoes from the past and future, etc. So it certainly does fit with the TARDIS' previous actions. --SOTO ☎ 07:34, October 6, 2013 (UTC)