Talk:Harmony Shoal

The Shoal is described here as a race. We know that Scratch represents it.

But do we know it is a race?

"Shoal" suggests a location, and you can represent a location. The people who surround the Doctor seem human, but one or two aren't (but you can't tell if they have line-face.) And Scratch yells "heresy" but then Hydroflax is worshipped.

It could be an organisation or a religion or a place, or, even, a race. Is there an official source for it being a race? 167.160.116.147talk to me 08:09, December 28, 2015 (UTC)

Are Scratch and the Shoal of the Winter Harmony actually members of the Halassi race? Despite never being actually stated during the episode it is heavily implied. King Hydroflax once raided the Halassi Vaults during which he tried to steal the diamond, which was driven into his skull. Scratch later recalled an event in which Hydroflax visited their world in "blood and joy". The Halassi race had also tasked River Song to retrieve the diamond, yet she and Scratch met first before having time to make any other arrangements.


 * That's just speculation. No, there's nothing in the episode which suggests they are a race, and the article should be altered to reflect that.-- 21:47, January 5, 2016 (UTC)