Board Thread:Inclusion debates/@comment-57280-20170205011338/@comment-1789834-20170205014708

TheChampionOfTime wrote: The page also doesn't mention the cross-over in AUDIO: All-Consuming Fire. Since we're talking about ACF, I'm interested to know with how this Wiki deals with scenarios where it's a valid adaptation. I've always treated the Audio Novel Adaptations akin to the Target Novelisations of the episodes. They're almost like a second account of the same event.

BUT, if we're to say PROSE: All-Consuming Fire and AUDIO: All-Consuming Fire are to be treated separately and occurring individually and unrelated to one-another... then how do we explain the fact that we have two almost identical Sherlocks with the same origin story...?

This has always confused me. Are the adaptations treated as alternative realities in this universe? Or are they treated, similar to how I treat them, as basically two different perspectives on the same event. My comment is admittedly quite messy but I hope you gather what I'm saying... I've always wondered how this Wiki deals with them... two practically identical stories.