User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Tales from the Tardis/@comment-4028641-20131226044919

I understand that this discussion was started before today but was closed when it all went to personal attacks. As I am only discussing the details of these two words as in use in 'Time,' I have decided to open a new discussion (everyone please behave, although I have no room to talk) without sourcing the last for any answers to my quarries involving these topics and this story.

'Time' seems to answer all of our questions about bodies, Doctor #s, and regeneration #s.

The Doctor's discussion about his lives seems to clearly state this:

7th Doctor: 7th Doctor, 7th body, sixth regeneration

8th Doctor: 8th Doctor, 8th body, seventh regeneration

War Doctor: NOT Doctor, 9th body, eighth regeneration

9th Doctor: 9th Doctor, 10th body, ninth regeneration

10th Doctor: 10th Doctor, 11th body, tenth AND eleventh regenerations (second one either wasted or sent into identical incarnation. I suspect first)

and most importantly:

11th Doctor: 11th Doctor, 12th body, and twelfth and (original set's) final regeneration

More importantly than this, it seems to suggest that this is the right way to list it all. Thus I propose (no matter how difficult it might be) that this be how we address lives, Doctors, bodies, and regenerations.

If this has already been decided, I am sorry. I was not looking forward to jumping into that past discussion and I hope to not have offended anyone.