User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Help!/@comment-5532276-20131005180812/@comment-26975268-20131005190239

To the best of my understanding, we try not to break T:NO RW in categorising, but are given a little more flexibility when there's no choice.

For example, if we were to just take info from Hide, flea is not necessarily an Earth insect in the DWU. But we have to give it some category, so we use category:Earth insects.

Virginia Woolf is never specified to be a writer, but yet is still put in category:writers from the real world. People looking at that category would expect to see all real world writers expressed in the DWU; excluding her would undermine the category's usefulness.

So, to answer your question more specifically, if wildebeest (wildbeests? does that work plural?) were mentioned off-handedly without explanation in a DWU story, I would definitely put it in category:Antelopes.

I am not, however, an admin, so I may have it all wrong, and have been doing it wrong from the start. So don't quote me.