User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-4028641-20171124185300/@comment-4028641-20180102001444

How the novelisation and TFD "fits" has no relevance to if this story is valid or not. How does Lungbarrow fit into any other story written for the DWU? Or how Spiral Scratch and  The Last Adventure? The answer is that they don't fit, and it's our job to point out how they don't fit, not to pick whichever version of events we love more.

I would like to move to close this thread. I've seen very little support for calling the final version of Shada INvalid, and I think the next logical move is to move the discussion of merging it into Shada (TV story) to said stories' talk page so we can get on with it.