User talk:The Librarian

Hi, just to let anyone know I've currently started on Doctor Who Magazine related pages which I hope will be comprehensive (I promise I'll catch up soon).I had to start somewhere but if anyone has suggestions or requests for details they would find useful / interesting or both, please let me know.Hope I can help! The Librarian 01:36, 23 July 2007 (UTC)


 * Hi, thank you for contributing to the TARDIS index file, there are however a few issues with your formatting etc of the pages, please see DWM Issue 1 for an example of the new Infobox I have created for the magazines.
 * Please also see the Help and Manual of Style pages. Thanks (any questions leave in the forum or on a talk page). --Tangerineduel 13:54, 23 July 2007 (UTC)


 * The alterations to the DWM pages are minor and are merely to bring them in line with other pages on the TARDIS wiki. Should you have any problems please leave a message on a talk page. --Tangerineduel 15:48, 23 July 2007 (UTC)


 * Hi Tangerineduel, hope you get to read this cos I am now stuck!
 * The template you have applied to my pages on the whole is appreciated as are the minor edits you've done however, as there wasn't previously a template to use could we clarify a few points before I decide to carry on?

The Librarian 17:47, 23 July 2007 (UTC)
 * 1) You've taken out the brackets (refering to related wiki topics) after the article and replaced them with in-title references. Can I ask that it reverts back. The reason I chose to do it the way I did was because, as you will see on my way to issue 383, the article title doesn't always reflect the content of the article. It only really applied to the early issues aimed at younger readers.
 * 2) Would it be ok to remove the `to be added' line where none appeared in that particular issue or would you prefer I put `none` to leaving it blank as there is nothing to be added. I would be unhappy with removing the content category as it gives a continuity to the overall pages?
 * 3) If I continue to use your template it does not include 'credits' for issue production which are revealed more with later issues. I feel these should be included as an acknowledgement of other peoples work (many of who are now key figures in shaping and determining the type of Doctor Who we get to share).
 * 4) Could the infobox be reduced slightly in width as this would increase the definition of the cover image, and not encrouch as much across the main contents, which like everything else become longer and more detailed with later issues?
 * 5) I don't want to mess with site convention but am curious as to how existing pages (often stubs)can be expanded to include additional information that may not however appear in the template used for the article. If such information can be included throughout a section, does it need approval first, and from who if a template is to be expanded?

Hi...
 * 1) It would perhaps be better for in those cases to have a | and still keep the text of the article ie: Dalek amd Mutants from the planet Skaro, they both link to the same page, but different text. Or if this doesn't suit perhaps in brackets a small explanation of what the article is about. (Also on a side note I removed the brackets mainly because it was a slightly messy way of displaying the information and looked slightly out of place.)
 * 2) none would probably be best (I'm totally behind having continuity between pages...) so none would be good, so that future contributors know that there is definitely nothing in these headings.
 * 3) Feel free to use the page layout you've implemented (the only things I ask you add is the ==External Links== at the end and also at the very bottom of the page (rather than your categories, just as this one keeps everything separate). So there could obviously be a Credits section of the page after the Contents or wherever you want, as I said when I went through and edited I kept all your headings etc.
 * 4) How the page is displayed is some what dependant on the screen resolution and layout of the user viewing the page, however the image as displayed sits at 250px, (a lower number a smaller picture), the infobox is however the same width as your original infobox.
 * 5) As for other articles just add a heading or whatever, there isn't any approval process. There are various articles spread throughout the Manual of Style and help pages which act as a guide to various topics. But in general if there's enough information (especially stub articles) then just add it, the exception is the TV, Book, CD and Anthology pages which have a very established page layout and it's generally best to stick to those. A rule of thumb is to look at similar pages around it as an idea.

Hope this is of some assistance (anything else I'll try to answer also). --Tangerineduel 18:30, 23 July 2007 (UTC)

Re Message
''Hi, sorry, I was trying to clean up my talk page and accidently deleted content from the welcome template. Can you please re-edit it to recover it 'cos as a newbie I appreciated it and now feel guilty. PS where do I find out how to remove it from my talk page? I won't play with it again in case you can re-edit it back. sorry. The Librarian 01:52, 30 July 2007 (UTC)''

To go back through your page's history (like all pages) just click the History link at the top of the page. Also you can just highlight it all and delete it (removing all content from your page).

Also, just another side note on formating, generally speaking the headings should be two = (==) rather than the one which you used in the the reformating of the X Doctor Comic Strip Stories. The single = sign results in overly large headings. (You can add further headings within them by just adding my = signs either side and it will continue to add up in the contents.)

When creating pages (sorry to be lecturing) check that a page doesn't already exist, for example abbreviations used in referencing Doctor Who Comic Strip Stories, should really be covered (and is already partially covered) in Tardis:List of prefixes rather than a page of its own. (I will be altering and transfering the pages). This is both to assist in future page creations and keeping the information in an easy to access area.

Also (while not nesscary...as others will inevitably place it in) categories at the base of pages is a good idea as it will help others when working on your pages. (Generally looking at other pages similar to your page you're creating will help).

This also goes for formating and other things, take a look at some of the pages that have a lot of edits, or even some of the CD or novel pages which are generally all laid out in a similar fashion to one another for ease of reading, or the TV stories (most of which have been fixed...some still aren't onto the full Manual of Style)...but the formatting is still there for the most part.


 * Just one (hopefully final) thing, everything should be written in past tense, rather then present. (Further explanation see Tardis:Manual_of_style) --Tangerineduel 13:51, 30 July 2007 (UTC)

The abbreviations
Just having a look through your abbreviations, some of them are going to need to change, just since the DW at the start would only confuse, as DW is the prefix for TV stories.

Currently on the Tardis:List of prefixes there are:
 * DWM - Doctor Who Magazine comics and prose stories
 * DWA - Doctor Who Annual and Doctor Who Yearbook comics and prose stories
 * DC - The Dalek Chronicles
 * RT - Radio Times comics

Compared to you page:
 * (DWM) Doctor Who Magazine regular issues (including variations)
 * (DW HS) Doctor Who Magazine Holiday Special DWMH
 * (DW YB) Doctor Who Magazine Yearbook already covered see DWA
 * (DW CC) Doctor Who Classic Comic DWCC
 * (DW US) Doctor Who (United States reprint title) DWUS
 * (DW An.) Doctor Who Annual already covered see DWA
 * (DW BIT) Doctor Who: Battles in Time DWBIT
 * (DWA) Doctor Who Adventures DWAM (for Doctor Who Adventures Magazine, covering both comics, prose stories and anything else which might be referenced, it is the same for DWM and DWA)
 * (TVC) TV Comic (including variations) already covered see below
 * (TV21) TV Century 21 already covered see The Dalek Chronicles for more information
 * (RT) Radio Times already covered

My changes are in italics (I will begin to swap it over to the Tardis:List of prefixes page, but any red links which haven't as yet been utilised feel free to change...

While I'm on my formating spiel, when reading large chunks of information, bullet points (first at least) makes for an easier read, after the bullet points it can be simple indentation (or indented bullet points), it just makes for an easier to read article.

Any other questions feel free to ask. --Tangerineduel 13:10, 30 July 2007 (UTC)


 * Actually...reading through the X Doctor comic strip stories pages, there doesn't need to be a note (especially not a whole section) on the prefixes. As any article with a prefix should be clickable and take you to the prefix's article ie DWM. Just thought I'd explain my reasons for removing it from the X doctor comic strip pages (as it doesn't deliver any information pertinent to the page. --Tangerineduel 13:25, 30 July 2007 (UTC)