User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-5791028-20150117172224/@comment-9435571-20150604154240

I'd say that given that half of the main characters involved are definitely covered by this wiki, this should still be covered, even if these characters are not the Doctor but Benny, Iris and the Graceless twins, whose inclusion has been argued extensively already.

To reverse CzechOut's argument, we would have arguments each year on why we include all properly licensed adventures of Iris and Benny, but not this one.

The crossover with Dorian and Sherlock is not much different than "Shades of Gray" (which also doesn't include the Doctor) or "All-Consuming Fire" and "Diogenes Damsel" (which already establishes that Sherlock Holmes exists in the DWU too, and furthermore, it has the David Warner Mycroft, like WoBF, while Mycroft is played by a different actor in other BF releases). In the extras, they actually mention that they used the Warner Mycroft specifically to tie it more to the Benny series.

And the appearance of Vienna is no different from the one in "The Shadow Heart". It actually has no references to her previous adventures in her own range.