User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-26975268-20130407222910/@comment-188432-20130412061149

It's always dangerous to lift lines of dialogue from a television show and divorce them from the visuals. We know that they don't land on the "planet" Akhaten or the pyramid, because there are several shots which establish that both of those objects are in front of them from the position of the amphitheatre. Clara may well request a visit to Akhaten, but it's not where the Doctor takes her. Hardly the first time a companion has asked him to go somewhere, gotten his apparent acquiescence, but ended up elsewhere.