Howling:What would you like to see for the 50th anniversary show?

I see that November 23, 2013 is a Saturday. I believe we all expect a spectacular episode that evening. Who or what would you like to see? Me, I'd like to see Carole Ann Ford. Boblipton talk to me 22:10, November 10, 2011 (UTC)

I'd like to see something like what Star Trek Deep Space 9 did, by inserting their characters into an old series episode. They could put Matt Smith and companion(s) digitally into scenes with each previous Doctor. He wouldn't have to interact with them, just observe them, but it would be a great way to include all the other Doctors. Oh and bring back Jamie too. Shambala108 talk to me 06:57, November 11, 2011 (UTC)

The Trials and Tribbleations approach might not work for Doctor Who as well as it did for DS9. Keep in mind, DS9 was celebrating the anniversary of what was technically a different show than their own. DS9 could honor TOS by having their characters travel back to an old episode, but since Doctor Who is still technically the same show I'm not sure that it would work as well. They probably already came as close to doing that as they're going to with Rememberance of the Daleks. Anyway, I'd definetly like to see Carole Ann Ford return, as well as William Russell (Sarah Jane could have been wrong about him not having aged), as they were both there from the beginning. I would also love to see Jamie return at some point, although since they would need to deal with his memory wipe it might make more sense to do that in an episode centered around him (like School Reunion was for Sarah) instead of bringing him back for what I'm sure will already be a big episode. They should also stick to the formula of their previous anniversaries and bring back any past Doctor who would be willing to come(and is still alive). They could use a bit of technobabble to explain why the ones who are way older than they were when they were on the show look different(like in Time Crash) or they can just ignore it and hope nobody notices(like in The Two Doctors). It should also have Daleks, Cybermen, Time Lords, the Master, Sontarans, Autons, or all of the above. Also, as long as Moffat is doing a story arc involving the Doctor's name, it might be interesting if we learned either his name or the mystery behind it on the shows 50th anniversary, although it might be best if he keeps it seperate from his main story arcs. Anyway, I'm starting to wish that the BBC had started the show about 2 years earlier.Icecreamdif talk to me 16:50, November 11, 2011 (UTC)

But, if it had, you'd have said exactly the same thing about 2 years ago! You're just impatient. (Mind you, you're not the only one.)

On the subject of Ian Chesterton's age: In the release of the surviving episodes of The Crusade (1965), William Russell played him as considerably older in the narration that replaces the missing episodes. As the "Releases" section of the TARDIS Index File article on that story points out, that seems to contradict Sarah Jane's reported rumour but there's nothing in the narration to indicate when it is set, so it could conceivably be well into the future.

"Inserting" characters into an old episode would be difficult to pull off technically, as well as dramatically. The aspect ratio has changed (from 4:3 to 16:9), so using old footage means either not filling the full width or (alternatively) lopping off the top and bottom of the frame. There would also be a problem with image quality, since the resolution has improved greatly. That's not to say nothing of the kind could be done, however. One way -- and there must be others -- would be to set an entirely new story in the same place and time as an old one. One of the hazards the Doctor and perhaps one/more of his companions would have to deal with would be the risk of meeting their earlier selves. They'd be trying to avoid that, so footage from the old episodes could be confined to longer shots, where there's room to crop the frame. An obvious candidate for the setting would be Shoreditch in late 1963. Not only did the first episode, An Unearthly Child, take place there but so (slightly later) did Remembrance of the Daleks. There'd be scope for "near misses" with the First Doctor and/or the Seventh. If they brought Sophie Aldred back as Ace (which would be quite possible), she too would have to contend with there being a younger version of herself around the place. Mind you, letting two Aces loose would be quite dangerous -- Shoreditch could get blasted out of existence even without a contribution from the Daleks.

One thing is extremely obvious, however: Trying to put everything into a single anniversary episode or even a two-parter would be foolish. Too many people have too many disparate hopes for who and what will reappear and the story would get badly overcrowded. Because the golden anniversary is such an important one, spreading the celebrations, and therefore the reappearances, over most of a series would make much more sense. --89.241.69.17 06:37, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

i like that idea 89, and it would make a lot of sense to have an aniversary year versus a single aniversary episode. just want to say, that if there was a multi-doctor episode, i hope it would start something like this: 11 and his companion at the time land the tardis in an empty meadow on earth or something and 11 starts complaining that that wasn't where he wanted to be. then 10 arrives with donna (i think she would work better for this type of episode compared to martha) and starts complaining similarly to 11 before donna points out 11 behind him. then 9 arrives with rose and a simmilar thing happens again. they mingle for a bit before hearing another tardis land and one of the doctors already there speculates that it might be 12 or 13 and then they are all surprised when it turns out to be a pre time war doctor. i just think that would be a cool opening if they did that. but i really don't care much what they do, as long as it is awesome (although i do hope they will continue their tradition of multi doctor episodes) 121.216.142.176 07:57, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

arg. i've got to remember to log in before posting! that was me, btw. Imamadmad talk to me 07:59, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

If they really wanted to do an episode where the Doctor runs into past versions of himself through archive footage, they probably could technically pull it off. A 90s episode of Star Trek was able to be set in a 60s episode, and they could just film those parts of the anniversary special in 4:3 if they wanted to. I'm just not sure if they could come up with a very good story to make that work. For the Star Trek episode, they didn't do an episode where a hundred Jem'hadar ships travelled back in time to destroy the Enterprise so that Kirk wouldn't be able to save the Federation in the future. Instead, they had a relatively useless Klingon travel to one of the silliest episodes of the Original Series, where he tried to kill Kirk by putting a bomb in a Tribble, forcing the DS9 crew to where the 60s uniforms and hang out on the Enterprise. For the Doctor Who anniversary though, I think people are expecting something a bit more epic than that though. People are expecting different versions of the Doctor to team up to fight old enemies and old companions to come back. That just wouldn't really work with that format. An anniversary year would be awesome, but unless Moffat finishes up his Silence arc in the next season, he may not want to spend an entire year focusing on the show's past. As for your idea about the different Doctors all landing in the same place-I hope you mean that some force brought them there and it wasn't just a funny coincidence. Back in the Classic Series, the multi-Doctor episodes were usually brought about by the Time Lords, although that is obviously impossible. They'll have to find some other way to bring different Doctors together. They could do an episode like The Five Doctors (but better) and find an excuse to make most of the reccuring enemies (Daleks, Cybermen, Autons etc.) minor enemies who are working for or being manipulated by one major enemy (like the Master, Omega, or the Silence). Or he could bring a bunch of old enemies back the way he did in The Pandorica Opens, but give them all more to do.Icecreamdif talk to me 18:34, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

Icecreamdif, "unless Moffat finishes up his Silence arc in the next season, he may not want to spend an entire year focusing on the show's past": Are you sure about that? The Silence arc is already pointing straight at the show's past with the question "Doctor Who?" and the golden anniversary isn't going to have taken Moffat by surprise. It wouldn't totally surprise me if the question/answer/silence stuff is the buildup to the anniversary. -- 2.96.24.170 (formerly 89.241.69.17) 21:54, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

just saying, i've heard rumours that 11 will regenerate during the 50th anniversary. i'm not sure if it would be true, but it would be a good time to have the battle with the fall of 11 at the anniversary and either reveal or deepen the secret of the doctor's name right before 11 regenerates, with all his past selves and many of his past companions arround him. also, i wonder how the writers would introduce the classic doctors/companions to the new generation of watchers, the kids who have only been watching since 2005 or later and don't know about the classic series. it might be confusing to suddenly reintroduce aspects of the classic series without 8 year old being left sayin "what? what!? WHAT!?!". lets hope the writing is as good as in school reunion with bringing back sarah jane, and that they will bring back classic doctors for a multi doctor episode. it would be a shame to just bring back the new-who ones. Imamadmad talk to me 01:28, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well, the 8 year olds who were watching The Five Doctors may have been confused about Patrick Troughton and William Hartnell(impersonator), but as long as they are already familiar with the concept of regeneration they should still be able to figure out what's going on. 2.96, if you had read my first post on this page you would have realized that I have thought about the idea of Moffat doing some kind of reveal about the Doctor's name (either actually telling us the name or explaining why it is a secret), and if done correctly that could be a very good story to tie into an anniversary year. I'm not sure if he would want to do that but it would be awesome if he did. Also, for the anniversary, he might want to bring back a more classic villain, like the Master or the Daleks instead of the relatively new Silence. Still, it is possible that the Master arranged for the Daleks to ask the Doctor his true name after the Cybermen had fired their truth ray at Trenzalore, and the Silence were just trying to kill the Doctor to stop this. (just for the record I don't really think that that the Cybermen have a truth ray or anything). Bringing past Doctors into a regeneration episode could be interesting too. It could be The Twelve Doctors, even though one of them is caught in a space eddy, one of them is lost inside the vortex, and one of them is played by a look alike, and the rest of them all sufferred rapid aging.(it makes about as much sense as only having two past Doctor-actors return in The Five Doctors)Icecreamdif talk to me 02:07, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Icecreamdif, "2.96, if you had read my first post on this page ...": I did read it but I'd forgotten that bit by the time I posted my note about "the question/answer/silence stuff" -- otherwise I'd have added something like: "as you suggested above." Sorry. -- (IP address will have changed again, I expect) 89.242.71.175 07:38, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Imamadmad, "i've heard rumours that 11 will regenerate during the 50th anniversary. i'm not sure if it would be true": Well, I've heard Matt Smith say he'd like to break the record for the longest serving Doctor and to outdo Tom Baker's 7 years, he'll need to keep going far beyond the anniversary. Mind you, the last actor to express an ambition to do that was Colin Baker, which proves ambition is an unreliable guide to what will actually happen. --89.242.71.175 07:47, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

well, at least matt smith has equalled colin baker so far and will beat him next year. one baker down, one to go :) Imamadmad talk to me 10:17, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Some nice ideas here, but I have a couple of oddballs myself. First, I'd like to see what would happen if they moved back to a half hour slot -- twice the episodes, so that some of the stories can get their proper lengths -- some have definitely felt like they could use another half hour this season. My other oddball ideas is I'd like to see the old actors back.... but why do they have to be in their original roles? Let 'em come back as villains and have a little fun. Oh yeah, Graeme Harper to direct. Boblipton talk to me 20:39, November 13, 2011 (UTC)