Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/A Good Man Goes to War


 * If River is Amy and Rory's daughter, why wasn't she erased along with Rory when he died in Cold Blood?
 * Simple. When Amy's parents were erased from time, Amy continued to exist. Therefore, when Rory was erased from time, River continued to exist.

ANSWER:

In The Big Bang episode, Amelia Pond child has just been erased from time:

Amy: "How can i be here if she's not?"

Doctor: " You're just an anomaly, we all are. Hanging onto the eye of the storm which is closing."

I think these qoutes in DW: The Big Bang should answer your plot hole!


 * Why would the Cybermen have safety signs on their ship? There's clearly a "Fire Escape" sign and another denoting the contents of the tanks in the background while the Cyber Leader calls out intruders.


 * Perhaps they stole the ships? They were clearly the same Cyber Ships portrayed in the Series 5 Finale So, that doesn't mean they didn't steal them. They are also similar to the ships in The Invasion. Also, Cybermen aren't indestructible, they would likely need safety guidelines as well.


 * Why hasn't the Doctor ever assembled an army before now and why didn't he bring more of his assistants to help instead of old enemies like a Sontaran.
 * Clearly he never saw the need before, and they are all people who owe him favours, he probably doesn't want to interrupt his old friends new lives.
 * For all we know the Doctor may have done something similar to this before, but off-screen.
 * Although Sontarans are normally his enemy, Strax wasn't. Same can be said for the Silurians recruited to help.
 * The Doctor clearly chose his army for specific abilities. Martha Jones would have offered little to this mission, for example. Nor would, say, Sarah Jane. In addition, the Doctor has stated several times, most recently in SJA: Death of the Doctor his reluctance to revisit former companions. So instead of past companions he chose individuals to whom a debt was clearly owed.


 * Vastra compliments the Doctor on taking over the station without a drop of blood spilt. However, she is wrong as at least two soldiers and one monk die during an altercation explicitly orchestrated by the Doctor.
 * Vastra did not witness the brief fight with the soldiers and the monks, she likely didn't know that had occured.
 * Perhaps she meant it literaly, based on what her experiences have been like.


 * When the Silurians and Judoon and the Sontaran appear and take control of the base, why don't the monks attack then? And why are they left on the station when everyone else is taken away?
 * It's strongly implied at Kovarian arranged the whole thing as a trap, so the monks were likely acting under orders.

Perhaps since doc found out amy was flesh previously, madame kovarian must have improved the flesh to withstand sonic waves. Also how did Melody turn flesh? what caused her to melt?
 * If Melody is a flesh avatar, why doesn't she "melt" when Rory uses the sonic screwdriver while holding her to open the door to Amy?

BEST ANSWER:

Not all functions of the screwdriver are in use when the screwdriver is activated. The 'open locks' function is different from the 'Flesh discorporation' function.

Yes but how does the doctor change the setting/function as there is only a buttion on the screwdriver, i am talking about the previous screwdrivers too.

the monks and clerics are working together. The monks clearly have some form of sentience and so would not kill their allies. The life support system continues to heal the crew while they are walking about the ship, and possibly nearby the ship. The child is seen walking to the flight deck at the end of that episode so it is reasonable to say that he could walk around quite freely. As for fighting, they don't get involved that much in the episode, they capture the escape pod, with an apparent crew of 12, although only 1 is seen, (either a bluff, or that they are tied up inside the ship) and besides capturing a neighbouring ship is something one would assume pirates would do
 * Curnal Manton suggests that the strategic advantage of the Headless Monks having no heads is that the Doctor would not be able to convince them not to kill him, as the Doctor has proven so able to do with his enemies in the past. However, once the appearance of the Doctor (in the guise of a Headless Monk) causes the marines/clerics and Monks to attack each other, Manton removes the ammo from his weapon in order to convince the Monks that the marines/clerics are not a threat to them. How could that be an effective way to diffuse the situation if the Monks have to heads with which to reason? And why would Colonal Manton beleive that such a strategy would work in the first place, given that he was the one to explain the inexorable nature of the Monks?
 * At one point, you see Toby and Henry Avery, (the son and captain from The Curse of the Black Spot.) I thought that Toby couldn't be disconnected from the life support or he would die, because he was extremely sick...so how is he able to be up and fighting?

Yes but in Black Spot, rory 'redrowned' as soon as he was disconnected from the 'bed', so the 'near-the-ship' theory doesn't 'really' work, does it? sorry for the 'excessive' use of apostrophies, i 'wanted' to 'try' to 'use' as 'little' as i 'could'.

The Doctor had said Toby had typhoid fever. The Automated Sickbay presumably cured him of it; however, typhoid is only a bacterial condition, and Toby was seen functioning relatively normally prior to being put in sickbay. Rory, on the other hand, was presumably in a state of suspended animation (for lack of a better term) keeping him from dying of drowning. Probably because they produce a signal, or since theyre aliens. they maybe able to use 'head functions' somewhere else! Maybe they were 'born'/live headless. we might find out about more of these creatures later on.
 * How are the Headless Monks able to chant there attack prayer if they don't have heads?
 * How are the Headless Monks alive? Don't decapitation generally kill most species?

Could be related to scarecrows in 'The Family Of Blood'?

*Long 'Bad Guys Going Good' Plot Hole

Why is sontaran a nurse? i swear i saw him in 'the poison sky'? why he want to help doctor? have they met? when did they meet? why does m. vestra look alot like alaya and the leader of the silurian army in 'cold blood'? vestra uses terms such as 'old friend' when they havent met? why are silurian teams attacking the human 'doctor' rebellion? why has humans teamed up with kovarian? is she human? more questions on identity and purpose of kovarian? any other so called 'obvious' plot holes could be answered here please?