User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-4028641-20151007072528/@comment-4028641-20151007150258

I just feel like we need to put all games, new or old, to the same tests that we did others. If Worlds in Time is a role-playing game for instance, then I'm certain Dalek Attack is just as narratively unclear. In fact, I would compare DA to Legacy, except that story has a more clear narrative.

I'm looking over the newer Video Games added, and they are strange ones, aren't they? TARDIS Tennis, where the Doctor's companions John Lennon, William Shakespeare, and Queen Victoria have to compete against each other in tennis in order to play Winston Churchill... The type of game that makes you go 'whaaaah' because it sounds too crazy to be real. But I can't find too much on that one to make in invalid.

Monster Match is straight out because it's not a story at all -- just a game of candy crush played with Who monsters. Fun tho, I visit it a lot to remember nostalgic days. Same for Cosmic Collider, Cyber Quiz, Sonic De-Cloaker, SuDocWho, Defend This, Secret Santa, Santa Shooter,

Clockwork Quest is a game where you don't even know who you're playing as, suggestively yourself. Games like this are usually the sort to be invalid in my eyes. Same for The Wire and Cybus Spy.

If you could win Black Hole, I'd say it was enough of a story to be valid. However, according to what I can tell, the only way to end the game is to loose. So, I doubt it again. If Dalek Break-out has an ending, I suppose it could be valid.

K9: Deja Who is a "what-if" game illustrating K9 taking part in different New Series adventures, similar to The Last Dalek. Same for Slitheen Surfer and The Waters of Mars.

Defeat Deffry has different endings to choose, which we had previously used to rule out stories as invalid.

Satellites is weird cause I guess it makes sense as a point in the DWU, but I would still say invalid because it's a bit unclear who you are... But I could see this one going either way.

Art Attack, Amy's History Hunt, Save Paris, Doctor In A Dash, The Doctor and the Dalek, Eye of the TARDIS, Ghostwatch, Ood Escape, Security Bot and Jobsworth Judoon all seem to be pretty solid narratives according to what I can tell, but I might be wrong.