Howling:Silence in Series 5

So characters have been warning the Doctor that “silence will fall” since the eleventh hour. Now that we know that the Silence edit themselves out of memory it is possible that the silence have been around since the beginning of Moffat’s writing. I am in the process of re-watching the previous episodes to see if Moffat left us clues and came across the final scene of the eleventh hour. During that scene Amy’s face grows grim several times in the scene and she turns away only to look normal again. In addition she fiddles with the Tardis controls several times in the scene. I originally thought it odd, but ignored it since nothing came of it in that series. However, watching it now she appears to search for a particular control and flips it and then turns around quickly to mask the fact that she just did something to the Tardis as if the silence told her to do something. Perhaps a Silent has been in the Tardis all this time. This would also explain why we hear the voice in the Tardis in The Pandorica Opens.

Now on a side note, I also rewatched The Edge of Destruction recently and can see a lot of illusions to something getting into the Tardis. Barbara, Ian, Susan and the Doctor all start acting differently and also seem to be fighting these new traits (which feels like subliminal messages). Something affects the Tardis and causes it to malfunction (much like Pandorica Opens). And to top it all off Susan even mentions Silence. I am not saying that this is connected, just that I found it really funny. However, if Moffat links all the way back to the third story of Doctor Who, then I think Moffat is an even more amazing writer than I ever thought.

Anyways, I would like others to post here other instances where characters might see Silence so that we can discuss their legitimacy. MasterIII 21:47, May 3, 2011 (UTC)

It is incredibly unlikely that the writers of the 3rd episode of the show were setting up a plot arc that wouldn't be resolved for almost half a century. In Edge of Destruction, everything that happened had to do with the TARDIS being alive and telepathic, and trying to warn them that the fast-return-switch was broken.(Although it would have been simpler to ring the cloister bells or something.)Icecreamdif 22:29, May 3, 2011 (UTC)

No I think you misunderstood me. I am sure that the writers of Edge of destruction had intended for the episode to be concluded after the two episodes. What I was trying to say is that Stephen Moffat may be a clever enough writer to have seen possibility in that episode and to write elements of that into this season's story arc so as to link back to it. Again that was just a side note in this thread and highly unlikely, mostly I am interested in scenes in Moffat written stories and in series 5 as a whole that may be interperated as a charachter seeing silence.MasterIII 03:14, May 4, 2011 (UTC)

Someone just pointed out to me a few things to add to this, all in the soundtrack:


 * The background music that's used as the Silence theme in the series 6 opener also appears in various places in series 5.


 * The "electronic lion purr" sound that follows the Silence around also appeaed in various places.


 * The high pitched noise right after the Doctor interrupts the companions having their huddled conversation underneath the TARDIS control panel appeared multiple times, often near lines about Silence, but also in A Christmas Carol and other places that don't seem relevant.

At this point, I'm just forwarding someone else's idea; I haven't gone back and watched series 5 yet to see if there's anything to it... not that I'm complaining about having another good excuse to do so. :) --99.33.24.89 11:13, May 28, 2011 (UTC)

Also, on the Edge of Destruction bit, it's not impossible that the Moff thought about that. He's talked about rewatching the early episodes recently, and he's retroactively added "unintended premonitions" into past episodes before, albeit mostly his own RTD-era episodes. (In fact, this episode may have another one: What happened when the Doctor and Martha were stranded in 1969 in Blink, and did it have anything to do with the fact that for some reason they ended up watching the moon landing 4 times?) Edge also seems to have some premonitions of The Doctor's Wife. (And the classic story that episode referenced most directly, War Games, was the 1969 story where Zoe's and Rory's memories were wiped, and the Doctor went off on his "Season 6B" adventures that nobody remembered until the Virgin novels decades later... a lot more happened than most people remember indeed....) --99.33.24.89 11:29, May 28, 2011 (UTC)

The bit about Amy fiddling with the Tardis console and then acting like she had no idea what she'd just done, was extremely alarming to me the first time I saw it. It reminded me of Turlough, albeit that Turlough knew what he was doing at the time. I'd be very interested in a list of "electronic lion purr" noises and musical cues, such as 99.33 mentions.

Also, some things are a bit odd to me about the warning Prisoner Zero gives the Doctor: 1- PZ is the Doctor's enemy, so it doesn't make sense for PZ to give helpful clues. It seems more like a taunt. 2- Why would the fall of the Silence's dominion over earth, be a taunt? Was demonizing the Silence a mistake? 3- Same question if it's a warning... why warn the Doctor that evil domineering aliens will fall?

Some of these elements surrounding the Silence are starting to seem like an arsepull... let's hope not. Agonaga 04:18, May 31, 2011 (UTC)


 * Maybe the fall of the Silence is somehow connected to what ultimately led to the army of Clerics. Or maybe the Silence are a lot less local than we thought, and Silence Will Fall (in the opposite sense) over the rest of the galaxy, even though the Silence have fallen on Earth. Or...


 * Anyway, I think it's intentional that "Silence Will Fall" can have two opposite meanings (much as "Miranda Cleaves" can, "cleaves" being the English word most famous for having two opposite meanings...), but I don't think the Moff worked out to do with those two opposite meanings until this season, so it'll be hard to work out too much of the plot by watching season 5. --99.8.228.227 04:00, June 5, 2011 (UTC)

I think it makes sense that the Silence were in the TARDIS during Series 5 at least because they were most likely the ones who cause the TARDIS to blow up. Putting that together with Amy fiddling with the TARDIS controls suddenly makes sens: I haven't watched "Pandorica" in a while, but does it seem possible that the Silence told River to land outside Amy's house on June 26, 2010? River, unlike Amy, has experience flying the TARDIS, and knows what controls are what even better than the Doctor. Also, I've heard a lot about instances in "The Lodger" where Amy may see a Silent while in the TARDIS and then acts confused as if she's forgotten something. I also think that the ship using the perception filter in "The Lodger" was owned by the Silence; it returns in "The Impossible Astronaut"/"Day of the Moon". Craig is coming back this fall, so maybe that's when this will be solved. Glimmer721 23:58, July 5, 2011 (UTC)

P.S. For scenes in "The Lodger", see this video Glimmer721 00:25, July 6, 2011 (UTC)

In The Pandorica Opens just before the TARDIS explode theres a voice that say it again “Silence will fall“ and is not the voice of the Silence. Why would Silence say that anyway? Bmaria 15:10, July 6, 2011 (UTC)

I'm starting to wonder: if Prisoner Zero came through that crack in the wall, did anything else come through?Boblipton 16:50, July 6, 2011 (UTC)

Probably not. The Doctor only opened the crack for a couple of seconds, and we saw the crack the whole time it was open. A Silence could have come through, and we just forgot about it, but why would it. The Silence have been on Earth since the wheel and the fire, so why would they have to come to 90s Earth through a time crack?Icecreamdif 05:50, July 7, 2011 (UTC)

I just noticed in this picture if you look at the middle left there are some cowled figures that look a lot like the Silence. Also there have been several images of Silence wearing monks robes, this fits with my theory that the Headless Monks are somehow connected with the Silence. 200.199.23.121 14:07, September 12, 2011 (UTC)
 * Those are Roboforms, nothing to do with the Silence. Also on whether the Silence could've had a hand in Edge of Destruction I would say: highly probable at the moment. I believe Steven Moffat or someone else connected to the series said something about the Silence influencing for much longer than anyone expected and mentioned the lack of memory of as prelude to the possibility they have been influencing things around the Doctor his entire life. The Light6 01:07, September 13, 2011 (UTC)


 * Well, that could explain every discontinuity in the history of the show: the Doctor's age, the 2nd Doctor thinking Time Lords are immortal, everyone on Gallifrey forgetting about the Eye of Harmony, the Daleks not recognizing the Doctor in two stories where they should have, the Doctor and the Master forgetting they were loomed, Time Lords using the Looms in the first place (because they forgot that the Curse of Pythia never actually worked), the Delgado Master being both his 1st and 13th incarnations, the 1st Doctor's single pulse and the conflicting explanations that have been given, when the UNIT stories happened, the first four Doctors frequently mixing up the words "galaxy" and "universe", the TARDIS sometimes being able to translate written (even smell-based) language and sometimes not, whether TARDISes are built or grown, most of War of the Daleks, the multiple first times the Doctor met Shakespeare (and which incarnation helped him write which play), … :) --50.0.128.155 02:51, September 13, 2011 (UTC)


 * So can lack of infinite amounts of time to do the research on older works. Boblipton 03:26, September 13, 2011 (UTC)
 * One day, Gary Russell will end up as show-runner on Doctor Who, and there will never be a single continuity error in the 13 episodes he oversees before he gets the show canceled. :) --50.0.128.155 04:18, September 13, 2011 (UTC)

Why would the Silence have been involved in Edge of Destruction. The events of that episode were all explained by the TARDIS trying to warn the Doctor and friends that the spring on the fast return switch was broken (maybe that's why they recalled all the type 40s). If any recent episode makes that story make more sense than it's The Doctor's Wife. Even if the Silence were somehow involved in that episode, what could they possibly have hoped to gain? As for the Silence being behind every continuity error in the series, that seems more than a little unlikely. What, for example, would the Silence gain by making the Second Doctor think that Time Lords are immortal (and though not strictly immortal they are incredibly long lived barring accidents. Didn't it take the First Doctor 500 years to die of old age, and if you go all 13 lives without accidents, a layman might call that immortal) Same with confusing the Master about which incarnation he's in, or making everyone forget what year it is. The Silence wouldn't seem to have anything to gain from this.Icecreamdif 04:20, September 13, 2011 (UTC)

The notion of the Silence being involved in The Edge of Destruction is at least slightly daft. The possibility that it could have contributed to Moffat's ideas, however, is not -- it's just unprovable. If it did contribute, even Moffat himself might not have been concsious of the fact. As I recall, The Edge of Destruction was, in effect, the TARDIS playing a game of charades to try to get across the notion "out of time" because the stuck switch was continuing to tell her to travel backwards in time, when there was no earlier time she could travel to. She had, quite literally, run out of time. A voice interface would have been useful on that occasion.

It's much more plausible that so-far unexplained, seemingly minor events in The Eleventh Hour and later episodes might be down to the Silence -- not retrospectively "explained away" by their influence but always intended to be part of their story -- because Moffat was in a position to put such things into the show by then. It's not merely possible that the Silence have been around since the start of Series 5. They were. Moffat might not have had all the details worked out, but he certainly had enough to make Prisoner Zero say, "Silence will fall, Doctor." Any further back than The Eleventh Hour is a shade unlikely, however. --89.242.76.105 08:34, September 13, 2011 (UTC)

People keep taking my comment about the Edge of Destruction seriously. Don't take my comments about EoD literaly. All I was trying to say was that I could see elements in EoD that might suggest a silent in the Tardis as far back as that episode. I had watched The Day of the Moon as well as a video looking at the clips of series 5 that might have been slients on Youtube just prior to rewatching EOD. It was an amusement to me to think that Moffat might be trying to tie things back to the third story of Doctor Who. Do I think that is really the case, no of course not. I agree that it is highly unlikely that that is the case. I guess I was trying to suggest that those reading this post should watch the episode over with the idea that a silent had gotten into the Tardis, just once. They should h ave a laugh with this notion and then go back to the original intent behind the episode (which I agree is much more closely tied to the Doctor’s Wife).

Completely separate from the EOD discussion:

What I do believe (until this theory is proved wrong) is that there are silents in series 5 that will be revealed as series 6 concludes (including one wandering around inside the Tardis). Again the scene with Amy in the console room for the first time still doesn’t sit right with me. MasterIII 23:57, September 13, 2011 (UTC)

That really doesn't look like its anything more than Amy just playing with the buttons and being surprised when it makes a noise. I doubt the Silence have anything to do with it. The only time in season 5 whereit reeally seems likely that a Silence is present is during The Pandorica Opens when River was in the TARDIS and it blew up.Icecreamdif 00:25, September 14, 2011 (UTC)