Talk:What If? (feature)

Validity
Someone added an invalid tag, which is a shame I’ve put a lot of effort incorporating this into other articles, but I think it should be discussed.

I personally believe it should be valid. For a start the illustration is completely in universe as are many of the piece in it. I’d argue it could also pass rule 4 by proxy as the following year an illustration of the Griffiths Doctor in the same outfit as What If?. I think this was meant to be part of a meta-fictional DWU.

In fact a change to rule 4 along the lines of “is it meant to take place in the DWU or a meta-fictional world about Doctor Who” could be helpful. Either way. I strongly support the validity of this. It’s a what if other world scenario. Like Deadline being Unbound. It’s the same situation. 81.108.82.15talk to me 00:22, 19 March 2023 (UTC)