Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/Planet of the Ood


 * The Doctor does not seem affected by the Ood Sphere's cold weather, but in The Abominable Snowmen, he felt it necessary to don a fur coat while travelling in the mountains of Tibet.
 * If the Doctor had a more frail body, he would have felt to cold more.
 * Necessary could mean as a fashion accessory.


 * When Halpen and Ryder first go to Warehouse 15, Halpen pours his "hair tonic" onto the Ood Brain. When he retreats from the edge of the containment area, there is still tonic in his glass which he drinks and then leaves.
 * Ood Sigma passes him another glass. You can just about see his arm lowering as Halpen begins to lift the glass.


 * The Ood Brain has a bad reaction to the hair tonic, why don't Ood suffer from it.
 * Technically, it wasn't a bad reaction. Since the 'hair tonic' was actually to turn Halpen into an Ood, it is likely that the liquid helped the Ood Brain to strengthen.
 * Of course, I'm pretty sure pouring an energy drink on your brain wouldn't feel too good either.


 * As the Ood begin to turn bad, the Ood behind Solana briefly stops panicking.


 * Ood fighting against the armed guards are seen not to be suffering from Red Eye.


 * When the Doctor and Donna are escaping Warehouse 15, Solona Mercurio joins out of nowhere.
 * Solana can be seen coming around the corner of the container just after the first security guard is killed by the Ood.


 * The Doctor criticises Donna's apparent hypocrisy, pointing out that her clothes were made by, effectively, slave labour. However, in Gridlock, he says that Janis Joplin gave him his coat, implying that it is a coat which was made on Earth and would therefore have been made in similar conditions.
 * Not necessarily, as Janis Joplin was a folk singer from the Hippie culture of the 1960's and not likely to have owned much in the way of mass produced clothing from sweatshops.
 * The Doctor, however, wasn't being hypocritical.


 * Why wasn't Ood Sigma affected by Red Eye?
 * As the Doctor explained, the Ood Brain had different feelings. One of them was rage and anger, which most of the Ood felt, giving them red eye. Ood Sigma, however, received the intelligence and patience of the Brain, which helped to turn Halpen into an Ood over a long period of time.


 * In Blood of the Cybermen, the Doctor tells Amy that she is protected from the cold by the TARDIS. Donna, however, feels the cold.
 * The Doctor could have upgraded the TARDIS since then, given his increasing number of adventures in the cold and lack of a heavier jacket.
 * In fact, it's not hard to imagine that Donna, immediately after this story, asked the Doctor whether he can do anything about the cold, and then he did.


 * Also, if there were a discontinuity, it would be with the later story, not this one.