User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-24894325-20161008100044/@comment-25117610-20180717203809

User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-24894325-20161008100044/@comment-25117610-20180717203809 As suggested by User:Amorkuz on Talk:The Eleven, I'll bring my opinion over here: I believe each incarnation of the Time Lords gets it's own page.

As per Forum:The Master, it was decided the Master's incarnation wouldn't get separate pages "There is simply no in-universe way to do it that will be commonly understood or agreed" (quoting CzechOut). And even Romana, who has no IU names for incarnations, gets pages such as Romana I and Romana II because these names are wildly used OOU. That said, we do have names for each incarnation of the Eleven.

So it makes absolutely no sense to me having information which happened to the Eight on a page called the Eleven, because they are separate incarnations. We would never describe events from An Unearthly Child on the War Doctor page, because those events happened during another incarnation.

Concerns about a "main page" (like the Doctor or Romana) seems fair, but not really a pressing corcern. Yes, we have no name the refer to the Time Lord without using an incarnation number, but pages like this are far less edited/used than incarnation pages (that is, Romana II is edited/used and linked to more than Romana). If and until we have a name for them, we'll be okay without such "main page", because we kind of already don't have it.