User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-27280472-20161218221939/@comment-1272640-20170105013818

User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-27280472-20161218221939/@comment-1272640-20170105013818 SOTO wrote: SOTO wrote: In other words, even if it briefly passed Rule 4, it was never officially released in that capacity, so fails Rule 3, at the very least. This was never going to pass the four little rules. If anything, it would be covered as a cancelled story, or an invalid source. What would?

We're talking about Moon Eyes, which, while published in a charity anthology, was published in a charity anthology by the license holder. We typically exclude charity publications because they're basically fanfiction. In this case, Obverse published an anthology, but had the proceeds go to charity. It's licensed.