User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-25117610-20170221193933/@comment-25117610-20170311221554

Well, we do have a "cut-off point" to making categories, so I fell like a "Rule of X" for lists of appearances wouldn't do us harm.

TheChampionOfTime wrote: Padrac has appeared in six stories and he will probably never appear in one ever again. Well, if we'd make a rule, such specific cases should not come in mind. That aside, I got the very opposite impression from the end of Stop the Clock. Whatever might come next, I feel like he'll very much return (but will stop it here, as this is not the focus of the thread, and could become spoiler-ish).

For me, as soon as a "X" number of appearances is achieved (whatever "X" number we end up deciding), a list is made. But I agree with Amorkuz: for characters who appear on different media (or different series, like Ollistra, or even non-consecutive appearances on the same series, like Padrac), it is specially important to have the list: listing the name of the series (or, even, anthologies) in which they appear can be very helpfull while searching information.