User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-4028641-20151101035254/@comment-24894325-20160320014419

I also believe that it is better to finally make a decision than to wait for a perfect consensus on a perfect decision. It would be good to have the Osgoods sorted out before the second UNIT audio box featuring one of them is released in June.

1. Osgood's First Name. I agree with Bwburke94 that this point should be removed from discussion. Our disagreements do no affect editing either way.

3. Disambiguation if human and identity share a page. If it is decided that they share a page, then the disambiguation would apply to both, not only to the identity. The earliest story where either human or identity appeared is The Day of the Doctor, so I don't believe Osgood (The Day of the Doctor) would be really problematic in this case.

4. Name for the Zygon Osgoods sisters. There is no need to take Bonnie into account. She creates no additional trouble. As for the name for the first Zygon Osgood, there were three versions: Zygon Osgood, Zygon (Osgood) and Osgood (Zygon).

I think everyone said their piece and argued it exhaustively. The discussion faded naturally when there was nothing new to say. There is no new information and will not likely to be in the near future: UNIT audios are set before The Day of the Doctor.

If I may make a proposal: can we just vote on this? After trying to narrow down the questions to be voted on, for instance to 2. and 4.? If necessary, each side could summarize the arguments for each variant being voted on.