User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-86.178.203.198-20140629173408/@comment-6032121-20201007165425

User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-86.178.203.198-20140629173408/@comment-6032121-20201007165425 I'd typed a lengthier closing post when this was originally closed prior to the Great Discussions Data Loss Incident, but nothing you couldn't get from reading through this debate, which reached a pretty clear consensus long ago. This passes Rule 1 and Rule 4; anything more, such as whether to consider this a novel vs. an anthology, to be taken to the relevant talk pages.