Board Thread:Inclusion debates/@comment-188432-20130914014029/@comment-5791028-20150519031019

I'm not sure you do understand my point. Yes, Richard Hurndall played the First Doctor in The Five Doctors. But he was doing it in the style of William Hartnell, just as the actors Master of Spiders mentioned do in the audio plays. By contrast, Trevor Martin is doing his own version of the Doctor that doesn't correspond to any of the televised Doctors. That is the point I was trying to make.

The other play adaptations are all right because one is a Sixth Doctor story and the other doesn't feature the Doctor at all. But unless you can give me an argument for how the Trevor Martin Doctor can possibly fit into continuity, I stick by what I said about why it should be Non-DWU.