User talk:The Librarian

Continuity: the story titles should be italicised. (The way to work out references from continuity is. References are in-universe and if there's a lot of them organised under category headings (see...Alien Bodies for an example), continuity is out of universe.)

External Links: The external links website title is too long and non-specific. The web link should make reference to the site's name it's linking to, with brief explanation. The The Millennium Blag page I edited slightly, so now it reads 'Doctor Who - Battles in Time official website, with trading cards details', less wordy, still all the information, it also doesn't need a full stop at the end, it's a weblink in a list (even if it's the only one there, it's still bullet pointed.


 * Hi there - just passing through and thought I'd say hello - a really nice page on BiT. Was very amused that some of the isolated images I couldn't remember drawing :) Speaking of which - back to the drawing board for issue 59! Lee Sullivan 20:45, 8 September 2008 (UTC)


 * To paraphrase the Dalek movies; Every move you make I see, every sound you utter I hear...(sounds a lot less creepy in the 60s Dalek voices with the lights flashing not in sync with the voices). I'm always around here. I didn't notice, but have just seen (re Lee Sullivan). As far as promotions category wise it would probably go in Category:Doctor Who merchandise, probably in a subcategory or two. If there are a lot of promotional give aways for each (the Weetabix, chips, cereal etc) then each should be in a separate category. So maybe (within the DW merchandise category) it can be Category:Doctor Who promotional items, then within that category; Category:Weetabix Doctor Who promotions and so on. Get back to me if I've (as is sometimes the case) jumped on the wrong horse. --Tangerineduel 07:48, 17 September 2008 (UTC)

Doctor Who Power Rollers
On first glance I thought these might be a photoshop mockup! We really are in odd times of Doctor Who Merchandising! What the hell are 'Doctor Who Power Rollers'? It seems to live up to the 'slap a Doctor Who logo on it and they'll buy anything' mentality (or am I just being A) Cynical or B) not understanding the concept?) Or both. Ah...for the good ole days of Dapol where they'd release a different coloured Dalek for ever occasion and a green K9. Merry Christmas. --Tangerineduel 13:20, 24 December 2008 (UTC)


 * And a Happy New Year to you. Aren't Frubes the yogurt...things. Doctor Who branded yogurt...things. It's no worse than Dalek Ice Rays and other food related Doctor Who things. Don't worry about the BIT things, however I have made it easier, no typing involved anymore just select 'Doctor Who: Battles in Time magazines and cards' from the licensing selector when you're at the upload section, just scroll down it's under magazines. This'll add it automatically, no typing involved. --Tangerineduel 16:30, 2 January 2009 (UTC)

The Darksmith Legacy
Here's a link to the Manual of Style for the TARDIS Wikia: Tardis:Manual of style. This will help you to structure your articles more in line with the rest of the site.

I really hope all that writing doesn't sound like I'm putting you down. You asked what I thought so I've given some constructive criticism which I hope will really focus all your enthusiasm into making some great articles. The potential is definitely there. Definitely don't worry about making mistakes, every one does. I look forward to working with you further on making the TDL articles among the best on the site! User: Clockwork Apricot

Gisella
Could you please come back to the Gisella article you started and, at a minimum, give a list of appearances and/or fill out an infobox? The article has stirred up some controversy (see Talk:Gisella) because the lack of sources has made some editors unsure it's "real", verifiable information. Thanks :)  Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  08:38, 7 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Seems to have progressed a bit since your break, so it's not as objectionable as when I left the note. But, hey, while I've got you online:  a question about TDL.  From what I can tell of the online site, the contents there amount to easter eggs.  Is it more substantive than that?  I mean, is there new fiction there which is genuinely different or greater than what's in the books?  Should we also create a page about the website itself so that people can cite it using the WEB prefix?  Or is there nothing on the cite which one would likely reference in an article?   Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  21:58, 13 May 2009 (UTC)

Comic infoboxes
Because of your past work on filling out a lot of comic-related material, your views are invited on a proposal to radically alter the comic infobox. Please come to the forum thread and give your views. Thanks!  Czech Out  ☎ | ✍  17:02, 15 May 2009 (UTC)
 * These have now been implemented. Please refer to template:infobox Comic for detailed instructions.  If you have further questions, or find some flaw in the programming as you enter strips, please let me know.   Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  02:06, 23 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Thanks for the note :) Whatcha mean "online publication"?  I might need to put in another little variable there.  Are we talking about exclusive online comics?    If you'd give me an example I can probably recommend the best way forward.  Need to be careful, though: most online comics aren't actually licensed, and therefore would be outside the scope of this wiki.  Anyway, keep me informed of any problems you're having as and when you use the template.   Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  23:58, 24 May 2009 (UTC)


 * The Return of the Vostok was an online exclusive Torchwood comic. Americanwhofan 00:52, 25 May 2009 (UTC)
 * Right, okay, but that's about the only one I can think of. The Whoniverse isn't like the SW Universe, where official online comics have been going on for years.  Nevertheless I did add a variable to allow for a website as the place of first publication.  Check out improvements to The Return of the Vostok for how to use the template with webcomics.


 * I've also taken on board your query about online BIT online reprint thingie. There's now a variable called web reprint which allows you to define a site for the official reprint of comics that otherwise first appeared in magazines.  I'll wager, though, that this BIT reprint is the only of its kind, and even it's not a very straightforward re-release of a comic to a webiste.  About the only "official" release of a comic to a website I can think of are the Radio Times Eighth Doctor thingies, which were reprinted online by permission of the creative team (and one assumes the BBC).   Czech Out   ☎ | ✍  00:58, 26 May 2009 (UTC)

Easter egg
Well, I'm the one that expanded it to contain both usages, following the broadcast of POTD. So i think it should be both meanings on one page. They are related, after all. A DVD Easter egg wouldn't be called an "easter egg" were it not for the holiday treat.  Czech Out  ☎ | ✍  01:47, 18 May 2009 (UTC)