Board Thread:Inclusion debates/@comment-20607870-20161120213354/@comment-1789834-20161121151659

DENCH-and-PALMER wrote: Does this mean The Name of the Doctor is invalid because She Said, He Said is? Surely not.

It's nothing to do with what references what. I think that's where you're getting tangled up. Your conclusion is that the Wiki deems anything referencing an invalid source as invalid. This isn't the case. It's to do with the storyline and what's happening in-universe.

The Name of the Doctor would only be considered invalid if it ever went against the flow of events preceding it. It has nothing to do with She Said, He Said. You need to treat the Whoniverse as though it really happened. Only then will this issue become clear. I used to have a similar problem with defining "TV story" until I realised it had nothing to do with the medium by which you watched a story haha.

Hope this clears things up.