User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-1272640-20161223201024/@comment-1272640-20161224000227

Fwhiffahder wrote: Pluto2 wrote: Fwhiffahder wrote: It's specifically the Ninth Doctor. I don't see why it should move. Then should we classify it as an alternate universe Doctor (but still valid)? It would be more accurate than NOTVALID, but still — strictly speaking, the two should be equally "correct" versions. Just use the "according to one account" language. And comment on the mention of three Ninth Doctors in (I think) The Tomorrow Windows.

Not that any of it really matters. This thread isn't likely to go anywhere. It's more likely that an admin will swoop in and peremptorily close it, claiming that it's already been settled. Well, as I've said, we've never had a formal discussion on Shalka, as the decision was just tossed out there during the Infinity Doctors debate and no one commented on it, so it was labelled a decision with no debate at all.