Howling:Doctor's Death

So I believe that the doctor killed in the begining of series 6 was the ganger doctor the only proof I have is that the doctor that got killed was wearing the wrong shoes, the doctor mentioned that they were both there when he got killed and it mentioned it in the recap of the ganger episode ... reasons why not cause I figured it out. Cory Jaynes 03:48, August 3, 2011 (UTC) &nbsp

If you have any proof for/against post it here. Cory Jaynes 03:49, August 3, 2011 (UTC)
 * I don't remember the Doctor wearing the wrong pair of shoes...do you have a picture? -- Bold  Clone  03:51, August 3, 2011 (UTC)

This has been brought up many times before. The future Doctor in The Impossible Astronaut is definitely wearing different shoes from the present Doctor we see through the rest of the episode. Then, in The Rebel Flesh, his shoes are destroyed by the acid, and he has to change into new ones—but the ganger copied the Doctor before that happened, so he has the Doctor's old shoes. Amy pointedly notices their different shoes at 03:55 in The Almost People, and uses them to distinguish the two. Then, at the end of the episode, we learn that at some point they switched shoes to trick Amy. So, the ganger Doctor ends up in the future shoes, which the real one returns to the TARDIS in the present shoes.

Except that, if you actually look, this is backward. The "present Doctor shoes" in TIA are low 4-hole brown shoes with thick laces. Those aren't the shoes he's wearing when he lands at the monastery. (In fact, I think he's changed multiple times: it looks like he has different shoes in the second half of Moon, yet another pair in Black Spot, and a 4th pair in Wife and the start of Flesh.) But, guess which shoes he puts on after burning his new shoes? When you see the two Doctors side by side at 03:55, the real Doctor, on the right, is clearly wearing the 4-hole brown shoes from TIA. So, after they swap, the ganger ends up dying in the present-Doctor shoes, while the real Doctor walks into the TARDIS wearing the future-Doctor shoes.

The Doctors switched shoes to trick Amy into thinking she knew who the real Doctor was, and Moffat switched shoes before that to trick the fans who'd caught last year's jacket into thinking they knew who the future Doctor was. Very clever. (And even more clever that most full-body shots of the Doctor throughout the season show him from the ankles up, so you have to watch very carefully to catch his shoes.)

Of course that doesn't mean it can't be the ganger who died. As if it wasn't obvious that people can change shoes whenever they want, he's already changed again by the middle of Good Man. Then again, it's also possible that the real Doctor dies, and the ganger (stabilized by the TARDIS, just like Jimmy and Dicken) takes his place for the rest of the series (or until the current timeline gets aborted). Or the ganger Doctor could be completely irrelevant. Moffat wants to make sure we're in suspense.

Anyway, here are some screenshots that I found online. To get a better view, find the scene on your DVR and watch for a few seconds; the lighting is changing in all four shots, which means the caps aren't very good.

--173.228.85.118 06:11, August 3, 2011 (UTC)
 * The Impossible Astronaut 07:57: future Doctor's corpse
 * The Impossible Astronaut 16:49: present Doctor
 * The Almost People 03:54: shoes side by side
 * A Good Man Goes to War' 31:55: Doctor in future shoes 

Sorry, I don't know how to get them to come up as images, so you'll have to click the links. --173.228.85.118 06:12, August 3, 2011 (UTC)

Okay so the fact that people can change shoes is kinda a good point ... but its a t.v. show and most people in t.v. shows don't really change shoes and clothes that much ... but they have been hinting at it ... but like i said it does seem to be a very popular theory so it maybe wrong ... if anybody else has a theory i wouldn't mind hearing it. Cory Jaynes 01:09, August 4, 2011 (UTC)

I like it. The thought that the killed Doctor was the ganger occurred to me after the two-parter, but it struck me as too early. However, the shoes are a clue on the exact order of the Doctor's jacket is Series Six. Of course that means that Moffat is repeating the type of clue, which means it is likely a red herring, which means w won't expect it, making it a wonderful clue.....Boblipton 01:43, August 4, 2011 (UTC)

@Cory Jaynes: It's true that people on TV don't change nearly as often as in real life, and that's even more true on Doctor Who. But not this season. Also, as I mentioned above, this season's episodes are full of shots of the Doctor from his ankles up. So, I'm pretty sure Moffat is deliberately teasing the fans, because he remembers everyone figuring out the jacket last year. --173.228.85.118 04:50, August 4, 2011 (UTC)

Okay right ... but off the shoe thing ... does anybody think that river calling the doctor calling an impossible man at the end of "Forest of the Dead" have anything to do with his death? Cory Jaynes 04:16, August 5, 2011 (UTC)

Probably not. It doesn't sound like she's talking about anything particular in his history, so much as the general point that he's just impossible to predict and capable of doing the impossible (with the joking double meaning that he's impossible to deal with). She's said similar things many times, after all. --173.228.85.118 09:38, August 7, 2011 (UTC)