User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Reference Desk/@comment-6433721-20130212041323/@comment-6433721-20130215072123

In that case, the pages referenced here should be edited to reflect the ambiguity, right? We don't actually know from the narrative yet except from the Doctor's word, so we shouldn't be saying the kidnapping definitely happened before Amy went to America - especially since the Lodger indicates that at least one of the Silence projects is abandoned in our era.