User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-31010985-20191101112654/@comment-1350697-20191105155159

My opinion in previous threads has consistently been that these are obviously valid -- the addition of Life After Death only confirms this stance. Every bar has been either neatly or more than thoroughly met.

Borisashton gets at a good point at the end of the opening post here, though: If Miranda Dawkins, a companion and adopted daughter of the Eighth Doctor, is in White Canvas, then surely excluding these stories would be a much, much more severe slippery slope, leading to the exclusion of hundreds upon hundreds of currently considered-valid stories, than the inclusion of these stories would be?