User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-1296654-20200630105828/@comment-1296654-20200630121732

The way I see it, we can either be strict and keep relations solely with the first Doctor to whom it applies (John, Gillian and Susan to First, River to Eleventh) or if the Doctor identifies them as a relation (John and Gillian to First and Second, Susan to First and Eighth, River to Eleventh and Twelfth).

The problem with the latter option is where to draw the line. The Fourth Doctor says that River is his wife in Diary of River Song but he hasn't married her yet. Fifth met Susan in The Five Doctors, so that does mean she should be added to his infobox? If Thirteenth mentions River in passing, should she be added?

I think we need an actual, proper rule about who qualifies.