Talk:Whoisdoctorwho.co.uk

Sightings
I've removed the "Sightings Page" section, which was just a straight copy of this page from Who is Doctor Who?. Apart from the copyright issues inherent in copying and pasting an entire BBC webpage into the wiki verbatim, since the page was user-generated the sightings and names cannot be considered canon and are unsuitable for in-universe listing here. For example, I wrote one of those entries myself back then; I don't think that makes me (or my old boss whose name I signed to it as a joke) eligible for inclusion in this wiki as an in-universe character. It is now impossible to tell which, if any, of those entries were written by BBC staff rather than enthusiastic fans, so on this basis I cannot see any alternative but to reject the "sightings" page's canonicity.

The submitters' listed names - some of which were signed as Whoniverse characters, some other fictional characters like "Marty McFly" or "Arthur Dent," most of which were just random screennames - were wikilinked. Most of the screennames were redlinks, but some have been given their own in-universe articles consisting of nothing more than their contribution to this fan-generated webpage. I'm now going through those and nominating them for deletion, pointing back to this talk page for the explanation and rationale. Rob T Firefly 06:05, October 6, 2010 (UTC)