User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-25566332-20131018141233/@comment-1506468-20131026175251

I read Lungbarrow this January, and the character is still pretty fresh in my mind. This is set quite a few years after Genesis of the Daleks, and Ferain claims to have always worked for the CIA, so it makes it unlikely that it is Valyes.

Lungbarrow does contradict Gallifrey in other areas: Leela and Romana first meet in Lungbarrow, yet do the same in Neverland.

Trying to fit Lungbarrow and Ascension together is pretty much impossible in this regard. I wasn't particularly a fan of Gary Russell's insistence on making contradicting Lungbarrow, especially since I'd loved the book. It goes into the realms of speculation to merge Valyes and Ferain. It's the rules of the wiki to keep things as accurate as possible, and merging the two articles would go against that.

It sucks, admittedly, but that's the case with this one.