User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Reference Desk/@comment-25566332-20121215234206/@comment-188432-20121221214626

It's not that you're beating a dead horse. It's that, for some inexplicable reason, December seems to be the month of questions about the validity of obscure parts of the DWU. And there's only so much detailed discussion about the validity of sources that the user base can take at one time.

We've had several debates on this matter already, so I this matter has actually been settled already. You are meant to make the inference you are making. Namely, if a video game has multiple endings — like the DYD and FYF books — then it's not valid, because we have no mechanism — unlike the Star Wars universe – for deciding which path is the "correct" one.