User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Help!/@comment-32744161-20181012183405/@comment-6032121-20181012225450

User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Help!/@comment-32744161-20181012183405/@comment-6032121-20181012225450 Shambala108 wrote: And ScroogeMacDuck, please do not derail forum threads to complain about the rules. If you have a problem/question, either post on the policy's talk page or contact the admin in question. See Tardis:Discussion policy and Tardis:Forum policy.

I didn't really derail it myself, though. I made a passing remark as part of the on-topic discussion, which was picked up by Snivystorm — and when I replied to that, it was prefacing with the warning that this was veering into off-topic, and ended with a return to the main topic, through which I meant to close the "harshness" discussion.

Which I'll do again! If it ain't broke, don't fix it, and all that.

So about your answer — The Howling is all very nice, and apparently you were well-inspired to remind Snivystorm of its existence, but it's not really the same thing. It's a place for users to post their own personal theories, which isn't really what I at least was talking about earlier — the reasonable, tone-appropriate, plothole-solving speculation that would absolutely be of interest to the casual reader, not just to fans looking for individual fans' own ideas.