User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-4028641-20170322025232/@comment-4028641-20171210075330

Bwburke94 wrote: No, I suggest that we cover TIDH (the individual comics) as non-valid. Surely you mean that we "don't cover TIDH as non-valid," because we can't cover something like this as non-valid. That just doesn't make sense.

Presumably, you're trying to say that the linking segments alone should be valid and the parts without modern narration shouldn't be valid. My point was that there are, again, instances of new narration in the middle of the flashbacks, so it's not as if you can just split up the scenes set on Maruthea and the flashbacks.

Bwburke94 wrote: How does this differ from Frankenstein?

It doesn't, because we don't try to pretend that Frankenstein wasn't shown in the TV movie. Sure it was shown as media and not a flashback, which I'm sure is your main point, but it was still shown in the same way that these comics are "shown." The original version of Frankenstein isn't valid on our site, in the same way that the only valid version of these comics is the version printed in TIDH.