Planet of the Ood (TV story)

"The circle must be broken!"

- The Ood

Synopsis
After setting the TARDIS controls to random, the Doctor and Donna arrive on the Ood Sphere, in the 42nd century. The sentient Ood are being sold as servants to rich citizens of the Second Great and Bountiful Human Empire. But what is possessing the Ood? And what is the circle? Why must it be broken?

Plot
We watch through the eyes of Mr. Bartle an advertisement on the Ood, who are being sold as servants to Humans. Bartle is sarcastic yet somewhat impressed with the advert, until he notices that his bosses has cut the price to just 50 credits each. The man on the other end of the communicator tells him it is a measure to stay ahead of the competition, and orders him to get going. As he orders his Ood, Delta Fifty to hand him last month's military export figures, he tells Solana Mercurio over the radio to get their buyers to buy them when they arrive. His Ood gives him the domestic files, and tells him to get it right. However, rather than obeying, his eyes glows red and tells Bartle the files are irrelevant. When Bartle asks why, the Ood uses his translation sphere and presses it against his forehead, electrocuting and then killing him.

Meanwhile, the Doctor sets the TARDIS to random settings, effectively taking a mystery tour with Donna. After they land, Donna is excited, yet terrified about landing on an alien planet. However, as she steps out, she discovers they have landed on a cold, snowy planet. The Doctor is overjoyed at the sight of finally experiencing real snow. He then tells Donna, not knowing she sought refuge back on the TARDIS to change into warm clothing, says "all you've got is a life of work and sleep, and telly and rent and tax and takeaway dinners, all birthdays and Christmases and two weeks holiday here, and then you end up here! Donna Noble. Citizen of the Earth, standing on a different planet." He turns around and realises she is gone, before she steps out with a coat. They then look up to see a rocket passing overhead.

Klineman Halpen arrives to cover for Mr. Bartle. Immedietely it is proven that he is more arrogant than the predecessor. At his office, Halpen, Dr. Ryder and Solana see footage of his murder. They see that the translation orb is responsible, though Ryder cannot explain why. It is also learnt that after Bartle was killed, Delta Fifty escaped, but was shot in the process. While Ryder also says to have no idea about the source of red-eye, Halpen asks his Ood, Σ|Sigma for a drink; it is just merely hair tonic, since he started loosing his hair due to stress for five years.

While the Doctor and Donna roam the planet, the Doctor hears an eerie sound that Donna can't hear. He later finds an Ood on the floor, the same Ood that killed Bartle, dying. Though Donna seems disgusted by its look, though the Doctor seemly tells her the Ood's a he, not an it. While examining him, Donna keeps him talking for the Doctor to find out what has happened. He wants to know why Delta Fifty has been shot. The Ood merely says nothing more than "the circle must be broken" before suddenly getting up to attack the two, but before he could stand, he dies. The Doctor confirms to Donna that he encountered the Ood before, and they were all possessed by the Beast, but because the Beast no longer exists, there must be another source nearby accounting for the psychotic Ood. They then come across a building; Ood Operations.

Solana meets up with the buyers from outside the warehouse and tells them to come inside. Just then, the Doctorn and Donna arrive, and by using the psychic paper, they are able to convince her that they represent Noble Corporation PLC Limited, Intergalactic (a made-up company). Just then, they hear an alarm, which Solana claim is a siren for the end of a work shift. In actuality, the head of security, Commander Kess has reported an Ood on the loose. His team pursues the Ood, and eventually corner him. When he turns to the guards, they realise that it is more than a mere case of red-eye, but the Ood has turned rabid. Halpen orders Kess to send the Ood to Ryder.

Solana gives out the presentation on the Ood. She shows three different Ood, one with the standard voice, one with a sexy female voice, and comedy classic option (when being told the Ood drops something, he answers "D'oh" from The Simpsons). Afterwards, while the buyers are enjoying the buffet, the Doctor and Donna discover that they are at the Ood Sphere in the year 4126, during the Second Great and Bountiful Human Empire that spans three galaxies. Donna is fascinated that Earth is still populated, despite all the news articles stating the near end of the world, including global warming and the disappearance of bees. Donna then learns that the red dots on the maps are Ood distribution centres. She decides to talk to an Ood to see if they get a say in this. However, the Ood merely tells them that the Ood were born to serve, or they'd die out. The Ood then starts mentioning the circle. The pair decide they've had enough with wondering in the room and decide to peruse around the base or operations.

Halpen, Kess and Ryder take a look at the chained and rabid Ood. The trio are baffled that after two centuries, there is a change in them. Ryder suggests they go to Warehouse 15 to find answers, which Halpen reluctantly accepts. When being asked about what to do with the Ood, Halpen orders security to kill it. Meanwhile, the Doctor and Donna discover that the Ood are not servants; they are slaves. The Doctor regrets not knowing much about them during his last encounter, as he was busy fighting the Beast at the time. They then observe Halpen. Knowing he's the boss, they decide to stay out of his way.

Halpen, Ryder and Sigma enter Warehouse 15, where it is revealed that it houses the Ood Brain. Halpen reminisces his first time to Warehouse 15 when he was six years old, and is still horrified by those memories. Ryder checks the computers and finds no changes in the brain. Halpen is then interrupted by Solana, who informs him that she passed two members of the Noble corporation, which she found doesn't exist, and they are missing. Halpen orders security to search them, but to keep it under the radar, and no alarms.

The two have found access to a warehouse, where they find countless cargo containers. They break into one, where they see about a hundred Ood just standing. Donna wonders why the Ood won't just go free, but they merely say they don't understand the concept. When the Doctor mentions the circle, all the Ood, in unison say that the circle must be broken, so they can sing. Unfortunately, they are spotted by Kess, who raises the alarm, against Halpen's wishes. While Solana lies to the buyers and tells them it is just a mere fire drill, the Doctor and Donna run, but the latter is captured and taken to a container with Ood, who have turned to red-eye. Meanwhile, the Doctor is being chased by Kess, who uses a claw to try and probably kill him. Though the Doctor tries his best to evade it, he eventually falls, but is saved by Solana, who shuts down the claw's power and reminds Kess that Halpen wants the two alive. Security eventually lets Donna free, who was about to be killed by the Ood.

However, the guards unwittingly let the Ood escape from the container too, along with other containers, who starts killing the team. Kess and his men open fire, giving the Doctor, Donna and Solana enough time to escape. After making it out, Solana confirms that everyone on Earth knows about the Ood's predicament, but don't ask. Reluctantly, she points them to the direction where they make the Ood turn to slaves. However, she defects again and calls out for the guards to apprehend the two. Kess manages to contain the rabid Ood, but believes the entire batch is contaminated. With no alternative, Halpen orders Kess to get some gas canisters.

By the time the Doctor finds the area, he hears the Ood song getting stronger, though Donna still can't hear it. After they break into the room, they find several Ood in a cage. Donna asks the Doctor to let her hear the song. After he is able to open her mind to it, she quickly wants to stop hearing it, as it is a very sad song of captivity. While Halpen and the team attempt to break into the room, the Doctor enters the cage and discovers that they are natural Ood, and carry a hind brain; the corporation would "lobotomise" them by removing the brains and replace them with translation spheres. Donna notes that she spent a long time looking for the Doctor, hoping the universe would be a wonderful place, but didn't realise how much issues and horrors awaits also, and wants to go home. Moments later, Halpen and the team breaks in and arrests the two.

After they are handcuffed to some pipes, Halpen interrogates them, and gets them to confess that they are activists from Friends of the Ood. Halpen claims that without them, the Ood would be nothing, and claimed that when they turned them into slaves, "they welcomed it", though this was only because the Ood shown their hind brains because they wanted to trust the humans, but were instead exploited. The Doctor also learns that Halpen is going to gas the "livestock", which he claims is as effective as how the humans dealt with Foot and Mouth centuries ago. Meanwhile, since the natural Ood appear to have influence of the rest of their kind, they turn every Ood, apart from Sigma to red-eye. In the room with the buyers, Solana notices the Ood turns into red-eye, and urges the buyers to leave, when a drunk and ignorant buyer is killed, the rest obliges to her wishes, though many are electrocuted in the process. Solana escapes, but doesn't make it far; she too is killed by an Ood. Furthermore, as the gas canisters are counting down, Kess is captured by the Ood, who subsequently release the captured ones, and imprisons Kess without a gas mask. When they timer reaches zero, Kess dies from the released gas.

The corporation plans on evacuating, and then destroy the building; Halpen decides to leave the Doctor and Donna behind. The Doctor confronts him about a supposed third element, and wants to know what it is. Halpen replies "it won't exist for very much longer", before leaving. Halpen and Ryder make it down to Warehouse 15, while witnessing the Ood revolution in full swing. While the Doctor and Donna attempt to break free, without any success, three red-eyed Ood enter the room, and plan to kill them. The two of them repeatedly tells them "Doctor, Donna, friends" and "the circle must be broken". Through the mild telepathic link, the natural Ood is able to hear them, and they are able to revert the three Ood back to their normal selves. The Ood free both the Doctor and Donna, who are trying to find the source of the third element. On the way, they see Sigma, who was abandoned by Halpen to join his people; Sigma guides them to Warehouse 15.

Once inside, the Doctor finds the giant Ood brain, which is the Ood's telepathic centre. Six pylons surround the brain, which was used to dampen the telepathy between brain and Ood for 200 years, forcing them to be servents. They are interrupted by Halpen, who holds them at gun point. Ryder tells them that he has surrounded the area with mines to kill it. The Doctor theorises that the brain spent 200 years adapting to the pylons, but Ryder claims responsibility. He exposes himself as a member of Friends of the Ood; knowing that natural adapting process took too slow, he spent ten years going up the ladder, and when he finally had access to the warehouse a few hours previously, he lowered the barrier to its minimum. In response, Halpen pushes him over the edge, and is "swallowed" by the brain.

As he is about to shoot the Doctor and Donna, Sigma steps in and insists he take another drink. It is revealed that the "hair tonic" is infact Ood-graft suspended in a biological compound; this ultimately rewrites his biology, turning him into an Ood. They witness Halpen transforming into one in front of their eyes. The Doctor notes that the Ood subconsious is divided into three groups; the red-eye is revenge, rabid is anger, and the seemingly unaffected Sigma represents patience, and it has been preparing for Halpen for a long time. Donna notes that after being with the Doctor, she doesn't know what is right or wrong anymore, to which the Doctor replies "It's better that way. People who know for certain tend to be like Mr Halpen". After shutting down the mines, Sigma allows the Doctor to shut down the pylons damping the telepathic field; the circle is broken, the Ood can sing.

The song erupts to a new one, and everyone can hear it, even Donna. Outside, the fighting stops. While the Ood group themselves, the soldiers stand down. Afterwards, the Doctor and Donna are outside the TARDIS, and explains to Sigma that the song resontated to the three galaxies; the humans decide to free the Ood and send them back home. After Sigma thanks them, he offers them a place in their song, but the Doctor says he has his own song, but Sigma tells him his song will end soon, since every song must end. He turns to Donna, who changes her mind, and wants to continue her travels with him. Before they leave, Sigma tells them they will never be forgotten; their children and children's children will sing of the DoctorDonna, and their names will be carried by the Ood Sphere's wind, ice and snow forever.

Cast

 * The Doctor - David Tennant
 * Donna Noble - Catherine Tate
 * Solana Mercurio - Ayesha Dharker
 * Mr Halpen - Tim McInnerny
 * Sigma - Paul Kasey
 * Dr Ryder - Adrian Rawlins
 * Commander Kess - Roger Griffiths
 * Mr Bartle - Paul Clayton
 * Rep - Tariq Jordan
 * Ood - Paul Kasey
 * Voice of the Ood - Silas Carson

Production crew
to be added

Story Notes

 * The snow scenes were shot in a boiling hot week in August, using fake snow. This was done using tiny pieces of paper, as pointed out in this episode's Confidential.
 * The transformation of Halpen into an Ood was originally far more graphic, but after the footage was viewed it was re-edited to be less horrific for a family audience.
 * Russell T Davies noted during production of the Ood's introductory episodes that he considered their home world to be close to that of the Sensorites.
 * This episode was originally intended to be episode 2.
 * The theme of humans exploiting alien life had previously been touched upon in two Season 2 episodes of Torchwood that aired a few months before this episode: Meat and Reset. The difference here is that freedom for the aliens in the Torchwood episodes came through their deaths, whereas most of the Ood survive.
 * At one point in the episode, there is a shot from the Ood's point of view, showing a soldier raising a gun to shoot him. This may be a reference to the video game Metal Gear Solid 3, in which there is an identical shot from an identical point of view with an identical weapon being used (The Patriot).

Ratings

 * Final Ratings - 7.50 million viewers

Myths and rumours

 * This is set before The Impossible Planet. (Most fans assume this because the pre-publicity stated that we would find out why the Ood were slaves and the date for that story was 43k2.1 but we never found out what those numbers meant, and there is no reason why this cannot be after that story. If Impossible planet was after this story, all the ood on Sanctuary base would not be slaves. Not necessarily, it's possible the people on the sanctuary base did not hear about these events, as they may have been away from civilization for some time.)
 * A snippet of the separation music from Doomsday can be heard after the Ood tells the Doctor "you song will end soon." He also said that "every song must end." This led to speculation that this was a reference to Rose Tyler's return, and/or an imminent regeneration for the Doctor. It is also a reference to River Song in Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead, and to the end of Donna's time with the Doctor. All four are songs, and each one ended, as predicted by Ood Sigma. The notion of the Doctor's song ending soon is brought to his attention again by a slightly psychic human named Carmen in Planet of the Dead.

Filming Locations

 * Blue Circle Cement Works, East Aberthaw, The Vale of Glamorgan

Discontinuity, Plot Holes, Errors

 * When Halpen and Ryder first go to Warehouse 15, Halpen pours his "hair tonic" onto the Ood Brain. When he retreats from the edge of the containment area, there is still tonic in his glass which he drinks and then leaves.
 * The Ood Brain has a bad reaction to the hair tonic, why don't Ood suffer from it.
 * As the Ood begin to turn bad, the Ood behind Solana briefly stops panicking.
 * Ood fighting against the armed guards are seen not to be suffering from Red Eye.
 * When the Doctor and Donna are escaping Warehouse 15, Solona Mercurio joins out of nowhere.
 * When the Doctor and Donna are leaping to avoid the barrels that are exploding behind them, you can clearly see snow on the lens of the camera.
 * The Doctor criticises Donna's apparent hypocrisy, pointing out that her clothes were made by (effectively) slave labour. However, in Gridlock, he says that Janis Joplin gave him his coat, implying that it is a coat which was made on Earth and would therefore have been made in similar conditions. Not necessarily, as Janis Joplin was a folk singer from the Hippie culture of the 1960's and not likely to have owned much in the way of mass produced clothing from sweatshops.
 * The Red Eye Ood killed Kess by locking him in a cage and removing his gas mask when the gas turns on. Why don't they just electrocute him? Red Eye is revenge, so the Ood would want avenge the deaths of Kess's victims in the most horrorable way.
 * Why wasn't Ood Sigma affected by Red Eye? The Doctor points out that different emotions were expressed through different Ood. The red-eye was revenge, the rabid Ood were anger and all of the patience and intelligence of the Ood Brain went into Ood Sigma.

Continuity

 * The Ood previously appeared in DW: The Impossible Planet / The Satan Pit
 * The Doctor refers to the time when he couldn't save the Ood from falling into the black hole in DW: The Satan Pit.
 * The Doctor comments that he visited the Sense-Sphere "ages ago". (DW: The Sensorites)
 * Massive brains had previously appeared in DW: The Brain of Morbius, DW: Time and the Rani and in NA: Deceit.
 * When the Doctor and Donna exit the TARDIS and see the Ood-Sphere for the first time, the Doctor comments that for once, he is glad to see it snow for real. During the new series, it has snowed four times, however it was only real snow in The Unquiet Dead. In The Christmas Invasion, the snow was the ash from the Sycorax ship breaking up in the atmosphere. In The Runaway Bride, the Doctor used the TARDIS to influence the Earth's atmosphere and force it to snow. Finally, in Voyage of the Damned, Mr. Copper tells the Doctor that the snow is really ballast from the Titanic as it flew over London. Ironically fake snow was used to film that scene in this episode.
 * The Third Doctor occasionally went by the name Doctor Noble.
 * In this episode, Donna tries to be friendly with the Ood, just like Rose befriended the Dalek in DW: Dalek and Martha befriended Hath Peck in DW: The Doctor's Daughter.
 * When the Ood say DoctorDonna this is actually a reference to Journey's End when Donna is a human but has the mind of the Doctor.
 * The song played as the Doctor and his companions tow Earth home is actually the Ood Song Journey's End.
 * Halpen calls Donna "ginger" because of her red hair, the newly regenerated Tenth Doctor was disapointed that he was wasn't ginger.(DW: The Christmas Invasion).

DVD Releases

 * Released in the Series 4 DVD boxset in November 2008 along with the rest of the Series.
 * Released as Series 4 Volume 1 in a vanilla edition alongside Partners in Crime and The Fires of Pompeii.
 * The BBFC has rated this story a 12 certificate citing a 'moderate gory scene'. Partners in Crime and The Fires of Pompeii were also both given PG certificates.