User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-1272640-20170101213115/@comment-24894325-20170122204606

Yes, I have a problem with that too. This is DWU. There are dozens of ways how a descendant of Compassion, who herself was first human and then TARDIS, could not be either human or TARDIS. Is it stated which Compassion Lolita is a descendant of? Is the descendancy process described in detail? If one individual can change species to TARDIS, why several generations of her descendants would necessarily belong to the same species?

I join TheChampionOfTime in believing that the best solution is to create parallel pages for everything that is not explicitly stated to belong to the rest of the DWU and provide copious notes in BHS sections of both the main page and the parallel page, explaining what is known and what is speculation.

Otherwise, we will get bogged down in conflicts such as an attempt to write Lolita in as a sister of The Doctor's TARDIS before it is even decided whether Lolita herself is a TARDIS at all.